3 ms·
It’s a great question. FWIW, I specifically posted this review by Doug DeMuro after watching a couple others that were clearly just PR regurgitation. I personal
by CharlesW 4y ago
It’s a great question. FWIW, I specifically posted this review by Doug DeMuro after watching a couple others that were clearly just PR regurgitation. I personally consider him a competent and neutral reviewer after having watched his reviews of other vehicles.
- jhpaul 4y agoI clicked comments first curious if this would be Doug's video. His reviews and retro reviews are so well constructed and thorough and, as with the cars, his "quirks and features" really shine through.
- belter 4y agoI just watched the review and he says he has only positives to say about. That makes me already skeptical. A review with only positives? Would he get other cars to review after a negative review?
- iotku 4y agoDoug has his personal biases (as does everyone else), but does make an decent effort to be neutral (within his capabilities) while hitting his main points and remaining entertaining. This [1] is a fairly great conversation with him which covers a lot of topics including the incentives [2] many other YouTubers/Car Journalists have (from getting flown out to launch events and the general pressures to not lose access to press cars by being too negative in a review) That said, while I trust Doug far more than many reviewers he still has many relationships with car dealerships, often gets access to preproduction cars that he can't drive yet (but almost always does a full review when he can), and does have a car auction business so there's still room for that to have an effect on his judgement even if he's trying otherwise. [1] https://youtu.be/pFGh-YqHT4Y https://youtu.be/pFGh-YqHT4Y [2] https://youtu.be/pFGh-YqHT4Y?t=5155 https://youtu.be/pFGh-YqHT4Y?t=5155