7 ms·
Details on AMD's Quirky Chipset Solutions for AM5
- formerly_proven 4y agoInteresting to note that, just from memory, this means most of the increased I/O possibilities actually come from the CPU itself, not the chipset. 2x7 W also means that chipset power remains pretty much the same compared to X570, though two chips will lend themselves better to effective passive cooling.
- ridgered4 4y agoYeah, there's a lot to be said about the daisy chain but the real news for me here was that 4 CPU lanes are added from last generation. I personally would rather they be used for a m.2 slot than a thunderbolt controller and hopefully they will in some boards. (I don't see the point of thunderbolt on a desktop) While the daisy chain is interesting, it doesn't sound like it gets you much at the end of the day and will double power usage (which was a real sore spot with x570 vs the asmedia chipsets) The dual chipset sort of seems like it's just a luxury item without a purpose in most cases. Maybe we'll see some interesting designs with server oriented boards but doubling the power usage doesn't seem worth what it will get you to me.
- glowingly 4y agoSounds like a decent approach. On the current AM4 setup, the chipset had an x8 link allocated (at least in dmi), but only x4 was ever hooked up. Based on information here, too bad they weren't able to build on that and avoid the daisy chain setup altogether (x4 direct to each "southbridge").
- _carbyau_ 4y agoI thought the length of board traces were part of the reasoning against that idea. If you could have your CPU placed symmetrically in the middle of the board with slots, ports etc both above and below so they don't get too long traces then maybe? But that would go against the ATX spec. I also wonder how often communication happens from one device direct to another without touching CPU? Is that a thing? DMA has been a thing for many years but with the memory controller on the CPU communications would still have to get there.
- bpye 4y agoPeer to peer DMA is a thing, though I don't know enough about PCI to say how it works on this sort of topology.
- AaronFriel 4y agoWhat an unusual departure from their previous generation. The prosumer and just-below HEDT market loved the Ryzen chips for their generous amount of PCIe lanes. The x670 looks to - confusingly - reduce CPU-available lanes/slots and risk contention on the chipset for peripherals and storage. No one will want to debug a daisy chained M.2 or USB 4.0 connection suddenly slowing down. If true and it's also true that the non-Pro Threadripper line is gone, this leaves a large gap for Intel to exploit with Alder Lake X. The Threadripper line's 60+ lanes of PCIe effectively took over the HEDT market. Intel not only couldn't compete on performance, but for storage arrays, ML workstations, other important niches, they were the only viable option. I'm hoping the rumors of Threadripper's demise are wrong, and both Intel & AMD are able to compete in the space. That's best for consumers, not this alternating pendulum. (See: Threadripper price hikes.)
- zamadatix 4y agoThreadripper/HEDT is a different line, socket, and chipset. This is for the consumer stuff and looks to have the same number of CPU direct lanes as last generation, just higher speed.
- AaronFriel 4y agoI am aware and I believe I accurately described first these rumored changes to the Ryzen line, and second the rumored cutting of the consumer Threadripper line. Is there some way I could edit my comment to make it clearer? > This is for the consumer stuff and looks to have the same number of CPU direct lanes as last generation, just higher speed. I think I disagree, as the PCIe4.0x4 slot off the chipset is now an additional step removed (& subject to greater contention). But I digress, my point is that AMD risks leaving a gap in their market coverage by doing two things: 1. There are rumors they are no longer competing in consumer-accessible high lane count CPUs/chipsets. 2. They have an opportunity with the next gen Ryzen to close the gap by (1.) offering more lanes at 4.0 speed (they could offer 40 CPU-attached lanes!) but by moving to 5.0 exclusively, they limit expansion options. If both leaks/rumors are true, it suggests a missed opportunity.
- 4y ago
- zamadatix 4y agox16+x4 has worked fine for consumers at PCIe 4.0 since GPUs aren't benefiting from the bandwidth so it should work fine with PCIe 5.0 and even if you bifurcate for x8 x8 + x4 so you can have another high speed addon card of some sort that's still ~250 Gbps of bandwidth per card which is more than any home or gaming setup will be bottlenecked by (workstation and server sure but those will be different boards). I'm not quite sure the dual linked chipset option for the high end really gets anyone anything. I mean sure, double all your ports... where half now have 2x the latency penalty to the CPU and all in all they are sharing less bandwidth than your primary storage slot has alone.
