6 ms·
OPNsense DEC740 Ryzen Embedded Fanless Firewall Review (2021)
- walterbell 5y agoVideo review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=853y4ShbpZg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=853y4ShbpZg
- 0x0000000 4y agoExcited to see more low-power, but still powerful, networking gear. I run OPNsense on an old Dell SFF, which is awesome since I can stick a few expansion cards and have 10G networking for <$200, but it draws 60W on average. Cutting that down would be great, but the reviewed device here is still 3-4x more expensive so its hard to justify the upgrade. I had previously tried an ARM-based "Espressobin" which was only about $50 but had no 10G and little-to-no official support, couldn't even reliably boot into Linux. Good signs for the future though!
- zokier 4y ago> I had previously tried an ARM-based "Espressobin" which was only about $50 but had no 10G and little-to-no official support, couldn't even reliably boot into Linux. hmm. There apparently is a successor "macchiatobin" that has 2xSFP+, but comments of poor software support is disconcerting https://macchiatobin.net/ https://macchiatobin.net/
- kevin_nisbet 4y agoI have one of the upper models (DEC850) I bought last year, and been meaning to write about it. Overall, it's been great, although I haven't gone through and done as much analysis as the linked post. I should've moved to a dedicated home firewall sooner, but wasn't super high on my priorities. But with all the problems home modems/routers seem to be having, along with an upgrade to fiber internet that included a modem with hard coded default credentials that could not be changed I made the switch. Only glitch I've noticed is a few problems with unbound dns, that I need to spend some more time on. DNS over TLS doesn't seem to be working for me, and I've had a couple glitches now when there are power fluctuations that I have to restart DNS after boot. But that could easily be something wonky in my setup and need to do more work to isolate the issue. Overall, I would recommend for anyone who wants something a bit better than just the consumer grade stuff provided by an ISP, and for small business, remote sites, etc.
- xvector 4y agoUnbound was also glitchy for me. I had to switch to Dnsmasq on the firewall. Optionally you can forward to AdGuard Home for DoH/DoT and ad/tracker blocking.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoPaying $700+ for something like this is just silly. OPNsense and pfSense are both charging massive markups on this hardware. pfSense doubles the price over the exact same box you can get from AliExpress or ebay. Buy a standard Ryzen mobo, a low-end recent Ryzen CPU, undervolt it, toss some ram in, an old SATA SSD, and a dual or quad port PCIe adapter off ebay. Or just buy an old Dell SFF PC; you can get your choice of how powerful a processor you want. If you want the embedded/fanless setup, then buy one of the aliexpress/ebay boxes. Qotom is one such seller, I believe. As someone with a ton of experience with opnsense: their release style is extremely irritating. The only way to get security updates is to conduct a full upgrade of the system. The UI is clunky, outdated, full of useless "help text", and almost seems to be purposefully designed to use confusing field names and terminology. Debugging problems is difficult at best with inconsistent logging infrastructure. I've also never once had a config restore go properly, something I've tried to do several times because I generally get about 2-3 years out of an opnsense install before enough stuff has broken that I need to reinstall from scratch. Last but not least: they now routinely ignore their support forum except for the most simple, common problems. Every time I've had a problem, I've found a corresponding post in their forum which has gone gnored by their employees.
- walterbell 4y ago> OPNsense and pfSense are both charging massive markups on this hardware. Hardware remains one of the few viable business models for open-source software. The combination of features on this particular device have literally not been sold before, so in this particular case, the price may be somewhat justified IF they are also providing regular UEFI firmware security fixes. With such high margins, it's surprising there are no hardware clones for AMD firewalls. Is that due to CPU shortages? Protectli is a success story for Intel firewalls, where the open (coreboot) product earns a price premium and opaque clones expand the market.
- briHass 4y agoWith the PC Engines' line basically EOL, what is the best hardware to run a home setup < 2Gbps WAN for around or below $200? I'm not too keen on buying a largely unsupported Intel box off AliExpress that has a 40% chance of being DOA. I suppose there isn't much profit to be made for a lower-end box, but I'd prefer to stick with *sense instead of wasting time learning Mikrotik's OS, even though they have some great price-points.
- c0l0 4y agoZotac ZBOX Series have always been absolutely solid for me, but they are not that cheap any more... I bought my latest x86-based router from AliExpress, and never regretted it! Review available here: https://johannes.truschnigg.info/reviews/2021-01_fwbox/ https://johannes.truschnigg.info/reviews/2021-01_fwbox/
- linza 4y agoI switched from PC engines to https://protectli.com/ https://protectli.com/ and I'm happy so far, although it's more expensive. I haven't tried anything else yet, so just a single data point.
- __turbobrew__ 4y agoSeconded. I have a protectli vault 4 port and it can handle 1Gb/s traffic fine. If you want to use OpenBSD beware that you might not be able to push 1Gb/s with protectli devices. I had issues with OpenBSD pushing full gigabit, most likely due to all of the security mitigations.
- zeroflow 4y agoIf you want to safe some bucks and don't need coreboot or local support, you can opt for various chinese resellers like topton or qotom which also provide firewalls based on the same boards. I'm running a J4125 based topton box and it's running fine for about 2 weeks now.
- c0l0 4y agoIt would be __very__ interesting to learn how much bandwidth this beautiful beast can saturate with cake managing SQM (under Linux, esp. OpenWrt), and if proper support for ECC UDIMM is implemented. What an awesome piece of networking machinery!
