2 ms·
You are right about the lack of creativity in grammatical structures, but I assume that wherever you have said "you don't need X" you have meant that you should
by adrian_b 4y ago
You are right about the lack of creativity in grammatical structures, but I assume that wherever you have said "you don't need X" you have meant that you should not express X in the irregular ways typical for IE languages, but you should express X in a simple and regular way.
For example, a verb can be just a name of the action, without having multiple forms to express tenses, but then, whenever the action does not have the default tense and aspect, e.g. a present and habitual action, you must accompany the verb with some adverbial particle expressing the intended tense and aspect of the action.
In a similar way, a noun can have the meaning of one or more entities of some kind, of unknown gender. Whenever you have to express that there are 1, 2, few, many or another definite number of entities, or when you want to mention the gender, you should have to add to the noun a numeral or adjective expressing that information.
So you need to express tense, mood, aspect, number, gender, definiteness and so on, but it is possible to do this in a simpler and more systematic way than in any natural language.
Creating the large set of adverbial/adjectival particles that are required to express all these meanings, in such a way that all of them will be short, preferably monosyllabic, while being easy to pronounce and to remember, and while not suggesting undesirable meanings to the speakers of the most widespread natural languages, requires considerable creativity.
Simplifying the grammar would also get rid of a lot of redundancy that exists in the natural languages. In a time when the largest quantities of information are communicated in written form, that redundancy is no longer useful.
Nevertheless, in the original spoken form of the languages, the redundancy was more useful than today. For example, when listening to a story, one might already forget some details about what was said a little while before, so repeating a part of that information in the form of various kinds of agreements between words was more important than when reading the same story, when you can look back at the previous text line, when something is confusing.