4 ms·
Haiti was independent for more than a century before the US invasion. What was it like before that? As someone from a third world country, I’m ambivalent about
by rayiner 5y ago
Haiti was independent for more than a century before the US invasion. What was it like before that?
As someone from a third world country, I’m ambivalent about these “blame the white people” stories.
- azinman2 5y agoI think you should read up more on the history of Haiti.
- viksit 5y agoThe article that should have been posted is this : https://nyti.ms/3G3zNKB https://nyti.ms/3G3zNKB Tldr - France and french banks forced haiti to pay reparations for having earned their freedoms for so long that 2.53 out of every 3 dollars they made for centuries went to “white people”. This led to a loss of 25 billion dollars conservatively or 200 if you’re being real. The US just took over as the next colonial power.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoIt was once maybe the richest and most densely populated place on earth. http://cyberspacei.com/jesusi/authors/chomsky/year/y501_008.htm http://cyberspacei.com/jesusi/authors/chomsky/year/y501_008....
- samatman 5y agoSearching for "rich" and "wealth" in that document doesn't turn up a demonstration of the claim, which I find extraordinary. Would you mind quoting the part which you believe does?
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>Saint Domingue was the wealthiest European colonial possession in the Americas," Hans Schmidt writes, producing three-quarters of the world's sugar by 1789, Though I believe the poster was asking about the economy post independence.
- rayiner 5y agoSo was Bangladesh (where I’m from). But because of natural bounty and resources, not technology or social organization. That’s why the Europeans were able to establish colonies in the first place. And even if restored to that level of wealth that would make them desperately poor by European standards today.
- Synaesthesia 5y agoBengal was actually quite advanced, orior to colonisation
- skippyboxedhero 5y agoThe comparison with other countries tends not to be made. Germany took huge amounts of money from the US, Japan (the CIA were rigging elections in Japan until a few decades ago), South Korea...in the 1940s, 100% this argument was justifiable. But after that point, particularly if you look at what happened in Central and South America, it is very clear that other explanations pre-dominate (and, not coincidentally, some of these places have been content to blame others all the way...Singapore was poorer than any country in Africa 60 years ago, had race riots worse than any place, they are now richer than most of Europe). Also, I did my PG thesis on this specific issue: whether you think it is right or wrong, this is how sovereign debt crises were resolved at the time. Egypt, Ottomans...there were few other options that creditors had because most of these places weren't nation states in the way we perceive them today. So passing financial management over to creditors or hypothecating specific revenues (something not mentioned in the article, but which happened in Haiti) were the only way that people agreed to lend...and they lent, they provided financing for everything. The article doesn't invert their question (deliberately, I think we all know what the agenda is here...it relates to contemporary politics only): if the US and France didn't lend, how does Haiti industrialise? The population had no savings, do you think roads and hospitals just spring up for free out of nothing? The US, Germany (in part), Australia, New Zealand, Japan, South Korea...they all industrialised using foreign capital. Finally, I think forced labour was used in road construction in almost every country (certainly in the US). The implication today has to be that this was because of racism or some inherent desire for evil...it wasn't, it was because (once again) of the lack of reasonable alternatives.
- rayiner 5y agoThank you, this is an insightful comment. > The comparison with other countries tends not to be made. I find that problematic because it reduces the situation in these developing countries to a moral narrative with the ultimate purposes of embettering descendants of european countries. But these narratives don’t facilitate solutions. The French are not, for example, going to ever pay back the $20 billion or so in reparations they demanded from Haiti. Nor are the British going to pay back the $1 trillion+ they expropriated from India. I’m much more interested in cross comparisons to industrial development to European countries. Bangladesh is currently industrializing using foreign capital. What parallels can be drawn to Germany or the US that would help keep that going? Because at the end of the day, the 6-7% annual GDP growth the country is currently enjoying is more significant to Bangladeshis than the combined effect of all the moral narratives ever penned about the country by the likes of the New York Times.
- sailingparrot 5y agoYou might want to read the article you are commenting on a bit more carefully, since this is explicitly mentioned. While Haiti gained independence from France in 1791, France demanded "reparation" from that loss under the threat of a war. > They reveal a debt so large, and so lasting, that it would help cement Haiti’s path to poverty and underdevelopment. Haiti became the first and only country where the descendants of enslaved people paid the families of their former masters for generations. > In 1825, France demanded five annual payments of 30 million francs. The amount was far beyond Haiti’s meager means. The first payment alone was about six times Haiti’s entire revenue that year, according to the prominent 19th-century Haitian historian Beaubrun Ardouin. https://archive.ph/9InwY#selection-851.0-908.0 https://archive.ph/9InwY#selection-851.0-908.0
- TMWNN 5y ago>Haiti was independent for more than a century before the US invasion. What was it like before that? After two centuries, one might start to think that the problem with Haiti is Haitians, were such a concept not wrongthink and therefore verboten. Relevant Reddit post: >TIL that Haiti has had 23 constitutions since 1801, with the most recent being enacted in 2012. At least two have declared the country to be an empire. <https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/3t5wzt/til_that_haiti_has_had_23_constitutions_since/ https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/3t5wzt/til_t...>
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe US has had what, 29? Articles of Confederation, US Constitution, and then 27 amendments. I guess several of the amendments came together so it'd be slightly lower.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThis article is heavily infused with the bias of the article with the authors' opinion of "USA bad".