9 ms·
HSBC exec suspended after comments about climate change
- raverbashing 5y agoThe Realpolitik of this is that it was likely some important clients/investors/VIP got too offended by it (preferably someone that invests in carbon-heavy industries for extra irony)
- WaxedChewbacca 5y agoLet's go look at the actual data. Here's the Florida measurement station that has the highest rate of sea level rise that I could find: https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_station.shtml?id=8726384 https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/sltrends_station.... > The relative sea level trend is 5.95 millimeters/year with a 95% confidence interval of +/- 0.89 mm/yr based on monthly mean sea level data from 1990 to 2021 which is equivalent to a change of 1.95 feet in 100 years. The press doesn't like to talk about actual measurements, because doing so destroys their scary stories.
- belter 5y agoCan't resist note the comment was made by the head of Responsible Investing :-)
- raxxorraxor 5y agoThis is probably the least offensive thing this particular bank has done. Leaks suggested it is basically a criminal organization in the heart of Britain and operating internationally. > head of responsible investing I cannot imagine the inside jokes for that position.
- belter 5y agoAs a Netflix series would be toned down as too outrageous :-) "History of HSBC controversies": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Controversies
- mytailorisrich 5y agoHe did not say anything irresponsible, quite the opposite. I suggest you watch his speech, which was actually very interesting. His quote about Miami is truncated in order to completely misrepresent it. As another commenter mentions, he actually said ""Who cares if Miami is six metres underwater in 100 years? Amsterdam has been six metres underwater for ages, and that’s a really nice place. We will cope with it." Remember that this was a speech on climate risk aimed at investment bankers. He did not deny or dismiss climate change, but expressed his opinion that the risk (mainly to the economy and financial markets) is much lower than usually claimed.
- JKCalhoun 5y ago> his opinion that the risk is much lower than usually claimed Like the storied automotive industry bean-counter that decides the lawsuits from fatalities will be cheaper than spending money on a more expensive part that is without some particular flaw. Otherwise I am not sure why the CEO of his company suspended him.
- jcrben 5y agoAnd how do you cope with the numerous species which will die, the coral reefs which are largely already dead, and the scorching heat waves causing a feedback loop to spin temperatures even higher? There's not one thing, and it's not easy to predict actually what will happen with this epic experiment.
- refurb 5y agoPlease describe the impact of dead coral reefs. I mean we cut down most of the trees on the East Coast at one point and the impact was? (And last I heard it was sunscreen killing them, not global warming).
- native_samples 5y agoThe coral reefs are not "largely already dead". They are actually in rude health with coverage being quite high lately: https://www.netzerowatch.com/peter-ridd-record-coral-cover-of-great-barrier-reef-refutes-climate-alarmists/ https://www.netzerowatch.com/peter-ridd-record-coral-cover-o...
- gadders 5y agoYou're probably better off watching the actual speech itself and seeing what you agree/disagree with: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfNamRmje-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfNamRmje-s
- belter 5y agoYou can start with this gold nugget: https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=100 https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=100
- jstx1 5y agoUsing the S&P500/MSCI World Index in these charts seems very disingenuous - they aren't supporting his argument, they just give off the sense of credibility if you aren't paying attention. He's going (A) "here's a chart" >> (B) "and this is my argument". But B doesn't follow from A at all, it just creates the impression of being evidence-based.
- bribri 5y agoSo basically he argues that climate change is not a financial risk that we need to worry about. Economies will continue to grow, and that adaptation will be key to mitigating the effects of climate change. He also argues that the market is already pricing in climate risk, and that the debate about climate change is distracting from more pressing financial risks.
- pera 5y agoWow this is way worse than what I could have imagined, the rhetoric of these people is going from "climate change is false" to "I don't give a shit, I'm rich and I will survive"
- alaricus 5y ago
- H8crilA 5y agoThis looks a bit like "financial autism" to me. The thing is the guy is right in a very strict sense - assuming risk premia typically associated with real estate it almost doesn't matter what happens in 100 years. There was even some research proving that the impact of future floodings is indeed correctly priced into the real estate market in the US. You can do that by connecting risk premia, prices, elevations over sea and climate change models. And I am calling it "autism" because so obviously you cannot say that to the general public, which will not care about your academic calculations :)
- fxtentacle 5y agoIt seems he was giving a presentation to investors who will most likely focus on the financial aspects, just like him. So to me, it seems the main issue is that his talk is being discussed out of context by the mainstream press, who were never the intended target audience.
- cheschire 5y agoGeneral question to the audience here. If this poster here had just said “financially retarded” that would be unacceptable, right? So in that same vein then, saying someone is performing an autistic act is generally insensitive and unacceptable, right?
- odessacubbage 5y agoit would be acceptable to describe situations in the market as 'schizophrenic' or 'bipolar' or 'crippling' so as an autist, i don't see this usage as particularly offensive.