- wtallis 4y ago> where half now have 2x the latency penalty to the CPU Are any of the typical uses for those IO lanes latency-sensitive enough for that to matter at all? Consumer-grade networking, SATA storage, and most USB use cases all involve latency high enough that one more PCIe switch wouldn't be noticed.
- Strom 4y agoHow much extra latency are we talking here? Anyone have any actual numbers?
- jleahy 4y agoI would guesstimate low single digit microseconds (and guesstimating latency is pretty much my job). Typical USB poll rates are 10-100 milliseconds. AMD made a perfectly sensible choice.
- NavinF 4y agoWat. All but the cheapest crappiest mice have been using 1ms polling for the last decade. IIRC USB 3.0 is effectively 8kHz and doesn’t use polling which does make a difference for real-time video (webcam and capture card) latency and lip syncing. But nobody cares about USB. A lot of applications do 10000 reads from your SSD in series (qd1) and that’s where latency matters. I agree that it should be on the order of 1us. And since most people only have one SSD, chipset latency is not that important.
- cebert 4y agoI was under the impression that AM5 would support PCIe 5.0 instead of 4.0. I’m becoming less excited about this next generation from AMD than I was a few months ago.
- wmf 4y agoIt will support PCIe 5.0 on the slots directly connected to the CPU, but probably only on X670E motherboards. Note that there will be very few 5.0 devices on the market and you won't be able to notice the performance difference.
- mahkeiro 4y agoSaying there are few devices yet on the market is not helpful. You don't buy a PC for the next 6 months. In a 1-2-3 years when your PC will be still ok it is very likely that more PCIe5.0 devices will be out, and probably not compatible with your MB.
- NavinF 4y agoI upgrade every couple of years to the best hardware on the market, but even for me PCIe 5 is just “nice to have”. No GPUs support it yet and rumors suggest that RTX40 will also be PCIe 4.
- trashtester 4y agoMy interpretation is that the chipsets wil have PCIEe 5 connections as follows: X670E: "Everywhere" according to the talk, which I interpret as: - 16 lanes of pcie 5 to the main pcie slots - 4 lanes of pcie 5 to the primary nvme slot (i would not be surprised if some boards will expose this as a pcie x 16 slot (with 4 lanes)) though. - 4 lanes of pcie 5 to the chipset (speculative) For the regular X670: - 16+4 pcie5 lanes to "GPU" and "nvme" slots, as for the X670, perhaps only 1 nvme slot, perhaps with an additional nvme x8 slot when running 8/8/4 instead of 16/0/4. - "only" nvme 4 to the chipset B570: - Only the "nvme" slot will have version 5 If I'm right, the Extreme card will offer twice the performance over the chipset, compared to AM4, which could allow it to fill some of the use cases currently covered by the non-pro threadrippers. If I'm wrong, and even the extreme X670E chipset will not be a good choice for those who depend on a lot of IO, compared to threadripper or Intel. Hopefully, I'm right, and in that case, I'm not sure if we need an intermediate step between the 7950x and lower end threadripper pro setups, at least not for connectivity and I/O. And those who actually need more compute than the 7950x will over will probably not care that much about the price premium of threadripper pro vs regular threadripper.
- shantara 4y agoHow much of this information was confirmed, and how much are rumors and speculations? With such a radical change from the previous generation, it seems more prudent to wait the remaining couple of days until Computex to be absolutely sure.
- cududa 4y agoHere’s where this gets cool. If you’ve ever got into pro level “over clicking” RAM channels to maximize performance, this would leave you scratching your head. Won’t the timing of each chipset on each board need to be painstakingly individually configured to avoid latency from a “default” profile used in all chips (which inherently vary between every batch)? Yes, yes they would. Unless you had an automated solution. And if you have an automated way you could optimize CPU and DDR timing instead of using “buffered”/ “safe” latency settings to accommodate any manufacturing variance. Well turns out AMD has a method for that. And given the necessity for a tech like this to make daisy chained chipsets work, it would seem this isn’t an idle patent. AM5 systems are basically going to get a 10-20% performance bump due to that optimization. Which is wild. https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-patents-automatic-memory-overclocking https://www.tomshardware.com/news/amd-patents-automatic-memo...
