3 ms·
There are of course two ways of looking at this. One would be that the US chooses its engagements. Even given that, Korea (1950--53, within your 75 year windo
by dredmorbius 4y ago
There are of course two ways of looking at this.
One would be that the US chooses its engagements. Even given that, Korea (1950--53, within your 75 year window), Vietnam, and the Yugoslav war (in which the US was not a major participant but did contribute to the no-fly zone) were reasonably significant, involving Chinese and Russian forces and arms. The Iraq conflicts were not highly symmetric, but did involve threats to US forces, which the US mitigated. On balance, the US seems to treat even highly asymmetric opponents with respect as concerns their ability to inflict harm and damage, and seeks to minimise that.
Another is that even where it faces a highly asymmetric adversary, there are:
- A long and formidible force build-up.
- A preliminary air-superiority campaign in which any possible defences are neutralised.
- A concerted effort to maintain superiority.
I'd say it's a bit from A, a bit from B. But the clear lessons are that the U.S. values, and achieves, total air superiority. In the present conflict in Ukraine, Russia did not, and has not.
Technology has also clearly moved on. The major development of the aughts was in IEDs and remote attacks. To an extent, the US applied countermeasures here again via air and intelligence superiority, with reconnaissance which both detected in advance and replayed after successful attacks the placement and entities engaged in IED emplacements.
I've had discussions elsewhere over the characteristics of Switchblade drones, in particular their one-way "kamikazi" modes. I see two principle advantages:
- A one-way mission should nearly double range, and increase defended area by the square of the range.
- A returning low-speed munition would tend to invite return-fire on the launch point.
Since Switchblade and Phoenix Ghost drones are carried into the field by individual troops, increased mass, decreased range, and greater vulnerability of the deploying troops would all be strongly negative characteristics. My counterypart in that discussion was not convinced, though I find the rationale fairly strong.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y ago>My counterypart in that discussion was not convinced, though I find the rationale fairly strong. I also see drones primarily (and incredibly) useful for recon, but not for combat - we already have cruise missiles and guided artillery for that, and under wartime economy, they could be mass produced much cheaper than they are now
- dredmorbius 4y agoClearly both. But the combat results do appear impressive, both on the video-watching public and on Russian invading forces and their leadership, for whom plans appear to have significantly changed.