3 ms·
Let's do some back of the envelope calculations. We are almost 50 millions in Argentina, and excluding the people that is too young or too old or has a job that
by gus_massa 5y ago
Let's do some back of the envelope calculations. We are almost 50 millions in Argentina, and excluding the people that is too young or too old or has a job that avoid taxes, let's assume only 15 millions have a credit card. Most of us have only one or two credit card (Visa & Amex or Master so they have a disjoint BIN).
The biggest bank is the National Bank, that has like a 30% of the share of deposits https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancos_de_Argentina https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bancos_de_Argentina I couldn't find the number of clients of each bank, but let's assume a 5% of share for each of the big banks, that's like 1 million each.
The 9 free digits for each bank, i.e. 10^9 possibilities and only 1^6 clients, so only 1/1000 of the numbers are valid. I think he didn't change the check digit, but he increased some digits, so it's somewhat like sampling only in the subset of numbers with a correct check digit. If you don't ask your nearby mathematician that says that multiplying by 2 a number in a modulo 10 check, you can estimate that with his method he sampled numbers with 10x more probability and only 1/100 of the numbers were valid. It's in the bruteforce range, but perhaps too low for a manual data entry.
Assuming each bank use the first 2 digits of their 9 digits for the branch (one in each capital city of each province, but some provinces have many big enough cities, and some cities here are huge, perhaps I need 3 digits...). Anyway, there are 2 fixed digits for the branch and 7 for the number of client. If not all branches have the same number of clients, and some of them don't even exits (if they have like branches 97-98-99 that are reserved for future use), then it makes it easy to guess a number if he noticed that BIN+branch is fixed because he is looking at the card of the clients near his business. I'd estimate x5 or x10 easier, but my handwaving is not strong enough to give a good justification.
So, with a lot of estimations, in ¿1/10? of his attempts he got a real card number.
About the CVC2, my guess is that he used a random number, the server noticed something strange and reported it silently, but the article is very light in details.