8 ms·
> I'm sorry, and pardonner mou Français, but what in the actual fuck? Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? It might make you m
by ekianjo 4y ago
> I'm sorry, and pardonner mou Français, but what in the actual fuck?
Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? It might make you much safer in case of a crash, according to your reasoning.
Wearing a helmet can itself become a leading factor to cause an incident, and it's clearly what they are hinting at in the linked article: that data seems to indicate that riders wearing helmets may be getting more incidents on average. Then it's a simple equation: number of incidents x gravity of the incident in both A/B scenarios, and compare which one is the most favorable. It's not a question you answer with a "what the actual fuck" kind of reasoning.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoI've seen research stating adjacent car drivers will give less space to a cyclist wearing a helmet due to implied added safety.
- enkid 4y agoThis sounds like one of those papers that got published with just barely "significant statistical evidence" but never had follow-up to verify, meaning you can't really draw conclusions for it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- analog31 4y agoThe study was barely scientific. The researcher was his own test subject, and the result has never been replicated. Also, most crashes probably occur under conditions where the driver can't be aware of whether the cyclist is wearing a helmet or not. "The cyclist suddenly came out of nowhere" is a common defense.
- arjvik 4y agoCorrelation vs causation much? In order to show that helmets *cause* accidents, they need to create a randomized study where they force employees to flip a coin to decide whether to wear a helmet or not. Otherwise, here's one plausible scenario: Employees who work in tiny suburbs with small roads and very little traffic feel safer, and this are less likely to wear a helmet. They get in less crashes because their town has fewer and safer drivers. Employees working in the city have more crashes simply because of being in a busy city, so they are more likely to wear helmets. Right now, you cannot prove that helmets cause crashes and not the above.
- moralestapia 4y ago>Correlation vs causation much? Oh I'm so tired of this meme! Plenty of times causation is found through correlation. Plenty. Of. Times.
- indymike 4y agoI can prove that helmets reduce head injuries both in quantity and severity.
- shkkmo 4y agoYou have the exact same causal issue to untangle. Do safer riders wear helmets or does wear a helmet make you safer as a rider? In reality there are confounds both directions. The effects of helmet wearing are higly contingent based on the geography and demographics.
- mcherm 4y agoYes, but it IS possible to do research that untangles these effects. Here is a review (from just 3 years ago) of such studies: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1369847818305941 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S136984781...
- shkkmo 4y agoI have some issues with that study. One major one is they basically rule out half the effects of helmets as a "logical fallacy": > Risk compensation, as it is typically defined and understood, is only one of six possible scenarios, namely a usual non-helmet wearer puts on a helmet and increases their risk taking. Importantly, evidence in the opposite direction, i.e., taking a helmet off leads to less risky behaviour, is not evidence in support of risk compensation as it is a type of logical fallacy After reviewing that article none of the studies are convincing either way. The only studies that actually look for causality are the ones which only measure speed to asses risk. Those are also the one that I would qualify as positive results but were listed as negative results because of that above mentioned logical fallacy. So while is is possible to untangle these effects, it has yet to be done properly to show a clear result either way.
- CaptainHardcore 4y ago> Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? Because I have a seatbelt, an airbag, and a reinforced shock absorbing shell around me.
- stefan_ 4y agoSo you wear a helmet as a pedestrian then? You are so unprotected!
- CaptainHardcore 4y agoI guess if I was going to walk in the road with traffic.
- ekianjo 4y agolike an everyday pedestrian you mean?
- Handytinge 4y agoEveryday pedestrians generally walk on footpaths, not roads.
- Tade0 4y ago> So you wear a helmet as a pedestrian then? I'm not going multiples of walking speed on something standing upright only thanks to gyroscopic forces, so no. Also even when running I have way better maneuverability than as a cyclist. Generally limbs > wheels when it comes to getting out of trouble. I wear a helmet when skiing though.
- ekianjo 4y agoIf a car collides with you when you walk you could make the argument its safer to have a helmet. this is not evem remotely rare in terms of occurence.
- yellowapple 4y ago> Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? My car has other safety measures in place to protect me from head injuries. A bicycle does not.
- ekianjo 4y agosure, but if a helmet makes things even safer by all means lets mandate helmets in cars. I want people to follow that safety logic to the end.
