5 ms·
Today's resistance to self checkout reminds me of the resistance to these shopping carts and before that the resistance to supermarkets ("why do I have to go fe
by gumby 4y ago
Today's resistance to self checkout reminds me of the resistance to these shopping carts and before that the resistance to supermarkets ("why do I have to go fetch my purchases myself?" "I miss the conversation with the shopkeeper" were common examples of complaints that have reappeared in the anti-self-checkout complaints).
- raverbashing 4y agoSome people will just resist any change and complain for the most petty reasons
- gumby 4y agoMy grandmother used to laugh about a famous person-on-the-street interview about Australia going metric: one woman complained, "why can't they just wait until all us old people die". It was her go-to comment about anyone complaining about change, and she found it funnier the older she got.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoAnd sometimes change actually sucks.
- guptaneil 4y agoTo be fair in this case, self-service is objectively worse than having the shopkeeper grab everything you want. The popularity of curb-side pickup of your grocery order shows how nice that model used to be, but self-service is more scalable and cheaper. The same is true when it comes to paying. It’s nicer to have someone else ring you up than you have to learn to do it yourself. I think a better comparison would be people complaining about frictionless checkout (where you just walk out like Amazon grocery stores) in the same way as shopping carts, which is actually a whole new and better experience but can feel so weird that people feel uncomfortable about it. (disclaimer: I’ve never actually tried an Amazon Go store but I do avoid self-checkout whenever I have fruits/veggies to check out)
- danaris 4y ago> self-service is objectively worse than having the shopkeeper grab everything you want. This makes some assumptions. Off the top of my head: 1) The shopkeeper is always available to grab your purchases without a wait. 2) You already know exactly which products you want, and/or there aren't different versions of products to select between. 3) The shopkeeper is trustworthy enough to get you the actual products you want. 4) You aren't a person that the shopkeeper is going to discriminate against. There are lots of good reasons to want to pick out your own groceries.
- Hamuko 4y agoWhenever I go get my own groceries, I can buy my lunches in advance for the next week as well if the expiration dates for my usual lunches are long enough. But whenever I've ordered my groceries delivered, I've had to assume that the expiration dates last for about a week. There's definitely advantages to someone picking out your groceries for you, but also some drawbacks.
- bombcar 4y agoIt works significantly better when there isn’t any real choice - you have creamy vs chunky peanut butter instead of forty different brands thereof. Give me whole milk is easier and simpler than “give me this particular brand of whole milk”.
- danaris 4y agoWhich is great when your needs are the default needs. When you have needs—or even just desires—that aren't The One Available Product, suddenly you're SOL. Sometimes with grievous health consequences.
- jwilk 4y agoI'll add: • You're able to speak loud and clear. • You can speak the same language as the shopkeeper.
- leetcrew 4y ago
- donarb 4y agoAnd the common response to self checkout is that you are putting a checker out of work. Never mind the fact that most of the shelves are not stocked by store employees, but by distributors. A grocery store is basically a place where the store rents out shelf space to the highest bidder.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> Never mind the fact that most of the shelves are not stocked by store employees, but by distributors. This is new to me. Do you just mean that the placement is decided by distributors? I'm pretty sure I have seen store employees putting stuff on the shelves from time to time at my local supermarket.
- caw 4y agoI believe this only applies to a few sections—soda, chips, and magazines(?). Your produce and canned food aisles are stocked by the store employees, though the planograms for the shelving layout comes from corporate, sized for the store’s footprint. There may be some distributor input into those, such as cereal, but I’ve never seen those processes, only the resulting stock plan.
- jjulius 4y agoThis is correct. In many areas, alcohol is also stocked by distributors. But the rest of the grocery store is stocked by store employees.
- bombcar 4y agoThis also only applies to some stores - not all. You can often tell by the uniform the sticker is wearing. Smaller stores and chains are often stocked by the store itself, even if Coke delivered the pallet.
