4 ms·
Patients keep getting charged for crying
- ddingus 4y agoThis is unbridled greed playing out in a negative way between doctor and a patient. Just because something can be done does not mean it should be done. That said, keep doing it! These stories have real legs! Catch and spread nicely enough to be highly effective universal health care advocacy. Personally, there is absolutely no way I would allow stuff like this to happen. I bet many physicians are busy and do not review billing to the degree our current policy requires them to. One would think fear of this discussion happening would be right at the top of a short list titled: "bad things are likely to happen"
- usednet 4y agoJust reading the article and remembering my last hospital visit gives me a headache. I got better treatment in Tunisia than at an American hospital in a wealthy area. What an embarrassment for us being the only developed country without universal healthcare.
- username_my1 4y agoI mean even with public health system you still will have private hospitals The problem here is the excessive charging itself. Or the fact that they can think they can do it.
- didibus 4y agoThat's not always the case, and is a choice to still allow private hospitals or not and in what capacity. In Quebec for example all hospitals are public and you can't have a private hospital. In the rest of Canada, hospitals are required to be not-for-profit, though they are still private, you can't have a for-profit private hospital.
- ProfXponent 4y agoAgreed, the US healthcare system is a joke. I’m a US citizen living abroad and my biggest fear is getting sick when I go home to visit family.
- fzeroracer 4y agoThis is one of the reasons why I've been seeking opportunities outside of the US. I saw my parents go bankrupt over healthcare bullshit and I refuse to let that happen to me.
- ProfXponent 4y agoCannot recommend this enough. Life becomes a lot easier once you leave that failing state.
- bumblebritches5 4y ago
- a-dub 4y agoi suspect that maybe there's been a mental health push in recent years with the onset of the pandemic and doctors are simply making notes of these events in the emr without any thought that it would show up on a billing statement. how it goes from well intentioned healthcare initiative to showing up as a billing item on patient statements remains an exercise to the reader.
- madaxe_again 4y agoI find that very unlikely. I know far too many people who went into medicine. They were all doing it because their fathers were doctors (sorry, consultants, maybe a lowly surgeon or two), and they too wanted the nine bedroom country manor and six cars. People enter medicine for the money, maybe a little for the prestige. This is nowhere more self-evident that in their billing practices - and the fact that most medics seem to be always operating at the absolute edge of their competence and have nothing but unbridled contempt for patients. Not exactly symptomatic of “I care” so much as “I charge”. Same with lawyers and bankers. Unimaginative, lucrative, “follow in thy father’s footsteps” professions full of avaricious dullards.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- menacingly 4y agoCivilization at scale is very difficult. It seems to have something in common with software. Naive ideological purity produces folksy, approachable solutions that fail to address just enough edge cases as to not function past a certain point. The more I encounter scale, the more terrified I am of it. We don't seem to have any great answers. I spent my youth frustrated that the suits were going to complicate my elegant simplicity, that some series of meetings would pile on needless complexity, but the miserable truth is they aren't exactly wrong. Sentences that begin with "Why don't we just-" are usually fatally shortsighted. Startups that appear to have finally cut through the burdensom red tape of the crusty establishment are doomed to become their parents: at scale, they start to do what they were fighting in the first place. Google looks like Google for a reason. We love a fresh start, because we see in it the promise of a new take, someone applying the simplicity to a problem we intuitively feel is there, but sooner or later they must face the meat grinder of scale. I hope it isn't true that processes must trend toward the absurd, that patently outlandish medical billing is the fate that awaits us all.
- ProfXponent 4y agoLet’s not pretend that American problems apply to the rest of the world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- monkeydreams 4y agoI work in Australian healthcare systems and can tell you that this situation does apply to the rest of the world, although the charging usually occurs to the public purse rather than the other way around. The problem is that these activity/diagnostic/lifestyle codes exist for good reasons but existing incentives can push diagnostic coders toward exploitation for maximum funding rather than as a tool for capturing treatment burdens.
- Grimburger 4y agoThe US spends dramatically more than every other OECD country. It's not even slightly comparable. They are the clear outlier on Earth. https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/healthres/health-spending.htm
- foogazi 4y agoA) Hospital is overcharging B) OTOH - don’t cry and you save $40 C) Devil’s advocate: It says emotional assessment. If someone is under emotional distress the hospital has to do an assessment and see if they are getting enough medication or there are other problems: abuse, depression, etc.