- wmf 4y agoWon’t the timing of each chipset on each board need to be painstakingly individually configured to avoid latency from a “default” profile used in all chips (which inherently vary between every batch)? No, because PCIe works completely differently from RAM. PCIe is a packet-based protocol that's very latency-tolerant. (Multi-lane PCIe links may require deskew but that's a standard feature that has existed all along.) I think it was Marcan who tunneled PCIe over RS-232 and the chips didn't even notice.
- cududa 4y agoWell the chipset also handles shuttling RAM channels..
- NinjaKitten 4y agoNo. You appear to have a fundamentally flawed understanding of the system at hand.
- cududa 4y agoPerhaps. 16 years out from AMD ram/ cpu channel optimization. If the chipset isn’t handling RAM channels what component is?
- potiuper 4y agoAmazing no vendor has come out with a X300/Knoll mini ITX board with a PCI x16 along with NVME slot.
- wmf 4y agoThere's some kind of market segmentation at play where nobody will make a high-quality board with a low-end "chipset" even though it would be perfect for many customers.
- walterbell 4y agoThe segmentation goes the other way too. At one point, there were no Ryzen boards that could be rack-mounted for enterprise use.
- JonChesterfield 4y agoMemory slot direction doesn't seem that important. At least, I've got a desktop board in a rack that seems happy enough. Or is there something other than memory direction that puts you off, ipmi perhaps?
- formerly_proven 4y agoIf you put it in a 1U case I would be very surprised if it didn't matter - I'm doing that with a very low power platform and the clearance between the memory and the case only leaves a 2-3 mm gap, which I doubt would permit sufficient airflow for a normal passive CPU heatsink with a normal CPU power.
- JonChesterfield 4y agoThat's definitely true, 1U is mostly filled by memory height. My boxes all have GPUs in so I don't get to go that short.
- walterbell 4y ago
- rasz 4y ago>their 600-series chipset No, the chipset is in the Ryzen CPU. What they mean is a Southbridge used by board manufacturers for market segmentation purposes. >AMD’s Ryzen line of client Desktop processors don’t even need a ‘chipset‘ Amazing, an article stating the truth for once! >Despite this, nearly all Desktop motherboards still contain a chipset, but in its modern iteration serve as I/O expansion hubs and back to muddying the water. No, "chipsets" are used for market segmentation, and AMD is complicit with gems like this: https://www.itworldcanada.com/article/amd-zen-3-processors-will-be-incompatible-with-400-series-and-older-motherboards/430513 https://www.itworldcanada.com/article/amd-zen-3-processors-w... https://www.extremetech.com/computing/320548-amd-will-support-smart-access-memory-on-ryzen-3000-cpus-for-gaming https://www.extremetech.com/computing/320548-amd-will-suppor... https://www.anandtech.com/show/14477/amd-confirms-pcie-4-not-coming-to-older-motherboards https://www.anandtech.com/show/14477/amd-confirms-pcie-4-not... https://www.eteknix.com/some-asus-x470-and-b450-motherboards-support-pcie-4-0/ https://www.eteknix.com/some-asus-x470-and-b450-motherboards... not to mention overclocking lockouts all this bullshit depending on what ASMedia IO dongle connects over PCIE bus on the motherboards. >dual-source these chipsets and proceeds to explains how there will be none of that with exclusive ASMedia once again :) >Low-end, Mid-range, High-end ah yes, back to artificial segmentation based on limited BW 4x PCIE switch while CPUs provide plenty of dedicated PCIE lanes. >“X670E“ branded motherboards will require the primary PCIe and M.2 slots to support PCIe 5.0 linkrate. The chipset itself is identical to X670. and now we are at making up totally fake name for a non existent product X670E to upmarket PCIE 5.0, sweet! >designing only a single piece of silicon to span across multiple market segments, it is much more cost-effective to design for the mass market middle-end solution and double up for the high-end rather than designing a larger, more expensive die that fits the requirements of the top end spilling truth by accident once again. Yes, AMD is selling us the same cheap solution under different names for different prices, and we should be thrilled!
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- walterbell 4y agoAMD Computex 2022 keynote with announcement: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRtBB2VnF8M&t=145s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BRtBB2VnF8M&t=145s
- sylware 4y agoMaybe everything (ethernet/hdaudio) should be on the cpu die for good (if not too much EM interferences). Maybe a legacy SATA controller hardwired to a few cpu pcie lanes, and an optional wifi chip hardwired the same way.