- gumby 4y agoDistributors for the big food companies (Coca-Cola, Pepsi/Frito-Lay, etc) essentially rent and maintain a section of shelving and then keep it full and decide themselves on the distribution of products that appear. Smaller manufacturers sell their product wholesale to the stores who then stock them in the normal fashion. The end caps of isles are sold to the highest bidder, typically by the week; if that bidder is coca-cola they manage that display as well, subject to the constraints of the store. One of the innovations of Frys Electronics was to try to run their shops that way, as they started by selling serial cables and other computer supplies in their family's grocery chain. It only partially worked as the vendors weren't really equipped to do this, the way the food companies are.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Markoff 4y agowell, if I am saving supermarket money on shopkeepers then supermarket also needs to expect I will also try to save some money on "mistakes" while using self checkout, two can play this game, especially considering how much money shopkeepers scammed me, because they always make "mistake" which is beneficial only to shop (OK, to be fair, not always, "only" in 95-98% cases, I can't even remember how many times they scammed me with wrong price(tag)s or wrong item (it's almost every other or every third purchase, so I check receipt every single time), but I remember very well once in a many years guy made mistake and charged me cheaper bread, that was like winning the lotto)
- bombcar 4y agoWhen Target was just starting to expand as Super Target in my area they somehow had the barcode for turkey ringing up as 25 cents total instead of per pound. I tried to explain to the cashier that it had to be wrong and they started to get mad at me, so I gave up and took my 25 cent turkey.
- karaterobot 4y agoI like talking to people in the checkout line. The lady who checked me out today grew up in the same tiny town my parents retired to, 7 hours from here. Just learned that today. Plus, the UX of self checkout systems generally sucks to the extent that it makes me angry when I use it, and I'd rather feel better at the end of a transaction than worse.
- millimeterman 4y agoPeople like you are my worst nightmare :P. The last thing I want when shopping is interactions with random strangers. I'll even gladly take a slightly janky self-checkout experience if it eliminates interacting with a cashier.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoSelf-checkout machines are simply bad though. All the hoops they make you jump through to prevent theft makes for a terrible experience. Having to put everything on the damn scale, even if it's the only thing you're buying, sucks, and even still it always yells at you, "UNEXPECTED ITEM IN THE BAGGING AREA!". And there's always a dozen prompts you have to click through before you can pay. Home Depot gets it right. They have a large table with a handheld wireless scanner, a receipt printer, a card payment terminal, and a touch screen that you don't need to interact with at all. All you have to do is start scanning and tap your card when you're done.
- wutbrodo 4y agoDo you really find that to be a hurdle? The first time I used one, the scale warning surprised me. But it's trivial to avoid, and now self checkout feels super efficient to me
- frosted-flakes 4y agoI'm tall, and the scales are nearly at floor level. And if I walk into a grocery store and buy a single bag of milk (which doesn't need another bag because it is a bag so why would I put it in the bagging area?), having to stoop down to put it on the scale is an inconvenience I'd rather avoid. Some stores let you select "no bag" every time and let you proceed to payment, but most don't. Being treated with so much suspicion is also not pleasant. My solution is to avoid self-checkout at stores with crappy machines, or avoid those stores altogether. If Home Depot can do good self-checkout, why can't everyone else? That's the primary reason I frequent HD over Lowe's.
- louracryft 4y agoIt can be a hurdle for people who aren't already familiar with the machines and their arcane rules. That quickly becomes a problem if the store doesn't have enough staff to dedicate an employee to the self-checkout area. I've been seeing this more often in the past few months at understaffed low-cost retailers. When there's nobody around to override the machines, people get frustrated and move on to the next open machine without understanding what went wrong. Five minutes later, the entire self-checkout area is offline, and the would-be customer sometimes feels sufficiently annoyed and neglected to walk off with their groceries.
- astrange 4y agoThe strange thing about self checkout at my nearest store is that the store is 24 hours, but they close self checkout at night, which is also when they have no staff, so the only way to use the store is to walk all over and drag the manager back to open a checkout.