3 ms·
It's a zero sum because the persons and financial resources buying what you have to sell is a finite number. If they buy from me they probably wont buy from you
by belter 5y ago
It's a zero sum because the persons and financial resources buying what you have to sell is a finite number. If they buy from me they probably wont buy from you.
This is independent of the relative merits of the products we are both selling. Maybe I forced my products to be shown in the major television channels, because I also own the television channels and you dont.
- solveit 5y agoNew persons are born every day and financial resources are a bookkeeping tool. If I make something new and you make something new then we can trade our products and we both gained without anyone losing out. It is not true to say the world is zero-sum.
- belter 5y agoThe Federal Reserve who controls the M1 supply would like a word with you.:-) There is a limited amount of goods and services you can sell to the inhabitants of a planet with a population of 7.7 Billion. What if the planet would have only a population of 7? Each person owning one of the 7 continents? Let's say the persons owning Africa and the person owning North America, due to some meteorological disaster, and unfortunate investments, had to sell their respective continents to the hotshot owning Europe? If the money supply is infinite, then has no value. Now from the finite money supply in the world who is going to gain the most?
- thethimble 5y agoYou’re being downvoted because you're conflating two concepts that are related but not the same: the money supply and economic output (GDP). Economic output is non-zero sum. Consumption/production scales up and down elastically. The money supply is adjusted independently in order to drive “ideal” output growth while maintaining “ideal” inflation levels.
- belter 5y agoThanks for replying. I appreciate it. But you fail to note the creation of a market happens by destroying another. Amazon vs Book Shops, Uber vs Taxis, Cars vs Faster Horses, Netflix vs Theater Industry and DVD Rentals.[2] There is a limit of resources and economic output per year, the ones owning the more productive processes will get a progressive bigger share of the output. More and more, lots of activities are zero-sum and the long term is a complete zero-sum. [3] It's not a view from mainstream economists, because many do not want to be seen as heirs to Karl Marx ( an Economist let's not forget, not a politician). It's also a discourse popular from a certain political current, that spouses the "we can all benefit mantra". I prefer to use Constrain Theory [1], and be reminded that if somebody creates a more efficient Amazon, faster, cheaper, better then Amazon will not prosper. If somebody opens a new service, or creates a new product, there will less disposable income from the customers of this product to shop at Amazon. Reminds me of a story, normally told with several variations so my details are not exact. When Henry Ford II toured some factory, he taunted some workers with the fact increased Robotic Automation would make Ford less dependent on the workers. The workers replied asking Ford how many cars he was expecting the Robots would buy? [1] "Exponential Economist Meets Finite Physicist": https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/04/economist-meets-physicist... [2] "Capitalism: A zero-sum game": https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/capitalism-a-zero-sum-game-110050700073_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/capitalism... [3] "The Zero-Sum Economy": https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/zero-sum-economy-fuels-high-inequality-by-adair-turner-2018-08?barrier=accesspaylog https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/zero-sum-econom...
- thethimble 5y ago> you fail to note the creation of a market happens by destroying another This isn’t true. If you go back to the origin of human civilization, economic “output” was limited to survival - food/shelter. Today survival represents an ever-smaller fraction of economic activity. Where did this additional activity come from if it was limited to replace preceding activity? Similarly real gdp per capita has been increasing since the beginning of time. How can this be possible if the economy is zero sum?
- WalterBright 5y ago> It's a zero sum because the persons and financial resources buying what you have to sell is a finite number. Nope. It's obviously false by inspection - the GDP grows most years. At the micro level, suppose I give Picasso $25 worth of art supplies. He then creates a painting with it worth $1,000,000. This painting becomes a valuable asset that he can then use as collateral for a loan. Banks loan money by creating it. I.e. $999,975.00 magically appeared! I wish the schools would teach this stuff. In my experience, very very few people understand this.
- belter 5y agoThat is called leverage and only exists because the government prints money. You are now seeing the results of that unfettered activity. The bank did not create money, the bank loaned money up to the percentage the government allowed it to leverage itself... "The Fed's Tools for Influencing the Economy": https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/monetary-policy-recession.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/economics/08/monetary-... "Reserve Requirements: The Federal Reserve also has the ability to adjust banks' reserve requirements, which determines the level of reserves a bank must hold in comparison to specified deposit liabilities. Based on the required reserve ratio, the bank must hold a percentage of the specified deposits in vault cash or deposits with the Federal Reserve banks..." "...By adjusting the reserve ratios applied to depository institutions, the Fed can effectively increase or decrease the amount these facilities can lend. For example, if the reserve requirement is 5% and the bank receives a deposit of $500, it can lend out $475 of the deposit as it is only required to hold $25, or 5%. If the reserve ratio is increased, the bank is left with less money to lend out on each dollar deposited..." The monetary value of Picasso work, is tied to the competition between the ones who have a part of the current money supply, and how much they want a Picasso. If Picasso could produce 10,000 paintings per day, so that each person in planet could have one, we would not be talking about millions of dollars per painting. So no money is being created from nothing. It's leverage plus application of constrain theory. The main constraint being the amount of money printed and the leverage on the assets.
- WalterBright 5y ago> That is called leverage and only exists because the government prints money. This existed long before the government took over the banks and decoupled it from gold. It's called "fractional reserve banking". > The bank did not create money It absolutely did. It's how fractional reserve banking works. The "fetters" are the collateral backing up the loan. The money is destroyed when the loan gets paid back. I know it sounds like magic, but it isn't.