3 ms·
Thank you, this is an insightful comment. > The comparison with other countries tends not to be made. I find that problematic because it reduces the situation
by rayiner 5y ago
Thank you, this is an insightful comment.
> The comparison with other countries tends not to be made.
I find that problematic because it reduces the situation in these developing countries to a moral narrative with the ultimate purposes of embettering descendants of european countries. But these narratives don’t facilitate solutions. The French are not, for example, going to ever pay back the $20 billion or so in reparations they demanded from Haiti. Nor are the British going to pay back the $1 trillion+ they expropriated from India.
I’m much more interested in cross comparisons to industrial development to European countries. Bangladesh is currently industrializing using foreign capital. What parallels can be drawn to Germany or the US that would help keep that going? Because at the end of the day, the 6-7% annual GDP growth the country is currently enjoying is more significant to Bangladeshis than the combined effect of all the moral narratives ever penned about the country by the likes of the New York Times.
- selimthegrim 5y agoBangladeshis seem perfectly happy with a “Pakistan invested nothing in us from 1947-71” narrative while buying air defense systems from them well into 21st century.
- rayiner 5y agoAnd they’re downright gleeful about the recent divergence in GDP per capita growth between Pakistan and India/Bangladesh, as well as Pakistan’s inability to get their birth rate down to replacement levels. But that doesn’t top India’s recent preoccupation with being mad not about the 700 years of Muslim rule prior to British colonization…
- selimthegrim 5y agoI don’t worship Aurangzeb and neither should anyone else. What’s going on is about erasing Muslims rather than moving forward (moving the buildings or building a new mosque on a different site, etc). Inventing sacred sites (and I am not saying this about Kashi/Mathura because those are well documented) is the oldest trick in the book (see attempts at Charminar in Hyderabad by Hindus, Shab Bhar Masjid in pre-Partition Lahore, etc)
- selimthegrim 5y agoSpeaking of Shab Bhar Masjid, today’s Google Doodle is of none other than Gama Pehlwan, who was involved in that and also saved lives of many Hindus during Partition.