7 ms·
MasterCard to launch biometric checkout tool for retailers
- mc4ndr3 4y agoNot Content with Owning your Data, Corporations Seek to own your Body
- charcircuit 4y agoKnowing what you look like is different than owning you.
- walterbell 4y agoNecessary but not sufficient.
- hedora 4y agoYou're not without representation. If you don't like the actions of CEOs, you should have run against them in an election. - The US Supreme Court (more or less)
- capableweb 4y agoReads like a press-release directly from MasterCard. Is there any proper articles on the technology that doesn't read like it wants to sell something to me?
- dfxm12 4y agoGiving away biometric data like this seems like a very poor trade-off compared to just pulling out your phone or card. More secure? More hygienic? Come on...
- KennyBlanken 4y agoAny arguments about security they make are pretty weak given how badly they screwed the pooch on NFC. It's comically bad. Stuff like "oh, it's cool, we'll just trust the device to auth the user", allowing NFC to have a higher spend limits, readers using the same seed for encrypted sessions...
- guerrilla 4y agoWhat now, this sounds terrible. I'll have to read up on it.
- Nextgrid 4y agoMasterCard and most other card networks are happy to shift fraud liability onto the banks and/or merchants. Why should I care as a user that the system is technically insecure if I’m not actually put at risk? I also don’t see the problem with your own device authenticating you - I trust my device more than a random terminal onto which I’m supposed to type a PIN. When it comes to spend limits, this is primarily down to merchants - they are in control of their terminals and can choose to reject (or ask for additional auth - mobile contactless + PIN is technically possible for example) any method if it doesn’t fit their risk appetite. Most merchants choose to allow even completely insecure methods (card-based contactless with no CVM) because in practice the convenience for the prospective shoppers offsets the cost of fraud.
- maccard 4y agoThe security on a card is really via policy, not via technical security. It doesn't matter how secure your encryption is if you are susceptible to a wrench attack [0]. As long as the bank accepts liability for NFC payments while vehemently denying any liability if you share your pin, it doesn't really matter how technically good their security is. [0] https://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- r0snd0 4y ago
- lxgr 4y agoWhat specific vulnerabilities are you referring to?
- cm2187 4y agoPlus I suspect you will still need to pull your card. Biometrics sort of work when you are trying to match one user with one face (authenticate on a computer). But if you are searching a face among a billion users, you will get false positives, not the least because of twins. So you still need a way to tell your ID to the system.
- usrn 4y agoBiometrics have to be the biggest meme in security maybe behind anti-virus software.
- grapescheesee 4y agoWait, you dont run multiple anti virus software?
- jchw 4y agoFingerprint authentication for unlocking personal devices seems alright to me. It works well on my laptop, as an alternative to typing the password, and makes it easier to stomach my rather aggressive auto-locking settings. (And with fprint on Linux, you get quite a bit of control over exactly what and how fingerprint based auth works, using PAM.) Facial recognition, on the other hand, is annoying as hell. Apple Face ID is seemingly one of the better systems, but I’ve used Windows Hello as well as Face ID and I can honestly say I hate both of them. They’re both solutions to problems I really do not believe anyone had. Like a lot of other “magic” security primitives such as passive proximity keys, facial authentication systems fail to validate intent. Fingerprint sensors are also a lot worse than passwords in this regard, but facial recognition authentication is absolutely ridiculous. I can accidentally unlock Windows Hello from halfway across the room. If my cat is about to walk on my laptop, I would like to lock the screen, but if Windows Hello is enabled, tough shit, as the moment keys are pressed it will try to find your face and unlock. At least Face ID tries very hard to ensure you’re looking at the device; if Windows Hello is trying to ensure that, it is not doing a good job. There’s hardly anything I can do to prevent the laptop from accidentally unlocking. Fingerprint authentication is still not ideal, so I think it should be limited to things that don’t need as much physical security. I think that it’s fair to say sudo prompts and screen unlocking are decent candidates. Even in the case where you have very advanced adversaries, at a certain point I wager the weakest link is going to be something else, and you are going to want to try to keep them physically separated from the machines if you want to stand a chance. Then again, I’m not a security person. That said, I think anti-virus is still a bigger meme.