- vegetablepotpie 5y agoI think it's a bit different because I'm sure the number of autistic people on this site vastly outnumber the amount of people anyone would call retarded. Therefore it's a bit of a self deprecating humor embedded in the GP comment. Reminiscent of WSB calling themselves apes and retards.
- MauranKilom 5y ago
- fxtentacle 5y agoI feel like they deliberately cut off the headline. He said: "Who cares if Miami is six metres underwater in 100 years? Amsterdam has been six metres underwater for ages, and that’s a really nice place. We will cope with it." And that sounds a lot more reasonable to me. He's not dismissing Miami as unimportant, but instead he is expressing his optimism in technical solutions for an environmental issue. Edit: It's in the video at 6:54 https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=414 https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=414 "Human beings have been fantastic at adapting to change, adapting to climate emergencies, and we will continue to do so. Who cares if Miami is six metres underwater in 100 years? Amsterdam has been six metres underwater for ages, and that’s a really nice place. We will cope with it."
- gregjw 5y agoWow, yeah, that totally flips around the context, shame on the clickbait.
- bowsamic 5y agoThat is somehow even worse
- belter 5y agoAre you really, really sure?: https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=100 https://youtu.be/bfNamRmje-s?t=100
- native_samples 5y agoI watched that section for a few minutes and saw nothing remarkable in anything he said. Are you really sure you aren't the kind of person he's criticizing? A summary of his comments would be: 1. Claims are over the top. There have been so many wrong claims of apocalypse that it's now really hard to get people's attention. "Most of you barely looked up from your phones at the prospect of non-survival - it's become so hyperbolic that nobody really knows how to get anyone's attention at all". He compares to the claims of gold bugs and about Y2K. 2. Climate activists generate far too much banking work given the time frames and nearer term problems. "We've got the China problem, a housing crisis looming, interest rates climbing, an inflation crisis, and I'm being told time and time again to spend time looking at something that's going to happen twenty or thirty years hence. The proportionality is out of whack". 3. At the moment, markets agree with him more or less. The more often the phrase "climate catastrophe" is mentioned in the press, the more valuable risk-associated assets become. In other words he feels like bankers have nearer term job related problems to be thinking about like the cost of living crisis, the lockdown induced recessions, and not claims the world is ending which, historically, have proven to be inaccurate as a general class. If you feel like these views justify firing or suspending people then you're the sort of person he's criticizing. Edit: Here's a summary of the rest of his arguments. 1. People claiming the world is going to end need to either present arguments for why the market is mispricing everything despite millions of participants, or, why there's going to be a massive boom if climate risk is 'solved'. But currently they don't do that, they're implicitly arguing that the market is seriously mispriced, without actually stating so directly. 2. IPCC figures for actual impact of climate change are surprisingly low, on the order of 5% by 2100. However even if you accept those figures, by 2100 the economy may easily be 1000% larger, so a 5% difference would not be noticeable. Also GDP growth is perhaps over-rated in terms of importance: growth has completely stopped in the recent past and it was OK. 3. People often make misleading claims about extreme weather increasing, without noting that weather related deaths and costs have all been trending downwards significantly. Thus not only dry financial/economic metrics seem impacted in only low ways, but also 'lifestyle' metrics. Humans have been pretty fantastic at adaptation and there's no reason to assume this will change. 4. "I don't doubt the science at all". California's fire budget is only 1% of their state budget, or .1% of their GDP. If economic growth continues as expected, even with more fires, that is solvable through adaption. 5. We spend way too much on mitigation financing and not enough on adaptation financing. 6. There's a difference between volumes and prices (this seems like a technical financial argument), e.g. revenues can fall without profits/prices changing because there's an indirect relationship. There will be winners and losers whose share prices go up and down, during green transitions there's going to be both and it's possible to build portfolios around both. E.g. at the moment coal indexes are outperforming renewables, but it's been different in the past and things will swing back and forth. 7. "Even if climate risk isn't negligible it's too far in the future to matter for most companies". This is again a technical point related to the priorities of bankers. He says company valuations don't really go beyond 20 years. Avg loan length is 6 years. Even if you assume the "Sharons and the Mark Carneys" of the world are totally right about everything and the world ends in fire and destruction in 30 years (not sure who Sharon is but seems to be a prior presenter), then from the perspective of a banker it doesn't matter because it's still too far in the future to actually be important for day to day financial activities. 8. He criticizes central banks for spending far too much time on climate risk instead of things they're meant to be thinking about like inflation and asset prices. 9. One climate risk that markets may not be pricing is the possibility of a giant unexpected carbon tax. Many claims by central banks about climate risk being high, are in reality when you check the fine print of the models, actually modelling implausible economic growth dynamics and massive interest rate shocks, which they then present as "climate risk" to make headlines. This isn't reported and he feels central banks are manipulating models in order to make headlines. 10. If we'd tried to model climate risk in the 1920s with today's knowledge of climate science, they'd have got it totally wrong as they'd never have predicted deindustrialization, the impact of greener technology etc. 11. Conclusion, summary of argument: humans are extremely good at managing change. We need to be less doom-mongering and re-focus / re-gain perspective on what investment bankers should be focused on. We need to not be caught out by opportunities like Tesla, and there's lots of investment opportunities in the green transition. Overall his talk is not even debating or doubting climatological sciences or predictions at any point. It is mostly about what bankers should be doing with their time.
