4 ms·
Real estate is going to be gutted - increasing mortgage rates (already have been happening) will decimate qualified buyers. Decreasing prices will further decim
by lazide 4y ago
Real estate is going to be gutted - increasing mortgage rates (already have been happening) will decimate qualified buyers. Decreasing prices will further decimate those willing to Hail Mary with cash offers hoping to get something after years of frustration.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoBut the effective, on-the-ground housing shortage is going to continue to keep demand for housing extremely high in almost all areas with reasonable economic options or amenity migration destinations.
- neilparikh 4y agoWouldn't this demand be priced into existing housing prices though (and thus not be worth acting on)?
- lazide 4y agoThe only reason there is a housing shortage is because there is an excess of jobs and money in that place. Which is changing. Houses in sunnyvale went from 750k-1m and impossible to find one for sale to 350k (yes really!) and on the market for years around ‘08.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> "an excess of jobs and money in that place" Nope. For one thing, there's the largest generation of the 20th century at peak retirement, cashing out of family houses that have gained huge amounts of value, and looking to move to amenity-rich locations. For another thing, the investment industry, short of other options, has started buying houses to rent them (short or long term), squeezing supply and driving up prices in many markets. For another thing, short term rentals (AirBnb, VRBO etc.) have had profound impacts on the availability of property in heavily visited areas (in fact, it's not so much absolute visitation rates, but vists-per-resident that characterizes this). Other factors too. That doesn't mean the market can't crash, but it will be something very different from what happened in 2008.
- lazide 4y agoAll of the effects you name are only happening because of inflated values driven by cheap money. Literally every, single, one of them.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoSorry, I find this ridiculous. The boomers heading into retirement situation is a reflection of 40-50 years of economic policy and has no connection with recent "cheap money". Actual investment in single family and apartment housing is almost entirely tied to its low risk/return ratio compared with (the perception of a lack of) other options for investment at this time. The money sloshing around for investment is as much as function of the effective privatization of retirement funding as anything else. The short term rental market is in part the perfect expression of how a relativel small number of wealthy individuals can totally distort a market to follow their own preferences, and reflects income/wealth inequality and lack of regulatory enforcement (they're freakin' B&B's people!) as much as anything else. Cheap money has almost nothing to do with any of them.
- lazide 4y agoThe ‘cheap money’ issue isn’t a short term one. It’s been steadily dropping with only minor hiccups since the mid 80’s - about 40 years ago. The last time the US had a inflation hit, at that time due to the Oil crisis. Mostly to keep juicing the economy, which has steadily been needing it more and more to grow/less responsive to stimulus. Folks I know who have done the AirBnB route were often getting mortgages and buying properties to let out, using the short term cash flows to pay the (low interest rate) mortgage. Which makes sense as an investment, because the mortgage was cheap (cheap money) compared to current cash flows. It has become more and more pervasive, until it stopped being able to make money due to saturation. Younger folks traveling around during Covid using AirBNBs helped (they were trying to avoid lockdowns and ‘dirtier’ hotels), but not sure how it is going to play out now. Anyone who had a 30 year mortgage they got then is going to do pretty fine though as long as they have cash flow.
- rcpt 4y ago> an excess of jobs and money And speculation. Bay Area has the highest price to rent ratios in the US. Rent really hasn't changed that much since 2020 and if the betting stops it'd make sense to go back to 2020 prices (which is like a 50% "crash" in parts of the Bay)
- deanmoriarty 4y agoI would so much welcome a 50% crash but I’m afraid we’ll never ever see it in the Bay Area. There are just too many people, job or not, in a very strong financial position. I’m sitting on $600k+ cash for a down payment and if I see townhouses correcting I’ll snatch one up immediately. And I am a very small fish compared to the wealth that’s around. My personal bet is that the Bay Area will just stay at 0% growth until the market recovers.
- lazide 4y agoPossible, we’ll see. A lot of speculators also bought assuming increasing property values, so if it’s flat for 5 years or whatever, then that’s going to nuke their gains. Meanwhile they’re paying out real cash every month.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThe return from a mortgage-free rental is not bad in most places. Property value increases in nice, but not critical for such "speculation".
- lazide 4y agoYup, good point! The rental market in many previously hot areas (SF, South Bay) has taken a hit, but not sure where it will land long term. Medium term there is a LOT less pressure with a lot of techies having relocated and remote work being accepted. Don’t forget though that anyone who is a ‘bigger fish’ (looking to invest many millions or half a billion or so) in a high inflation environment is going to be looking for as sure a bet they can with as high a return they can. And since money isn’t as cheap anymore, those are easier to find and get. So while it may not be bad returns, it may be bad returns compared to something else (a new business, for instance).
- rcpt 4y agoThat governs rent. But what we've seen with COVID is huge jumps in price to rent ratios.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoIt'll make housing even more expensive in 10 years as builders will be decimated like in 2008, we won't build housing for half a decade, and a new generation will look for housing while boomers sit on their 80% vacant 4bd houses they paid 1/5 of the current market price for.
- lazide 4y agoIn another 10 years most of the boomers will be dead.
- kortilla 4y agoThat’s not how life expectancy works.
- killjoywashere 4y agoYou're arguing that those who survived this long will survive more than 10 years. I mean, yes, but 1) food in this economy is still delicious so heart disease is still the cause of 50% of deaths, and 2) humans only have one copy of p53 from each parent, so everyone dies of cancer if Heart disease or <random> doesn't get them first. Given 1 and 2, the boomers are on their way out. My mom (born 1953) might make it another 20 years, but my dad (born 1945) is living on borrowed time (20 pk-yr history and cancer).
- lazide 4y agoIt is how actuarial tables work. Baby boomers in 2032 will be between 68 and 86 years old, and mortality increases rapidly up to and including those years. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1464018/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1464018/]
- robocat 4y agoWrong. 71 million alive in 2019 of 76 million born[0]. If the oldest boomer is 76 now, their life expectancy is over 10 years[1]. Most boomers have more years life expectancy than that i.e. most boomers will live longer than 10 years. And in a couple one will live longer, perhaps not releasing a house. Aside: most people mentioning “boomers” normally are saying something offensive - similar to making inane stereotypical comments about disabled people as an example. The term is very American-centric, and in my country the word mostly is used offensively. We mostly don’t know what gen__ means either. Edit: 25% of boomers don’t own a home. Today, white millennials are almost three times as likely as Black millennials to own their homes. If you are white, then every time you make a comment about a group that has it better off than you, lookout behind you. Goes double for complaints about the wealthy if you live in the US: you are the wealthy from the point of view of most people in the world. Disclaimer: I am not a boomer. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers [1] https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html https://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html