> If you can't be specific enough to be scientific about it, just keep it to yourself. This is some serious gatekeeping. A PhD student is an apprentice, on a p

> If you can't be specific enough to be scientific about it, just keep it to yourself. This is some serious gatekeeping. A PhD student is an apprentice, on a path to get scientific training. They are not yet trained enough, so that you could reasonable expect them to "be scientific" to a level of rigorous standards.