3 ms·
Well, there's "just a bit odd" as in Dan Aykroyd and there's "just a bit odd" as in Christian Weston Chandler. Even within the verbal "high functioning" band, t
by bitwize 4y ago
Well, there's "just a bit odd" as in Dan Aykroyd and there's "just a bit odd" as in Christian Weston Chandler. Even within the verbal "high functioning" band, the autism spectrum is still a spectrum.
And it really is a social disability, not a superpower. We really only display advantages in things we train ourselves to be proficient in, which tend to he things that do not bore or frustrate us because of other people's expectations of us. I got proficient in computers because a computer was host to a tiny world in which I had absolute control. But a sufficiently motivated allistic person could get just as proficient in this field as I. In fact the advantage has swung back toward allistics because the MBAs have taken over computing as a profession, and through Agile, Scrum, and other methodologies and "best practices" enforce it as something to be practiced on their terms.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThat’s why I’m working on my own, these days, I guess. Not so sure “sufficiently motivated” folks could just learn this. I have what I call my “fugue state.” It’s a fairly “timeless,” focused, self-centered state, where “everything flows.” I get a lot done, when in this state, but many hours can go by, and it’s exhausting. I couldn’t describe what I’m doing, to save my life. In fact, the best way to break it, is to ask me what I’m doing. I stutter, grope for words, mumble, etc. I can write detailed, articulate code documentation, explaining it, but I can’t verbalize it. I sound like a blithering idiot. I would not do well, with pair programming. I also get pissed when I’m yanked from that state. I get quite cranky. Lasts for about half an hour, afterwards. That kind of thing makes it hard to play well with others. When I was a manager, I didn’t have that issue.
- webmaven 4y ago> Not so sure “sufficiently motivated” folks could just learn this. Pretty sure the ability is there in most people. Not that many do it, but the potential is there. All too many people are disengaged and trapped into apathy by their experiences. > I have what I call my “fugue state.” It’s a fairly “timeless,” focused, self-centered state, where “everything flows.” I get a lot done, when in this state, but many hours can go by, and it’s exhausting. Yup. That state was dubbed "flow" by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi in 1975: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology) Among "normies" flow seems to often have a physical activity component, and is more common among athletes, musicians, artists, surgeons, and similar professions. Many gamers would recognize themselves in your description as well. The more purely mental version you experience is less common, though it isn't restricted to pursuits like math or coding. Writers (of types as diverse as journalists and fiction authors) can experience it too, for example. > I also get pissed when I’m yanked from that state. I get quite cranky. Lasts for about half an hour, afterwards. Oh my yes. I can get cranky enough to lose the whole rest of the day. Also note that the writer that gets cranky when interrupted is practically a trope. It is worth noting that a state of flow, while extremely productive, may not be the best state for improving your skill (although it does allow polishing skills smooth, as it were), which is better served by deliberate practice of activities that are a just bit too challenging to allow entering the flow state (if they are harder than "a bit too hard", it may help to do it at half speed, which can feel a bit wierd for something like coding). > That kind of thing makes it hard to play well with others. When I was a manager, I didn’t have that issue. Well, there is such a thing as "team flow" but it doesn't seem to be cultivated deliberately much outside of team sports, improv, and group music. Something similar can occur in group brainstorming sessions, though.
- bitwize 4y ago> Among "normies" flow seems to often have a physical activity component, and is more common among athletes, musicians, artists, surgeons, and similar professions. Who's to say it doesn't among programmers? One of the reasons why I vastly prefer mechanical keyboards is because their feedback smooths out the process of typing in flow state. It requires less mental effort to type on a mechanical, which means flow is less likely to get disrupted. Plus I can feel the rhythm of the keys beneath my fingers, and rhythms help keep my brain on track.
- webmaven 4y agoThat's interesting. Do you have data on whether the tactile or auditory feedback is more important?
- Jensson 4y ago> That kind of thing makes it hard to play well with others. When I was a manager, I didn’t have that issue. I'd suspect you just have adhd and not autism. But psychologists are just humans like everyone else and hears "social problems" and sets out to match anything you have to autism criteria, even though the person obviously isn't autistic. The other things you talk about just maps to adhd as well, like being easily distracted, super focus on things you care about.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have close family with ADHD (I used to steal their Ritalin, when we were kids). They are also a damn good engineer (hardware), but much better with people. Think Jon Bernthal and Ben Affleck, except as geeks, instead of badasses, and without the cool Airstream.