3 ms·
Ukraine has been successful in slowing Russia down, but that’s about it. Best case scenario now is Russia and Ukraine settle with Ukraine losing a bunch of ter
by refurb 4y ago
Ukraine has been successful in slowing Russia down, but that’s about it.
Best case scenario now is Russia and Ukraine settle with Ukraine losing a bunch of territory.
Russia gets time to regroup, and if unsatisfied, invades again in another 3-5 years.
Remember, this didn’t start this year, it’s been going on for almost a decade.
Russia can win by simply keeping Ukraine unstable and ungovernable and slowly taking more and more territory. And keeping NATO at bay.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoThe Russians don't have the money to outdo the west, they will fold, no matter what their propaganda department convinces some people to buy. While Putin has a pretty strong grip on the country it's not as profound as the one Stalin had, and it will fail eventually. He will be assassinated or a coup will happen if he doesn't relent in the next year or so.
- cudgy 4y agoPerhaps. Or Putin and the Russian people will galvanize and feel the need to pull the trigger on nuclear weapons and/or shift their economy into a military output machine, causing further instability for Ukraine and the European continent. The US did it when threatened in WW2. What makes us think the Russians are less likely to use nukes or other terrible weapons than the US?
- signatoremo 4y agoBecause it was the matter of survival and existence of Russia as the nation in the WW2? Amazing things happen when you are under attack. What are the same threats to Russia today? They are under no threats from the outside. Simple as that. The issue is that they’ve become increasingly irrelevant. They may work to become a modern economy. Russia is full of educated people, with a proud culture. Or they may rely on their past glory, expanding their empire by interfering with their neighbors. They’ve chosen the latter.
- cudgy 4y agoSo Russia and/or China can annex Mexico into an exclusive military alliance and the US would argue “They are under no threats from the outside (China and Russia). Simple as that.” No way that would be the case. Alarm bells and missiles would be flying over such a move. Why do people not understand this as an equally alarming concern to Russia?
- eveningcoffee 4y agoYou are here missing only one very simple but important fact. Russia nor China are not superpowers. China may become one soon but it is not yet. Russia can be as concerned as it likes to be but if it steps over the line, it will get its ass handled back to it.
- cudgy 4y agoRussia has more nukes than any country in the world. That alone makes them a power to be reckoned with regardless of whether they are a super power by anyone’s definition.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoBecause 1. It's suicide 2. the Russia doesn't -really- need Ukraine and neither does Putin 3. see #1
- cudgy 4y agoPerhaps the US and Europe is pushing things to the point of their own suicide as well. The US (alone) is sending 50+ billion dollars in military aid to Ukraine for a conflict that has only lasted for a couple months. At this rate, the US will send about $300 billion in 1 year! That represents almost 1/2 of the entire US military annual budget and would dwarf the military budget of almost all nations in the world except maybe China. Talk about suicide.
- eveningcoffee 4y agoHow much did wars in Afghanistan and Iraq cost? War in Afghanistan was only important for posturing. This is also the reason why when US decided to leave, it did not look back. Putin of course inferred that it is signal of weakness when it was not. Putin also inferred that Europe trying to keep good relations and keep doing business is signal of weakness. He stepped into trap created by his own delusion.
- lobocinza 4y agoOnly if you ignore Ukrainians sucessfull counter-offensives on Kyiv and Kharkiv. Worst case scenario possibly is a peace deal because, as you said, Russia will invade again in a few years and both sides will be better prepared. Long term the only way for Ukraine independence is the equalization of it's military capabality with that of Russia. This war is a grinding machine causing heavy material and human losses for both sides but Ukraine with international support have better odds than sanctioned Russia. And frankly it's a bargain for the European democracies to support Ukraine now and later get a better aligned energy supplier and a weaker ideological enemy. What's at play for Russia is the monopoly over European energy as Donetsk and Crimea have large recent-discovered oil & gas reserves. An independent Ukraine would certainly take over this market.
- refurb 4y agoUkraine will never be equal to Russia militarily. Its 1/10th the population. It’s in Ukraines best interest to find some co-existence with Russia at an acceptable cost. NATO is not going to do it for them and in fact is happy to sacrifice Ukraine if it benefits the overall security of Western Europe.
- lobocinza 4y agoIsrael is 1/10th of the population of Egypt and survived the Arab War where it was attacked by Egypt, Palestine, Transjordan, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and Yemen. And the Arabs received Soviet support. Also the US lost at Vietnam. The Soviets lost at Afghanistan and Russia is a shadow of what the Soviet Union was. Total population means nothing as it ignores that Russia demographics is skewed towards old women and that a large share of the youngers are from ethnic minorities. Russia is struggling to replenish losses and haven't mass conscripted. And sheer numbers alone aren't enough to win a war. Equipment, training, moral, tactics and logistics are also important.
- jnsaff2 4y agoAhem, more than 1/4 (41.2M vs 145.5M). "acceptable cost" here is losses in fighting for freedom or genocide. There is no choice at all, in case of fighting you have chances, in case of giving up it's death/rape/torture/gulags/deportations anyway.
- kcb 4y agoSure Sure. And the encirclment of Kyiv will be complete any day now.
- refurb 4y agoWill Russia take the entire country? No. Will the war end with a much smaller Ukraine? Most definitely.
- eveningcoffee 4y agoIt is possible but there are at least two serious vulnerabilities for Russia's forces. If UA can recognize them and exploit fully, large part of Russian army will collapse.