3 ms·
I'm a huge fan of the JetBrains IDEs, and while I appreciate the thought of modernizing, I really don't like this approach. Their IDEs are extremely powerful a
by pedrovhb 4y ago
I'm a huge fan of the JetBrains IDEs, and while I appreciate the thought of modernizing, I really don't like this approach.
Their IDEs are extremely powerful and provide many useful tools, and hiding them behind meaningless icons or burying them deep in a smaller number of context menus doesn't do any favors for either discoverability or ease of use.
My understanding of simplified UI is that it's meant to be accessible and inclusive to those who have other priorities in life than to spend time learning about the technology and tools they have to use. As a professional developer though, I'm comfortable using computers. It's a core part of the job, and new developers will have to learn this too. It's not helpful to make the UI look prettier by increasing margins (and thus decreasing information density), and it's not helpful to hold our hands and put away the scary text and initially confusing features - on the contrary, that's limiting and counter-productive.
I pay for PyCharm, and if I liked VSCode better, I'd use that instead - it's free. I trust JetBrains enough to believe they won't completely replace the existing UI without giving us an option to keep using the current one, but I wish the resources going to developing this were spent in a different design direction or on other improvements.
- chrismeller 4y agoCame here to say exactly the same thing. If I wanted to use VSCode I would, making my JB product look and behave like VSCode is not something I’m interested in.
- tveyben 4y agoI really hope that JB is reading these spot on comments!
- SebastianKra 4y agoThis level of pointless conservatism frustrates me. I got to play around with it a bit. The only thing they simplified is the main toolbar [1]. Everything else is mostly shades of grey, icons and dimensions. A developer could upgrade to this and nothing would change. And yet, we have complaints about a "dumbed down" interface, that is wasting space [2], that JetBrains should "fire their design team", ... I'd love to see the age distribution of people complaining here because I personally had been hoping for this update. Design must be a balance between conservatism and progress and JetBrains nailed it in this case. [1] They even show you the shortcuts now, which you should have been using anyways. [2] The vertical space from the top of the window to the code is the _exact same_.