3 ms·
39 day old low karma account. Normally, I think "what the hell let's have this conversation" but RU/UA are in a hot war, and comments of this nature to speculat
by ggm 5y ago
39 day old low karma account. Normally, I think "what the hell let's have this conversation" but RU/UA are in a hot war, and comments of this nature to speculation of war's widening effects need to be read in the context of active disinformation and destabilising behaviour online.
Why would a low karma account be used to make this speculative statement?
- throw1230 5y agobit of ad hominem. They already gave sources, so anyone can take a look and make their call
- ggm 5y agoYes, absolutely acknowledge it's a bit ad-hommy. But, the question stands: "the Russians diddit" had to be seen in the context we're in. Remember, a shitload of buuut Chyna is washup of US domestic politics and not actually about Covid. Anyone can take a look and make the call is "do the research restated" btw. That's a Q call. Maybe that's ad hommy too? All getting very meta.
- Jerrrry 5y agowhataboutism is whataboutism. judge comments on their own standing merits. OP shouldn't have to tie together identities because you're too short sighted to "do you own research" and evaluate a comment without reverting to lame fucking dog whistles. "someone with a checkmark tell me how to feel about this talking point" - you
- cma 5y agoThey presented a false dichotomy though. With no evidence yet that this one has ability for enhanced spread, both alternatives they gave imply that it does.
- hadeohedron 5y agoThank you for pointing that out, as a guy who excelled at physics and failed biology I just assumed it had an enhanced spread. I'll edit the post to reflect that.
- hadeohedron 5y agoSome people are genuinely fairly new to HN. I only became aware of this place a few months ago in following the ACOUP blog. But that's indistinguishable from astroturf accounts to an outsider so tell you what, I have a reddit account I've used for over a year and post regularly on. I've posted a link to your comment as a self-post on that account: https://www.reddit.com/user/ADotSapiens/comments/uue2sb/yo_verify_me_for_your_hn_standards/ https://www.reddit.com/user/ADotSapiens/comments/uue2sb/yo_v... Feel free to let that additional internet footprint act as some kind of bona fides.
- ggm 5y agoAn interesting approach. Actually, quite smart I think because you have a deep high karma post history in there. Well done.
- hadeohedron 5y agoI've got an older account if you still want to establish my sincerity although I lost the password and never was able to recover it. That doesn't count for much but if you chuck the corpus of it and /adotsapiens in an authorship verification program it'll spit out a match. https://reddit.com/user/malariadandelion https://reddit.com/user/malariadandelion You'll find it's all consistent with a white British politically opinionated nerd between the ages of 20 and 25, employed in a succession of blue-collar jobs, because that's the real deal.
- Jerrrry 5y ago"dont feed the trolls," tell him to go fuck himself, you make everyone else look "like a russian troll" by kneeling to these ungenuine, discussion-destroying idiots.