3 ms·
I'll offer the counterpoint that it's only complicated if you want to make it so. If you only need e.g. monospace ASCII, that doesn't take much. Do you really n
by userbinator 4y ago
I'll offer the counterpoint that it's only complicated if you want to make it so. If you only need e.g. monospace ASCII, that doesn't take much. Do you really need proportional fonts? Vertical layouts? Keming? In my experience, a lot of the time the answer is actually "no" --- and thus the simpler (and more efficient, less bug-prone) algorithm works just fine.
- zokier 4y agoDo you really need more than 1s and 0s? Maybe go back to blinkenlights and toggle switches, those are simpler and even less bug prone to implement. You can still perform any computation you want, but it sure will not be as pleasant as having nice ux.
- FooBarWidget 4y agoWhether you need them is up to users. If you have Asian users then ASCII will not do. No kerning? Why would users put up with ugly text rendering? Just to make our lives as developers easier? This attitude reminds me of what someone says about the difference between German and Japanese tech. Japanese ones last forever because they overdesign their products to avoid breaking even when misused, because they are customer-focused. Germans are rule-focused, so they design their products according to spec. German products also last forever — if you use the product exactly per instructions. But if you make a mistake... good luck.
- userbinator 4y ago"ugly" is entirely subjective.
- can16358p 4y agoWell, if 90 out of 100 users think it's ugly, that would better be resolved to have more users use your library, even if you are in the 10% as the developer.
- eska 4y agoAs a German working in a Japanese company this kind of romanticization of these two cultures always makes me snort.
- astrange 4y agoConversely, Japanese game engines sometimes don’t bother implementing proportional text, and then nobody can translate the game without porting it to Unity first. (German translations would need about 3x the UI space of Japanese ones, and that’s with a proportional font.)
- remus 4y agoI think the issue with this approach is that people may nod along and day they're happy with these compromises, but in reality they don't necessarily understand the trade offs and are then surprised when seemingly simple things don't work as expected. I'm thinking less of programmers here, who will generally understand what these limitations imply, and more of less technical users.
- pdpi 4y agoI think you're missing the point. These are fundamentally, but deceivingly, hard problems. The choice to only solve a subset of the problem is almost always the right way forward, but you can only make that decision if you understand how hard the problem is. A less knowledgeable developer can and will bite off more than they can chew with these things. Contrast with things like interpreters that a are a lot simpler to build and work with than most engineers think they are, and a perfectly reasonable solution to lots of problems.
- gitgud 4y ago> Keming Brilliant, I've never seen kerning (ker-ning) spelt in a way that illustrates it's importance!
- userbinator 4y agoIf you don't implement kerning, you won't get keming. ;-)
- GreenWatermelon 4y agoThere is a subreddit with the same name for this sort of topic: /r/keming