7 ms·
The big question with Tether has been, if they are holding commercial paper, whose commercial paper? Traders who deal in commercial paper of real companies that
by Animats 5y ago
The big question with Tether has been, if they are holding commercial paper, whose commercial paper? Traders who deal in commercial paper of real companies that do real stuff don't see Tether present in that market. The dollar amounts are too big to hide. The suspicion is that their "commercial paper" is high-interest loans to other cryptocurrency companies. With the whole crypto sector in decline, those loans are at risk.
This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market.
About 11% of Tether has been cashed out in the last month.
The real problem for Tether is simple. Why would anyone buy Tether at this point? There's zero upside potential, after all. And the competition, USDC and GUSD, looks better backed. So a steady outflow is to be expected. We're going to find out how strong their backing is.
Watch out for heavily promoted Tether-based "staking" schemes designed to prevent cash-out.
- wallaBBB 5y agoOh it’s even worse. For a while now some[0] have suggested part of the backing is in bonds issues by Chinese real estate companies [0] https://twitter.com/thelastbearsta1/status/1469007200496590848?s=21&t=Y4igVxc1nwkf-Fs3SjtRpQ https://twitter.com/thelastbearsta1/status/14690072004965908...
- kgc 5y agoIt could be worse than that. It could be commercial paper from Bitfinex or one of their other related party holdings.
- zby 5y agoBitfinex seems like a very good business. I mean at least since 2016 - but 8 years is enough. It is possible that they still mismanaged it catastrophically - but fees are really good in crypto exchanges and margin loses are socialized - so they are not a risk factor for the exchange.
- darawk 5y agoChinese real estate would be considerably better than crypto company loans, tbh.
- wallaBBB 5y agoChinese real estate companies are defaulting on their international bonds en masse and CN government has shown no interest in bailing them on that end.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoBetter to be backed by overvalued, sketchy physical real estate than nothing at all (see also: TerraUSD).
- jimmydorry 5y agoThey are backed by companies with near-zero or less than zero valuation (liabilities > assets). Many of these companies that are defaulting have no money on hand but have already sold apartments that they have not even started building yet. They are equivalent to a crypto that the market has lost faith in (both are worth nothing).
- dubswithus 5y agoAccording to Advchina, the underlying asset is of such poor quality that they will be torn down or abandoned. And from my understanding owning a property doesn’t mean you own it forever. It’s time limited by the government.
- CTDOCodebases 5y agoThis comes from the rumor that the commercial paper is from China. What I find more believable is the commercial paper is actually from crypto hedge funds and exchanges incorporated in Hong Kong.[0] [0] - https://protos.com/tether-papers-crypto-stablecoin-usdt-investigation-analysis/ https://protos.com/tether-papers-crypto-stablecoin-usdt-inve...
- dehrmann 5y agoSo tether could be theoretically backed by...bitcoin?
- CTDOCodebases 4y agoPossibly somewhat. There is typically a differentiation between commercial paper and asset backed commercial paper so who knows. It might depend on the individual lending USDT. I believe that these exchanges/crypto funds are borrowing USDT with interest payable in USD and principle payable in USDT. This would incentivise borrowers to buy USDT when the peg breaks to the down side thus keeping USDT pegged to the dollar. I think it would be more accurate to say that USDT is not backed by anything. The loans are backed by commercial paper but if the borrowers are not fulfilling these debts in USD in reality there is no backing. I presume the incentives that stop the peg breaking to the down side will only hold as long as the exchanges/crypto funds stay liquid. If there is a sustained mass exodus out of USDT I predict things will get ugly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dalbasal 5y agoEither way, unless they are fully backed by USD... stablecoin is just an unregulated bank and it can run. If that's not the case, they have as much rope as they have ability to liquidate. IE they can keep buying their own coin to defend the price for as long as they can. Imo, stablecoins are a good example of everyone knowing the score but systemic risk accrues regardless. Stabkecoins just the worst kind of risk. Low risk/reward on a daily basis. Risk of catastrophic collapse on a bad day. It's the type of risk that gets financial companies/complexes into trouble.
- lupire 5y agoStablecoin is only risky while you hold it. You can convert to Bitcoin or Eth to adjust your risk profile, and take profits occasionally in national currency.
- oneoff786 5y agoRussian roulette is only dangerous while you’re playing. In fact, it’s honestly risk free unless it’s your turn.
- eru 5y agoProperly unregulated banks are actually less likely to experience runs. Backing by USD is not required. As you say, anything they can liquidate is good. Doesn't have to be USD. This works best when you are over-capitalised, ie when you have a thick equity cushion, so that when your assets go down in terms of USD, you still have enough balance sheet assets left to cover all your USD obligations. You are right that trying to be stable makes things more systematically risky. If Tesla stock drops by 20% over night, some people are going to lose money, but the finance system won't collapse. If supposedly stable assets drop by 20%, everything can go wrong. That's part of why government backed deposit insurance for banks and too-big-to-fail are problems.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market. How does this happen again 15 years later? Is it because we ineffectively dealt with 2008? A result of the repeal of Glass-Steagall? Or have we over regulated banking to the point the miscreants went underground to build things like crypto? I don't get it. Crashing over and over doesn't seem good for anyone.