- yellowapple 4y agoWho here is saying helmets should be mandated even for bicycles, let alone cars? Why are the only options "pursue safety to its absolute maximum" v. "don't pursue it at all"? Why can't that decision be left to the individual rider, rather than forcing riders to forego safety equipment for astoundingly-lissencephalic rationale like "helmets reduce safety"?
- samatman 4y agoI know this will astonish you, but when I ride a bike, I don't always put a helmet on. Whether I do or not has a lot to do with how likely it is that I might get in an accident. Wild right? Why would I opt for more safety gear in a more dangerous situation.
- woeirua 4y agoHere’s the contrarian viewpoint just for the sake of being a contrarian, in spite of decades of evidence that helmets improve cyclist safety.
- treesprite82 4y ago> Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? Cars already have airbags and seatbelts which help a lot for the kind of collisions that would otherwise result in head injuries. > It might make you much safer in case of a crash, according to your reasoning. I don't see what in their comment could be construed to say that helmets make you much safer regardless of vehicle. > Wearing a helmet can itself become a leading factor to cause an incident Is there a source for this? Should be a randomized A/B test as you mentioned, not just a correlation - wearing a hi-vis jacket or other precautions taken more often in dangerous situations probably also correlate with accidents. Even if helmets do cause accidents through increased carelessness, some may still take issue to intentionally making a scenario more dangerous such that people are more careful. It's kind of settling for a local minimum, rather than aiming to reduce inherent risk alongside aligning people's risk estimates to not overestimate the precautions.
- stefan_ 4y agoBut a helmet will help even more. It costs nothing, what is there to reject?
- treesprite82 4y agoI don't perceive the benefit from risk reduction of helmets in cars to overcome the hassle hurdle. But I wouldn't advocate banning others from wearing helmets in cars if they so wished.
- darkerside 4y agoHelmets reduce peripheral vision. I would absolutely be comfortable banning helmets in cars if people started wearing them and causing more accidents.
- allears 4y agoMy bicycle helmet sits on top of my head, and has nothing to do with peripheral vision. Do you wear yours pulled down low over your forehead? If so you're doing it wrong.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoI once organized a workshop on reasoning about uncertainty and in it a woman attended who was in charge of cycling safety for a large government organization of some EU country. She confirmed that, statistically speaking, cycling without a helmet is safer than with but mentioned this as a good example of likely confounding factors and a case where you cannot take the statistics itself for policy making. But besides that, even if the average nation-wide number of accidents can be taken as a basis for nation-wide policy making because confounders can be ignored (a huge assumption), you can still not use this data reliably for individual decision making or policy making for smaller groups without further analysis. You need to account the variance, where the confounders occur, and what these confounding factors are. For example, regarding individual decision making, it could be the case that certain people who cycle with helmets on the average cycle more recklessly, but you cycle even more carefully with a helmet and are better protected. If so, you cannot take the average to inform your cycling. The same holds for other groups, such as professional cyclists for a company like in this article. To give another example, consider accident statistics of self-driving cars versus human drivers nationwide. The human driver statistics include each and every reckless and drunk driver in the country, including many people with whom you'd never share a car ride. At the same time, you might have been driving accident-free for more than 40 years. For you personally, or a specific group you belong to, self-driving cars could thus be way more dangerous than driving yourself.
- nathan_f77 4y ago> Do you wear a helmet when you drive inside your car? If not, why not? It might make you much safer in case of a crash, according to your reasoning. Would it? I've never heard anyone recommend this, but if this did actually reduce the likelihood of a serious head injury in the event of a car crash, then I would seriously consider wearing a helmet while I drive a car. I have no problem wearing one while I ride a bicycle or motorbike.
- happysadpanda2 4y agoNot that it correlates much to every day driving, since both speeds and driving patterns differ, but e.g. NASCAR drivers wear helmets (along with that whole neck protection setup that latches to the helmet). I don't know, however, if a helmet may work worse in conjuction with an airbag though. So personally I think I'd stay away from helmets in cars (but I really have too little data to make an informed decision). Having said that, in the case of this company, perhaps they could offer their passengers a "Hövding" device? (Hövding being the swedish word for a chieftain, but "hövve" is also slang for head, and in the case of this product it is a... "backpack/necklace thingy" that is a wearable airbag. Supposedly works really well, but probably comes with a price tag matching this function.
