3 ms·
I don't buy it. I'm not intimately familiar with how the monero project is run, but shouldn't you able to pick this up by looking at the PRs? Or are the reposit
by gruez 5y ago
I don't buy it. I'm not intimately familiar with how the monero project is run, but shouldn't you able to pick this up by looking at the PRs? Or are the repository owners just keeping their PRs under wraps and merging them immediately after they're created? Even then, the bigger question is how these changes get deployed. If you're going to change the hashing algorithm, you'll probably have to get most clients on the network to update in advance, otherwise all the people running outdated clients would be on a forked chain. Therefore it seems unlikely that monero insiders would have much of an advantage compared to an observant outsider.
- xur17 5y agoAgreed. The network would grind to a hault if the mining algorithm was changed without notifying everyone first. I have to imagine a new version of the node software is released (fork) that changes the hashing algorithm starting at X block. Anything else would be.. stupid.
- pengaru 5y agoWhen your currency intends to keep changing the algorithm, the protocol itself should describe the algorithm to use and automate the changeover process. It's not the manual aspect that is defending against ASIC miners, it's the non-determinism of what the algorithm is going to be. If you keep it that way for years, it starts looking very deliberate. In this scenario I'd describe the "insiders" as those participating in and following monero's development closely enough to be continuously aware of these changes at the source level. We're not talking about SEC regulated crap where insider trading is well defined, this is all unregulated wild west software land. Insiders are the nerds cloning git repos and building from source, lurking in monero chat rooms all day, etc.
- pengaru 5y agoIt just comes down to how we define "insider" in this scenario. This was years ago now, but at the time at least this wasn't an automated mechanism. So yes, you could follow the repository and pay very close attention, and if you're savvy enough maybe even automate that process to deploy the new miner whenever changes landed. (mine often broke by amdgpu opencl incompatibilities though, it often took some hacking to make the new algo work) But from where I was sitting it was very clear that the manual nature of it created tons of opportunity for the developers and those savvy and close enough to practically be in the same privileged set as developers. Whenever they changed the algorithm the network reset and the hash rate was a tiny fraction of its previous quiescent state, with a low difficulty, for days. I was paying semi close attention at the time, and even being purely manual with a single eGPU mining rig was able to somewhat capitalize on the opportunity created. Practically all my pittance of shares were mined in post-reset low difficulty periods. Those with actual large mining farms normally competing with the full rate difficulty surely were quite productive in those windows. There's no question that the switchovers would kill the hash rate, we can infer from that most the miners were being manually maintained by folks not closely monitoring the upstream repo for every change.