- nickelpro 5y agoTechnologically distinct market, even if economically parallel, Glass-Steagall wouldn't have prevented this. The crypto companies have operated almost entirely outside of regulatory oversight prior to the last 18 months or so.
- LatteLazy 5y agoIn this case the damage will be limited to a bunch crypto companies. The issue before was it hit companies we relied on for things like mortgages and current accounts. Crypto companies can just be allowed to fail and no one except their users will be effected. Hence they are not regulated. So even keeping GS (which was limited to big banks and a few similar institutions) wouldn't have made any difference. Not that keeping it would necessarily have been a bad ide...
- unityByFreedom 5y ago> In this case the damage will be limited to a bunch crypto companies. The issue before was it hit companies we relied on for things like mortgages and current accounts. Crypto companies can just be allowed to fail and no one except their users will be effected. I don't buy the argument that crypto lives in a vacuum. People valuing that asset are part of the global economy. The question is, is crypto really as valuable as the crypto exchange markets claim, and do companies assign face value to these assets, or do they account for the amount of risk they deserve?
- LatteLazy 5y agoAt the risk of getting semantic... Value is not a single concept. The value of something to me is different to to you. And for both of us it changes over time. Value cannot really be defined, let alone measured. So we are stuck with prices. And prices are sort of connected to value. But the connection is very non linear. We can know the price of crypto (or gold or shares or credit default swaps). But it's value is purely a matter of personal taste...
- LatteLazy 5y agoOf course, if they have been making a profit for however long they've been open, they should have a rainy day fund to cover those risks...
- delusional 5y ago> Why would anyone buy Tether at this point? There's zero upside potential, after all. Tether, and "stablecoins" in general are known as the casino chips of Crypto. A way to exchange more volatile crypto for what is supposed to be essentially dollars without creating a taxable event. Assuming crypto is still something people want to trade, that's still a valuable service. Tether isn't supposed to be an investment. It's a money laundering scheme to facilitate the other investments outside of the taxable economy and outside of KYC regulation. Seen from that vantage point, staking pools and "potential upside" is actually not desirable.
- grey-area 5y agoTechnically, isn’t selling one asset and buying another precisely the definition of a taxable event? I don’t see how tether helps you avoid taxes unless you’re going to lie about your transactions and hope nobody notices.
- nikanj 5y agoYou answered your own question
- slyfocks 5y agoIt is indeed a taxable event. People who exchange crypto for “stable”coins are generally doing so to stay out of the KYC banking realm so they can lie about their transactions to their country’s tax authorities.
- mateuszf 5y agoMaybe in US, but not in all countries.
- robinduckett 5y agoIn the UK, it is only a taxable event when the coin is exchanged to a "readily convertible asset", i.e. Bitcoin, Mainnet ETH.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CTDOCodebases 5y agoWhy would anyone buy Tether? Because the most liquid trading pairs and futures use USDT. The same companies who borrow USDT from Tether happen to be the same people who run exchanges or act as market makers.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoThey did — is that still true? Will it still be true next month or next year? Seems to me the slow abandonment of Tether has become faster.
- CTDOCodebases 5y agoMaybe. Or maybe the exchanges/market makers are buying back USDT in order to pay back their loans to Tether.
- eru 5y ago> This is how you get a 2008-type crash - loans which seem to be unrelated but are tied to a common market. Eh, the problems in 2008 were ultimately caused by (many) central banks around the globe letting nominal gdp drop. All loans (and dividends etc) are ultimately paid out of aggregate nominal income; so obviously they are all correlated with nominal gdp: it's basically the same as aggregate nominal income.
- funstuff007 5y ago> Traders who deal in commercial paper of real companies that do real stuff don't see Tether present in that market. The dollar amounts are too big to hide. Very similar to Madoff's derivatives transactions. He was so big, but there little evidence of him transacting his main "strategy" in the market.
- NelsonMinar 5y agoNo the big questions with Tether are: do they have backing assets? How much? And where are they? Whose commercial paper is a second tier question. In August 2021 The Economist estimated Tether to be leveraged 383-to-1. That's incredibly unstable. https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/08/07/why-regulators-should-treat-stablecoins-like-banks https://www.economist.com/leaders/2021/08/07/why-regulators-...
- timoth3y 5y ago> whose commercial paper? Perhaps it's in the form of debt from exchanges. Tether could buy short-term notes from the exchanges paying them in Tether -- maybe at a slight premium to make sure the exchanges go along. The terms would stipulate that Tether could call the loan at any time allowing them to quickly pull Tether off the market as needed to maintain their peg. How long the dance can go on would depend on the premium they've offered the exchanges and how much free Tether they've minted for themselves. Obviously, this is all pure speculation.