3 ms·
From a technical point of view I agree, but I haven't encountered any desktop applications that require Wayland and don't work on X11. It's almost exclusively t
by jeroenhd 5y ago
From a technical point of view I agree, but I haven't encountered any desktop applications that require Wayland and don't work on X11. It's almost exclusively the other way around in my experience.
I'm sure there are some applications out there that rely on Wayland support, but Wayland is unusable for proper remote tech support without some extensions to the API that Wayland developers don't want to add (notably, the ability to send input to running applications).
There are workarounds (hooking directly into the input system, for example) but those work despite Wayland, not because of it.
I'm willing to go as far as to say that by clicking the "fix me" button, the end user will probably end up fixing more applications than it breaks.
- simonh 5y agoThat’s not something you or the developer if this software have the authority to decide.
- mwcampbell 5y agoI think we can leave that up to the users of the software. If the users grant the developer that authority by running the software, and they're happy with the results, then who are we to say otherwise? True, we can decide not to use the software ourselves. But I don't think people like us that are savvy and contrarian enough to likely be affected by this pragmatic solution are the intended target users of this product anyway, at least not on the receiving end (sometimes called the "host" or "server"), where IIUC Wayland needs to be disabled.
- simonh 5y agoThe problem is the users are not informed what the software is about to do and have no way to evaluate the consequences.
- FieryTransition 4y agoExactly, if it's not something that can be isolated/determined to ONLY affecting the app itself, it shouldn't be done, and if you really really want to do it, there should be a big fat warning, but I really wouldn't..
- thayne 5y ago> without some extensions to the API that Wayland developers Depends on what what you mean by "Wayland developers". Wlroots, and thus sway, support such extensions and I think KDE is open to standardizing such extensions. Gnome supports remote desktop through an xdg portal. The problem is that, as with several other things, all of the compositors haven't agreed on a single standard.