- walterbell 4y agoGiven the dire security of COTS routers and Wi-Fi access points, we need alternatives which support open OS + coreboot. $200 used: The venerable PC Engines APU2 is a fanless x86 AMD 10W TDP router with 4GB ECC RAM, TPM 2.0 and GPIO pins, open schematics and coreboot, which can run pfSense, OPNsense, OpenBSD, Linux, FreeBSD and OpenWRT, with virtualization support. mPCIe slots for WiFi, LTE & mSATA. Constrained by supply chain at present. $200 used: HP t730 and t620 Plus thin clients have an AMD SoC with similar TDP to PC Engines APU2. $200+: MIPS-based Ubiquiti EdgeRouter Lite/4/6/8 can run Linux and OpenBSD (octeon/MIPS), but is also supply chain constrained. $200+: Intel-based https://protectli.com/ https://protectli.com/ (coreboot) and virtualization-capable multi-NIC mini PCs s with unknown UEFI, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31451142 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31451142 $400 AMD/Xilinx wildcard dev board for Robotics, KR260 has Arm SoC, Xilinx FGPA and multiple 1GbE ports + 10GbE SFP, backordered 20 weeks, https://www.servethehome.com/amd-xilinx-kria-kr260-robotics-kit-launched/ https://www.servethehome.com/amd-xilinx-kria-kr260-robotics-... $400: ASRock 4x4 dual-NIC has Ryzen Embedded or 4000-series SoC with Realtek NICs, questionable BIOS and limited support focus on Linux/BSD. $400 used: HP t740 thin client with Ryzen Embedded is Mac Mini size, with PCIe slot for low-profile quad-port or SFP NIC, https://www.servethehome.com/hp-t740-thin-client-review-tinyminimicro-with-pcie-slot-amd-ryzen/ https://www.servethehome.com/hp-t740-thin-client-review-tiny.... Some SOHO networking devices made by Microtik, QNAP and Ubiquiti contain Arm SoCs made by Amazon's Annapurna Labs, who also make AWS Nitro silicon, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annapurna_Labs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annapurna_Labs
- KennyBlanken 4y agoAn irritating thing: the t620 used to be barely worth $40-50 until someone started snapping them up and then charging a huge (100%+) markeup with "opnsense" in the title. You might as well just buy a Dell SFF with a low-powered i5 at that point.
- walterbell 4y agoDell Wyse 5060 thin clients (similar AMD SoC to PC Engines APU and HP t620 Plus) have also jumped from their $40 eBay prices. Ryzen Embedded SoC includes 10GbE networking, but until this Decisio device, I've not seen any OEM using it. Maybe there was a chicken-and-egg issue with OS drivers.
- aborsy 4y agoProtectli and Qotom boxes run OPNSense well.
- frzen 4y agoI have issues with webRTC and OPNsense at home. I presume from NAT type. I end up being stuck on TURN sometimes. I've tried adding a 'static port' as an outbound hybrid NAT rule which improved things but not in every scenario. Other than that opnsense on an old ewaste HP SFF PC has been excellent. My only upgrade would be something lower power and fanless. Or to add it virtualised on my homelab R330, but security and no Internet when I break that wouldn't be a better situation than now
- newman314 4y agoI started looking at these upon learning that Sonic might be bringing (10G!) service to my location soon. If anyone has any experience running 10G on these, I would love to hear more about it as my current ER4 is not going to be able to keep up. The alternative would be to build a small x64 system with 10G but I'd like to find a solution that has low power consumption.
- zokier 4y agoPossibly stupid question, but how do people do Wifi with these the wired-only routers? Just buy a normal full-featured Wifi router and let it do its routing, or can you get some dumb AP-only and offload all the routing on the more powerful wired box?
- dementik 4y agoThe latter. For example, I am using Unifi Wifi devices just for wifi, another box does all the NAT-stuff etc.
- bpye 4y agoI have an Intel box as a router, a managed switch and then a Unifi AP - there are certainly more parts, but each component does it's job relatively well.
- walterbell 4y agoMicro PC with quad-port Intel NIC as virtualized router + UniFi AP, but moving to OpenWRT on APU2 with mPCIe Wi-Fi card.
- Sebb767 4y agoI have an UniFi AP Nano flashed with OpenWRT which only acts as access point. Highly recommended, it's pretty cheap and has a solid range.
- zokier 4y agoIs it this sort of setup where wifi and lan devices are bridged together? https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/wifi/dumbap https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/network/wifi/dumbap Somehow I fell into rabbit hole reading into how OpenWRT apparently is in process of changing how they do switches (related to bridging?), from homebrew swconfig to upstream DSA https://forum.openwrt.org/t/mini-tutorial-for-dsa-network-config/96998 https://forum.openwrt.org/t/mini-tutorial-for-dsa-network-co... which seems to impact the setup a bit
- 4y ago
- tedunangst 4y agoThis is the first device I've ever seen using AMD's on CPU 10G Ethernet.
- egberts1 4y agoI snapped up a Dell Precision R710 with 92GB RAM. Helluva beast, there. But I’m happy with running some 23 VPS, a custom firewall that blocks QUIC/UDP and a transparent Squid that blocks DNS over HTTP. All that for $80. Sprung for some cheap spinning platters for a couple of separate RAID5s. Oh, Proxmox is my choice of VM manager. Only problem with netfilter/nftables is their inability to decremental IP TTL.