- mistrial9 4y ago
- throwoutway 4y agoNo thank you. I will not use these and I hope both city councils and legislative bodies ban them from use
- bsnal 4y ago
- cute_boi 4y agoThe problem is there are thousands of unaware or complacent people who gives their data easily. And, it doesn't matter if 2% of people grouse and complain over issue. If enough people use it, then many people are forced to use it whether its good or bad. Also, don't expect politician to fix such issue because they themselves probably think its good due to "security"
- walterbell 4y agoNYC, SF and a few other US cities have banned cashless stores, so all is not lost. As long as there's a choice to use cash, digital alternatives will have to compete against reality rather than narratives. USD in circulation continues to increase: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CURRCIR https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CURRCIR
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago
- rdtwo 4y agoSecurity is for them not for you. Their 3D secure system is already quite annoying
- qgin 4y agoHonest question, what's the worst thing that could result from MasterCard having a hash of my handprint?
- savant_penguin 4y agoThere will be no situation in which a mugger could get something from you Don't have your card/phone on you? No worries! We can still force your hand to withdraw money
- stu2b50 4y agoIs the idea that they chop your hand off? If it's just that they hold a gun to your head and make you authenticate with your palm, then they can do that right now. Once the gun is to the head you're kinda compelled to do what they're saying regardless of whether you authenticate with biometrics, password, whatever.
- EvanAnderson 4y agoIn the town where I live we have a murderer (alleged, admittedly) who cut off his victim's thumb to access the victim's phone: https://www.daytondailynews.com/crime/bail-set-at-15m-for-troy-man-accused-of-killing-roommate/GIHYQB5EYVDRHPG7RH6BJ7RPE4/ https://www.daytondailynews.com/crime/bail-set-at-15m-for-tr...
- andsoitis 4y agoThe first paragraph also says he killed the other guy. Even if he didn’t cut off his thumb…
- savant_penguin 4y agoThe idea is that even if someone points a gun at you they can't do anything to you immediately if you don't have a phone or a credit card with you (as far as I know anyway). But with biometrics no matter what precautions you take, you'll always be in a position to give people your stuff by force
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sergiomattei 4y agoNo thanks.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoyou should seriously look at how "UPI" from india works. its fee-less, offers the same protection and maybe more becuase you have to actively accept/decline payment and they can even set up stuff like autopay mandate and all. its tied to your mobile number AND your phone so it "might" not appeal to everyone but still, there are banks who offer it over their internet banking channels so the tech can be used in a browser setting which does help. There is already existing "fraud protection" mandated to banks so its not like the whole "mastercard does that so they need their share". they don't and india is slowly transitioning AWAY from plastic. this is a "gimmick" i suppose because UPI apps already support using your phone authentication to confirm a payment so yeah...... mastercard does not get this data and they want to make it "cool" to lull banks into shoving the cards down their customers' throats
- no_time 4y ago>smile into a camera or wave their hand over a reader to pay. The difference between "please drink the verification can" 4chan copypasta and real life is a few years apparently.
- square_usual 4y agoA month short of nine years ago. It wasn't that far-fetched at the time; it was written in the context of the Xbox, which could identify players using the Kinect.
- i_like_waiting 4y agoI wouldn't mind to have that option. Issue is that in sake of optimization, there are hardly any options in majority of categories. Even 1/3 of small fintech startups are tied strictly to unrooted android/ iOS. Just because my phone is rooted, I cannot use them as they don't even have browser option. Same with supermarkets pushing card and having 1 tile (out of 10) for cash.
- Perenti 4y agoHmmm.... so what is recorded to enable later verification? Saved video? Saved eigenvectors/values? And What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
- sexy_panda 4y agoAt some point we will have DNA scanner checkouts. [1] [1] https://youtu.be/S-909qc-9rY?t=32 https://youtu.be/S-909qc-9rY?t=32
- welcome_dragon 4y agoI find "smile to pay" very dystopian. It's been shown that the physical act of smiling can improve mood, so I don't think it's much of a stretch that someone at MasterCard said "hey what if we condition people to enjoy using their credit/debit card?"