2 ms·
Reproducibility of the First Image of a Black Hole from the EHT Collaboration
- belter 5y ago[PDF]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2205.10267.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2205.10267.pdf "...Based on the artifacts made available by EHT, we deliver documentation, code, and a computational environment to reproduce the first image of a black hole. Our deliverables support new discovery in multi-messenger astrophysics by providing all the necessary tools for generalizing methods and findings from the EHT use case. Challenges encountered during the reproducibility of EHT results are reported. The result of our effort is an open-source, containerized software package that enables the public to reproduce the first image of a black hole in the galaxy M87..." The Docker Image: https://hub.docker.com/repository/docker/globalcomputinglab/reproducibility-eht https://hub.docker.com/repository/docker/globalcomputinglab/...
- belter 5y agoThis work is an interesting step in providing the means to allow non specialists to reproduce the first image of a black hole in the galaxy M87. From the point of view of reproducibility of the scientific results would like to note the following: The paper focus on the technical aspects of the pipeline. From the 10 authors of the paper, 9 are Computer Science experts, under the mentorship, I presume, of the Charles Brightman Professor of Physics at Syracuse University a member of the LIGO Scientific Collaboration. From what I could gather, none of the authors is active in the Astrophysics of Black Holes or a specialist in VLBI with the probable exception of Professor D. A. Brown. Very recently, a team of Japanese Astrophysics and VLBI experts from RIKEN, one of the premier Astrophysics labs in Japan, published a paper submitted to The Astrophysical Journal. The paper has different conclusions than the EHT collaboration, and argues the detected 40 µas ring structure is an effect of sampling bias in the EHTC’s processes "Jet and resolved features of the central black hole M87 observed with EHT": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31383250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31383250 As far as I know the EHT team did not provide yet a response to the paper by the Japanese researchers. That is understandable, but hopefully one will come soon, due to the media visibility to the scientific results presented by the EHT Collaboration.