3 ms·
IIRC it is studied that cars behave more dangerously around bikers with helmets while they give a wide berth to unhelmeted bikers.
by whimsicalism 4y ago
IIRC it is studied that cars behave more dangerously around bikers with helmets while they give a wide berth to unhelmeted bikers.
- tomphoolery 4y ago"it is studied" Source please? This sounds like absolute bullshit. I've known so many people who have been killed or permanently disfigured because they didn't wear a helmet while biking in a large city. Cars don't give a fuck about us.
- andrenotgiant 4y agohttps://researchportal.bath.ac.uk/en/publications/bicycle-helmet-wearing-is-associated-with-closer-overtaking-by-dr https://researchportal.bath.ac.uk/en/publications/bicycle-he...
- gus_massa 4y agoFrom the abstract: > The distribution of overtaking events shifted just over one-fifth of a standard deviation closer to the rider – a potentially important behaviour if, as theoretical frameworks suggest, near-misses and collisions lie on a continuum. Looking at the graph in figure 1, "one-fifth of a standard" looks as unimpressive as expected. The distance from the kerb looks much more relevant. IIUC all the analysis is based on 2355 data gathered by Walker riding a bike himself a few years ago between two cities. It's not a mix of data from different persons or a mix of city and countryside rides. The most interesting part is that Walker published 5 articles about the same data, and he got a different result in each one.
- whimsicalism 4y agoYes, but you're missing that overtaking events is just one of the metrics in question. You're right that perhaps it is a big difference between cyclists, my guess would be the number of cars matters more than the number of cyclists. The study has been replicated elsewhere. > Walker published 5 articles about the same data, and he got a different result in each one. Uh, no? The 8.5 cm result has been consistent. At the margin, these things make a difference, especially given that collisions are rare as a fraction for rides taken.
- analog31 4y agoIndeed the researcher was his own test subject.
- whimsicalism 4y agohttps://psyarxiv.com/nxw2k https://psyarxiv.com/nxw2k To be clear, I am not saying that it is safer to ride without a helmet, just an interesting study of behavior. I get that you know people who are harmed by cars (as do I), but your appeal to pathos & anecdote should not have a bearing here.
- logifail 4y ago> This sounds like absolute bullshit. I've known so many people who have been killed or permanently disfigured because they didn't wear a helmet while biking in a large city. When I was at uni and was cycling to a 10am lecture, a small van pulled out of a side road across my path. I was in a cycle lane and had right of way. He simply didn't look in my direction until he had already started to pull out. I was unable to stop or avoid him, so hit the front of his van head on, was briefly airborne, and landed on the road on the other side. Miraculously only scuffs and bruises, although my bike was a write-off. At that point I started wearing a helmet(!!!) The next year, one of my friends went over the handlebars of her bike during a collision, except she landed head-first on the road, thankfully she was wearing a helmet. The helmet was split, she walked away with nothing other than mild concussion. Another friend and I walked out to rescue her bike later from the accident location, it also was a write-off. Once you've seen a bike accident up-close there is simply no justification for not wearing a helmet. Even if you haven't seen an accident, wear a helmet!
- littlestymaar 4y agoWikipedia links to this study[1] which found a difference of about 8,5cm in average, which sounds far from significant from a safety perspective (and again according to Wikipedia this study has been disputed). [1] https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.aap.2006.08.010 https://doi.org/10.1016%2Fj.aap.2006.08.010
- whimsicalism 4y agoAs a biker who understands marginal thinking, 8.5 cm could absolutely be significant from a safety perspective. The study is disputed by one researcher, the paper I linked contains a rebuttal and I think it is convincing.
- perlgeek 4y agoThere was one study about that, which was... not very robust science. It relied on self-report of the biker (and if I remember correctly, it was just a single one, so not enough data).
- BurningFrog 4y agoYeah, there is always a study made somewhere by somebody supporting whatever you want to believe in. Individual studies are on average fairly useless.
- whimsicalism 4y agoCould you reply with the study showing the opposite using new data? It should be pretty easy given that there is always a study showing you what you want. I'll be waiting :)
- BurningFrog 4y agoThere is a big asymmetry of effort in these kinds of requests, that are easily mistaken for winning the argument.
- whimsicalism 4y agoIt's pretty easy to win the argument when the opposing side is "studies are meaningless."
- BurningFrog 4y agoIt's pointless to argue with someone who doesn't even understand your argument.
- whimsicalism 4y agoFair enough, although it relied on video data, not self report, and included over 2300 cars. Perhaps it would have been different for different cyclists. Here is a study investigating this methodology of studying car behavior and ultimately concluding it is useful: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0001457513001279 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00014...
- fian 4y agoThe problems is that cars passing cyclists isn't the only time adverse car-cyclist interactions occur. I have been T-boned by a driver approaching from the opposite direction, in full daylight with no visual disruptions, when they failed to "look bike" and turned across my lane. They totally did not see me - so they fact I was wearing a helmet did not factor at all into the situation. I was flipped through the air and landed 10m down the side road on my back. My backpack took the brunt of of the impact but my head still snapped back and hit the ground. The helmet protected my head and prevented what would have at least been a concussion and possibly a fractured skull. In my 30+ years of regularly cycling on roads, I'd say the majority of close calls I've had have happened in with cars turning out of side streets of with cars turning across my lane from the opposite direction. Those are due to a combination of the following in my perceived order of likelihood: - the driver checking for cars/buses/trucks and not looking for motorcycles or bicycles - the driver seeing the cyclist but totally misjudging their speed and assuming they have time to complete their turn in front of the bike - the driver being as asshole and cutting off the cyclist. _Maybe_ the cyclist wearing helmet could affect the second scenario. It doesn't affect the first scenario and assholes are assholes regardless of helmet wearing. I've had less trouble with close/reckless overtaking. It does happen, but it is highly unlike the car driver completely fails to see a cyclist they are overtaking. Saying helmets reduce rider safety due to one scenario, where the car driver has to see the helmet and thus the cyclist in order to make a more risky overtaking gap judgement call, seems like a massive stretch to me.
- whimsicalism 4y agoAbsolutely agree, just thought it was interesting piece of evidence. As a regular biker, close passes are also a smaller of my concerns compared to most of the other hazards on the road.