4 ms·
In the Fight over How to Teach Reading, This Guru Makes a Major Retreat
- rahimnathwani 4y agoPSA: If you have a 3-5 year-old child who isn't yet reading independently, you don't need any special training to teach them to read English. Just 15 mins per day a few days per week, and a single book: Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons https://www.amazon.com/dp/0671631985/ https://www.amazon.com/dp/0671631985/ The only requirements are that you can read, and can spare 15 mins per day. I guess that applies to ~100% of HN readers. You could rely on your kid's school to teach them to read, but learning to read with 1:1 direct instruction is just so efficient. I've posted about this book on HN before (and I myself first read about it here). Here's an excerpt from an email an HN user sent me recently: "Last year, I bought the book for my 4 year old and we slowly worked through it. Now he can read about as well as his 8 year old friends."
- jbm 4y agoI read your comment too. My non-English speaking daughter went from zero english reading to above grade level after 2-3 months with the book during the pandemic. It wasn't even necessary to do all the lessons. I was impressed and highly recommend it.
- rahimnathwani 4y ago"The last two or three years, what I’ve learned from the science of reading work has been transformational" The research is over 20 years old. For years, people have been calling on her to fess up, and on school districts to switch to methods that are actually proven to work. This is too little too late.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoActually, this guy said it best: https://twitter.com/PaulMorganPhD/status/1528412297248575489?s=20&t=_NEFJjeL5f2A6sQjqNbwFA https://twitter.com/PaulMorganPhD/status/1528412297248575489...
- huitzitziltzin 4y agoNot sure why so many school districts empower an educational “research” establishment which seems to be uninformed about, and allergic to, empirical work… we have the same fights about math that we have about reading. It’s a mystery to me.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoHere are the folks from my local school district (San Francisco) explaining their approach: https://youtu.be/3RsitD6m0vU https://youtu.be/3RsitD6m0vU The questions towards the end of the video didn't receive satisfactory answers.
- jfengel 4y agoThese are the experiments. They don't get to raise a set of control-children in lab. They don't get to use animal models. They don't get to run Monte Carlo simulations. The only way to test if an educational theory works is to try it out in the real world. You train a bunch of teachers in it, try it on a bunch of children, and wait 15-20 years for the results to come in. All the while fighting for the integrity of the experiment vs. the numerous other variables people will impose. It would be great if we could do what we do with subatomic particles, or atoms, but we can't. Neither can we refrain from doing it, because we know that education needs to be improved. It's simply false to say "why even try because the old way was working fine", because it wasn't -- certainly not for everybody. The researchers are not uninformed. They have tons of information, all of it complicated and contradictory because people are more complicated than electrons. They're also under-funded to do research of the magnitude that they require, since their work on educating the next generation of citizens is arguably far more important than finding new bosons.