3 ms·
This seems horribly biased against secp256k1. Basically all the disadvantages listed don’t apply to the standard implementation, libsecp256k1. The libsecp code
by adastra22 4y ago
This seems horribly biased against secp256k1. Basically all the disadvantages listed don’t apply to the standard implementation, libsecp256k1. The libsecp code is constant-time, deterministic, sidechannel resistant, is comparable in speed to ed25519, etc. it’s a solid piece of cryptographic engineering. But the author instead insists on comparing as if you’d be using the dumpster fire that is OpenSSL?
A non unity cofactor is a huge pill to swallow. Deployed production systems have been broken over this. Cutting off that entire attack surface from the start with just the cost of being a bit more obscure in your selection of implementation library is a reasonable tradeoff to make.