- shkkmo 4y agoMotor vehicle accidents are a leading cause of traumatic brain injury related deaths. If you are under 55 the obly higher cause is suicide. (If you qre older than 55, your chances of a TBI related death from an accidental fall start to skyrocket with age.) There is a reason why race car drivers wear helmets, and it isn't just to have another place to plaster sponsor logos. I am not aware of any studies looking specifically at the effects of helmet wearing on TBI rates of regular drivers, but then good data on that for bicycles is also hard to come by but that doesn't stop people from pushing for bicycle helmets.
- toast0 4y agoRace car drivers are at a lot higher risk of a collision, spin, vehicle fire, or rapid disassembly in general than general traffic. And in many forms of racing, they usually go significantly faster than general traffic too. Helmets, neck restraints, five point harnesses, and flame retardant suits all reduce risk of injuries, and would likely reduce risk in general traffic as well, but the risks seem low enough that the expense (including time to equip) of that additional equipment is too much to justify its general use. Although, if there were an easier intervention to help with neck injuries, it might likely be adopted.
- oliwarner 4y agoNo, it rightfully illicits that response. Wearing a safety device shouldn't make an activity less safe. Your "simple equation" relies on your variables being solid. And they aren't. It's important to stress that the behavioural studies from Bath (that show helmeted riders take more risks in simulations, that cars give them less space) are not data about whether helmeted users are at greater risk. Or that comparisons between US and NZ riders and outcomes are comparable because of vastly different road and rider profiles. It's also hard to show how much helmets are helping because zero-harm accidents are rarely reported, so if we assume that they function correctly, and do reduce harm in impacts, we simply don't know how many near-misses there are. You can look at hospital admission data two studies show 75 and 78% of cyclists admitted with serious-enough head/neck injuries hadn't worn a helmet. That still needs adjusting for total accidents, and proportion of helmeted riders on the road in the first place. Again, poor reporting makes this tough. You also have to be aware that some studies and stats are polished up by people fervently for and against mandatory helmet laws. Biased reporting doesn't help anyone. There's a good selection here: https://www.helmets.org/stats.htm https://www.helmets.org/stats.htm (domain suggests a strong bias, but I'm not sure). Pedal Me doesn't provide a good argument here. It seems more like they're worried what their customers will think (do they need helmets too?) and nothing to do with actual safety outcomes.
- RC_ITR 4y ago> No, it rightfully illicits that response. Wearing a safety device shouldn't make an activity less safe. American Football vs Rugby and the difference in CTE is often cited as the prime example of where this is true. Helmets and shoulder pads encourage riskier hits.
- davisoneee 4y agoI don't think that example is quite so obvious. American Football is all about set plays. You line up and then charge at each other, meaning you have two lines effectively charging at each other and can focus all your effort on this one effort. Rugby is much more fluid, so the amount of direct head-on-head collisions is much lower, and the distance someone typically runs before tackling someone is much lower as the 'engagements' are more frequent. American Football is like going from 0-60mph every 10 minutes, whereas rugby is about sitting at 30mph constantly.
- dvzk 4y agoAs a frequent mountain biker, I can attest that wearing additional safety gear results in me taking more risks. I ride downhill faster, I take corners more aggressively, I take more jumps and I am less cautious over dangerous terrain. When wearing only shorts, a jersey, and a standard helmet, without pads or a full-face helmet, I ride subdued. Some of this difference is due to the innate and insidious sense of invulnerability with protective gear. It comes naturally even the first time you don it. It's a common source of accidents and something that must be trained out of you. Being able to get back up unscathed from bad falls also reinforces your future confidence, or lack thereof, which I can also attest from having fallen many times both with and without protective gear. I'd still never ride without (at least) a standard helmet. If helmets do factually cause more accidents, which is plausible for the reasons I just mentioned, I'd support making helmets mandatory for employees through legislation. It doesn't matter if the numbers support the opposite conclusion: maximizing individual safety in the eventuality of a crash is paramount. If you have ever had a head impact while wearing a helmet, you will understand why.