2 ms·
Obligatory reminder that insider trading laws (at least in the US) are about theft of information, not fairness. >KESTENBAUM: And she says while everybody gets
by gruez 5y ago
Obligatory reminder that insider trading laws (at least in the US) are about theft of information, not fairness.
>KESTENBAUM: And she says while everybody gets upset at insider trading because it gives someone an unfair advantage, that is not the legal reason why it gets you into trouble. The argument used these days in court for why it's illegal is that insider trading amounts to stealing information from a company. It's like theft.
>GOLDSTEIN: And so for that reason, proving that someone traded on insider information - that is not enough to convict them. If, say, a financial document from some company blows out the window and you happen to find it sitting there on the sidewalk, Sarah says it's not insider trading for you to use that to make money in the stock market because you didn't steal it.
https://www.npr.org/transcripts/596532106 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/596532106
In the case of public corporations, insider information (eg. this quarter's earnings) belongs to the company and the company has a duty to act in the interests of its shareholders. If you work at that company and trade on that information, that's illegal because the information doesn't belong to you. However, in other markets (eg. commodities or forex), no such "owner" of information exists so "insider trading" is effectively legal[1]. Applying this to the example, it's unclear whether it would count as insider trading. I suppose you could argue that people working on the project has a duty to protect tokenholders, and therefore they should be barred from trading ahead of some announcement, but in this case the insiders seem to be insiders on exchanges, which hold no such obligations.
[1] "Insider trading" in energy markets is not really a thing, because energy markets are largely for producers and users of energy to hedge their production and needs, and that production and those needs are the sort of "inside information" that would move markets. So everyone just kind of gets a free pass to trade on inside information. https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2013-12-19/helicopter-edge-is-better-than-black-edge https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2013-12-19/helico...