4 ms·
No bank in the world will loan you money without collateral. Now using your example of a loan based on a Picasso painting, the value of the painting is correlat
by belter 5y ago
No bank in the world will loan you money without collateral. Now using your example of a loan based on a Picasso painting, the value of the painting is correlated to the money supply.
If Picasso decided to go live in Zimbabwe and decided never to sell his paintings to other than Zimbabwe nationals, paying on the local dollar, that would limit the loan the bank can collateralize with the asset, in other words the painting.
The bank does not create money.
"Fractional Reserve Banking: The Myth of Creation of Money" :
https://medium.com/politicoid/fractional-reserve-banking-the-myth-of-creation-of-money-88db3256188f https://medium.com/politicoid/fractional-reserve-banking-the...
- WalterBright 5y ago> No bank in the world will loan you money without collateral. Now using your example of a loan based on a Picasso painting, the value of the painting is correlated to the money supply. That's what I wrote. The value of the painting was created by the painter, and money was created to back it. (And that money is destroyed when the loan is repaid, until the next time the painting is used as collateral.) This is how the money supply (in free banking) naturally rises to match the asset wealth in the economy. > The bank does not create money. Of course it does. Your linked article is simply wrong. Trying to equate it to gold bars is a grossly wrong equivalence.
- belter 5y agoIf Fractional Reserve Banking would create money, then it would not have a problem when all the depositors go at the same time to claim their money at the bank. :-) As the previously mentioned article states, the bank does not create money, it increases the Velocity of Money. "Banks do not create money out of thin air": https://voxeu.org/article/banks-do-not-create-money-out-thin-air https://voxeu.org/article/banks-do-not-create-money-out-thin...
- WalterBright 5y ago> all the depositors go at the same time to claim their money at the bank. If the bank did not create money, and simply loaned out the deposits, the depositors would still not find their money there when they run to get it. Banks loan out a multiple of the deposits, meaning they create money. Your theory that FRB doesn't create money is a fringe one, which should give some pause. What should also give pause is the gold example, which doesn't apply, and the false notion that bank collapses from runs only happen when they use FRB.
- belter 5y ago"The Money Multiplier and the Myth that Just Won’t Die…" https://www.pragcap.com/the-money-multiplier-and-the-myth-that-just-wont-die/ https://www.pragcap.com/the-money-multiplier-and-the-myth-th... "Banking and the Laughable 'Money Multiplier' Myth" https://www.realclearmarkets.com/articles/2016/06/29/banking_and_the_laughable_money_multiplier_myth_102248.html https://www.realclearmarkets.com/articles/2016/06/29/banking...
- WalterBright 5y agoThat went off the rails with: "Money is money and credit is credit. They are not the same thing, they are completely different financial animals." and: "Only the Federal Reserve can create money" How does the author imagine we had money before 1914? Perhaps the author and you would be interested in reading "Monetary History of the United States" by Friedman, an actual expert on this topic.
- belter 5y agoCan't reply to your comment below so will do it here. "Do banks really create money out of thin air?": https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/06/do-banks-really-create-money-out-of-thin-air/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/06/do-banks-really-creat... "...The phrase “banks create money” forms part of the popular discourse, but it conveys an erroneous representation of the banks’ role in the money creation process..." "...Without the correct understanding, the misguided belief that banks create money out of nothing will continue to influence models of the financial sector and monetary policy interventions..." "...The traditional view adopted in the money supply debate is that banks create bank money by granting loans. This explanation is then extended to suggest that banks thereby create money out of nothing. However, this is an inadequate caricature of the process of bank money creation..." "...To an outsider, it appears as if by recording an asset account entry connected to the buyer and by recording a corresponding deposit entry, the bank has created money out of nothing; this is the illusion of the bank having created money..." "...But this is only the prima facie appearance and not the truth of the matter because the outside observer has neglected to acknowledge that the deposit value records the value-for-value exchange conducted through an underlying transaction. In reality, the seller no longer has a house and the buyer now has a house..."