- bribri 5y ago"We will all be six feet under by then, so who cares?"
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI think the wealthy are convinced that in fact they'll be standing on our shoulders, but I digress.
- jhugo 5y agothe rest: "... Amsterdam has been six metres underwater for ages, and that’s a really nice place. We will cope with it." I think he's making a pretty decent point, but "who cares" is probably the worst way to start that sentence if you don't want to get fired.
- armada651 5y agoOnly a decent point if you don't care about Amsterdam. I would very much appreciate if Amsterdam wasn't under water in 100 years.
- jhugo 5y agoIt's already below sea level and only mildly damp, I don't imagine it will be under water in 100 years. The point is about human adaptation and ability to find technological solutions, not about whether you care about the specific cities.
- armada651 5y agoWhy rely on human ingenuity in 100 years to cope with the effects, when we can use the same inginuity right now to prevent it?
- jhugo 4y agoBecause maybe we can't! Many scientists think we are already too late to stop fairly major climate change. So the sane solution is surely to do both. Nothing that the guy was quoted saying in OP says that we shouldn't do anything proactive about climate change.
- cube00 5y agoThis is sadly a common sentiment https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2015/sep/11/peter-dutton-jokes-with-tony-abbott-about-rising-sea-levels-in-pacific-nations https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2015/sep/11/peter...
- bambax 5y agoThere's a cartoon that shows dinosaurs looking at the sky, at an incoming comet. One of them asks "Is it priced in?" This describes our situation quite well.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI think it's best of people just watch his speech because it is highly misrepresented: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfNamRmje-s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bfNamRmje-s Bear in mind that this was part of a series of speeches on investment climate risk for an audience of investment bankers. He does not deny climate change at all but takes an optimistic view on our abilities to adapt and states his opinion that risks are much lower than claimed (again that means risks to the economy and markets). Nothing irresponsible not outrageous, just an on-topic, supported, opinion. I found his speech very interesting.
- donohoe 5y agoClimate change is not just about sea-change, and this exec over-simplifies the issue here too. In addition to sea-change we can expect parts of the world become uninhabitable, there there will be further food scarcity. As a result there will expect displacement and more countries competing for limited resources. The mass exodus of people already creates political and economic issues which we are already seeing today. When I read about this exec, I am reminded of this New Yorker cartoon: https://i0.wp.com/www.derekchristensen.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/shareholdervalue.jpg?w=1880&ssl=1 https://i0.wp.com/www.derekchristensen.com/wp-content/upload...
- vegetablepotpie 5y agoStuart Kirk was suspended for the speech he gave. This was not an impromptu speech. I would be surprised if no one in the company reviewed it before it was given. Either this was a big miscalculation by the company, or HSBC wanted an excuse to fire Mr. Kirk. Either way, it was very tone deaf. Sadly I think the firing will have a negative impact climate action from society. When this story escapes financial news and into the mainstream media, the narrative will be that woke activists cancel executive for wrong think, and partisan passions will boil over.
- Bubble_Pop_22 5y agoThe only problem that I have is that this guy was fired and now will for sure go into politcs, whereas his skills and his ability to question everything are needed in Africa , South East Asia etc. He is right there is plenty of money to be made and developing countries could use Westerners who are sick of this climate paranoia. Westerners bringing their skills to developing countries + local governemnt which has no qualms about reporting bogus CO2 emissions numbers = the hypergrowth that developing countries deserved for centuries. You don't need to argue there, risking your job...it's the governemnt policy to under-report CO2. As the West castrates itself, demographically, financially and energy-wise... finally Africa will rise.
- p09ss 5y ago
- refurb 5y agoBurn the heretic! In every age science is threatened by heresy, and heresy is bound up in false doctrine. It is the desire of all heretics to minimize the importance of doctrine. When doctrine is minimized, heresy can exercise itself without restraint.
- belter 5y agoThese are the consequences Worldwide when Miami is six meters under water...more or less. https://coastal.climatecentral.org/map/6/-75.8798/27.975/?theme=water_level&map_type=water_level_above_mhhw&basemap=roadmap&contiguous=true&elevation_model=best_available&refresh=true&water_level=6.0&water_unit=m https://coastal.climatecentral.org/map/6/-75.8798/27.975/?th...
- shapefrog 5y agoI dont want to be that guy - but really is that all?
- belter 4y agoDid you browse a little bit? Half of Florida is gone. That is a migration of 10 million people just for one US State.
- shapefrog 4y agoYes I did - I zoomed out and looked all over the world. 6M is a dramatic increase in sea level I would have expected huge areas of land mass to be gone globally and that source suggests a fraction of a percentage point of land mass lost globally.
- Proven 5y ago