4 ms·
I think issue is that they come from different view points. Rossman runs a company offering these services and he sees issues what they are allowed and can do a
by Ekaros 4y ago
I think issue is that they come from different view points. Rossman runs a company offering these services and he sees issues what they are allowed and can do about repairs. And he has essentially trained and skilled labour to do it.
On other hand Verge look it from consumer standpoint. Who might do one of repair every few years. From that view devices should be much simpler and easier to repair by unskilled owners.
Nothing wrong on either side, but I might go with viewpoint that devices should be easily customer repairable without shipping special tools, with massive deposit.
- omegabravo 4y agoHow do you get ever thinner phones without the tooling designed to dismantle it? It's no different in other industries. Small and compact requires special tools. You (and I) being willing to compromise on size to have better ability to repair the device doesn't represent the market at all. These complex engineered systems are going to continue to trend towards costly tools for repair. In a similar way, ICs are also impossible to repair compared to decades ago when you could lift out a faulty memory chip and replace it. It's far more important for companies like apple to accept 3rd party replacements and provide access to parts than worry about the speciality tools required unless they're there to be difficult. It certainly doesn't appear to be the case here. A repair shop would buy these tools, because otherwise they risk damaging the ($1k) phone trying to save a few bucks. Phones are going to be too complex for reliable home repair. I also don't repair my compressor in the AC, nor do I repair the wingdings in my vacuum cleaner. I just replace the part. I think the compromise here is fine, they're not plastic welded, they're sealed with adhesive.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> How do you get ever thinner phones without the tooling designed to dismantle it? This all issue made me think about the SIM tray: the SIM card contacts could also be sealed and recessed between the battery and the motherboard, and you’d go to an Apple Store to change the card whenever you need it. But you don’t, no one would accept having to get a phone serviced every time a SIM change is needed, even if some people never ever change it after purchase. So it’s designed in a way that you just push a thin bar in it and it pops out, you put your card, push it back, and your phone is still thin and waterproof. I genuinely think Apple could come up with a similarily elegant solution if they were making way more money by having easy to repair phones than having people give up and buy new phones instead.
- nabla9 4y agoThere is something wrong in the other side. Whey you try to make a phone that is water tight, very tiny, tough and as durable as possible, you can't expect it to be easy and safe to open with easy tools. These tools are still cheap enough that you could have them in your local community center or library (here in Finland we have weird stuff in local libraries) where people can do it. Changing batteries to watertight wrist watches or is also hard.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWatches use a gasket and either a friction fit or screwed on cover. There is no reason a phone manufacturer can't do the same with a larger product.
- Gigachad 4y agoHow would you remove a friction fit backing for a phone? That would be a massive amount of force if it was fit tight enough for a phone backing. The adhesive is relatively easy to remove tbh, the tools aren’t rocket science. The average person doesn’t even replace their own watch battery because the stores can do it for them. There is close to no benefit to doing it yourself.
- omegabravo 4y agoInterestingly enough, friction fit watches have speciality designed tools for them so you don't damage the face when applying the pressure. I recently changed my watch batteries and had to use multiple clamps to close it. You can repair an iphone without these tools, you're just taking more of a risk.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nabla9 4y agoYou use case back press or similar tool to remove it if you don't want scratches. Just like with a iPhone you can always use knife if you don't care.
- samatman 4y agoSure as long as you're relying the market and not the government to give this to you. I personally don't care one bit about replacing the battery in my cell phone. I don't want to be reliant on one single corporation, but as long as the parts are available to other professionals I can pay, I'm fine. I do want the waterproofness and compactness that goes with this, particular for my watch which is also a phone for the record, so I consider this to go far beyond what is reasonable as a legal restriction. In other words, I hope you're not one of those people who thinks Right to Repair gives you a vote as to how companies design their products. That's annoying. Edit: a vote besides the one you take with your wallet of course! My Precursor might just arrive this week and I'm excited about that (and won't be dipping it in the drink, at least not on purpose).
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> I hope you're not one of those people who thinks Right to Repair gives you a vote as to how companies design their products. That's annoying. Welcome to democracy mate, where we vote on any issues we deem worthy. Among them is regulating how companies design their products, becuase sometimes they combust and burn down our houses, or electrecute and kill us, produce electromagnetic noise that knocks out all radio communication, and at the end of their life they get discarded and poison our groundwater.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> On other hand Verge look it from consumer standpoint. I think the Verge look at it from the idiot standpoint -> most consumers will go to a local repair store, and if parts and tools are avaliable then they can get better and cheaper service. The repair store can invest a few grand in proper tools and use them regularly.