3 ms·
There are basically three good outcomes from CS PhD's: - Learn you like teaching / mentoring - Become trained to read and write world class research, and beco
by hedora 4y ago
There are basically three good outcomes from CS PhD's:
- Learn you like teaching / mentoring
- Become trained to read and write world class research, and become a world class engineer.
- Learn that you are great at marketing and networking, and become a professor or nontechnical exec somewhere (perhaps your own startup).
Obviously, the more of the above boxes you tick, the better (all three is the path to ACM Fellow / Turing Award), and they're not binary dimensions.
The author of the post seems to have failed utterly on the third point, perhaps due to Covid isolation.
The behavior of the professor in the story seems middling, but not terrible. They should have provided the student with more theoretically inclined contacts, while making it clear that quantum computers are almost real now, and a hands-on systems PhD is likely to be much more lucrative/impactful than closing some open, escoteric theoretical problems. (It sounds like this student joined a systems lab without understanding what systems research is.)
If the student really wanted a theory PhD, they'd still get support from the theoreticians the advisor should have found, and the advisor should have had enough confidence in the student to delegate, and allow that (perhaps misguided) line of work, or helped the student find a more appropriate advisor.
- walleeee 4y ago> quantum computers are almost real now in what sense is this true? practical quantum computers seem almost as far off as they were decades ago and NISQ appears to mean not large or reliable enough to do much with one consequence being people take option 3 and pad a career with speculative papers, too many of which are lacking in rigor QCs are "possible in principle" but remain a formidable engineering challenge in which we seem to be making rather slow headway
- hedora 4y agoIBM claims they'll be at 4096 bits in a couple of years. I agree "option 3 only" types are particularly problematic. They soak up funding and burn out students. It's hard to weed out professors for only being good at getting tenure and grants though.