4 ms·
I think central authorities absolutely must make that call. Who else is going to decide how to dole out a scarce social resource? Americanizing healthcare is
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I think central authorities absolutely must make that call. Who else is going to decide how to dole out a scarce social resource? Americanizing healthcare is obviously not a good choice given how much worse it does overall by basically every measure (unless you're rich and don't give a toss about other people).
I certainly agree that central authorities can be better. But that's kind of a truism.
What alternative options do you have in mind? Admittedly I'm short on alternative ideas.
- civilized 4y agoI understand why people don't want money to completely decide who gets health care. But I don't think it should be a complete non-factor either. If I've worked hard and saved diligently for an emergency, and an emergency arrives, I feel I should be able to tell a doctor "will you treat me? I have money". But if you insist upon perfect equality of health care access, I guess it can't be. Some central authority has to decide if anyone is allowed to treat you, regardless of what you've saved for the eventuality.
- Waterluvian 4y agoMedical tourism will always be a thing for the rich. But I personally do not see an argument for driving a social service, even if only slightly, with capitalism. Perhaps that’s part of my developing thought on the matter: the public system paid by tax dollars should be equitable to all. But by all means, take your credit card to Pepsi Presents: For Profit Medical Centre and get a full work up.
- civilized 4y agoWhat makes the cut of a "social service"? Wouldn't it be anything people really need? Basic food staples, for example? China tried socializing food production, and it worked terribly. Production tripled when they re-privatized it and let farmers grow for themselves. People do a better job when they get to keep the rewards. US health care isn't capitalist in this sense of rewarding a good job. It's the worst of both worlds: a system whose regulations are superbly adapted to optimize profit for the administrative class at the expense of both doctors and patients.
- dijit 4y agoThis is not an interesting conversation honestly. Some Americans think that the US Healthcare way is “the right way but Slightly Off-Track(tm)” and will not be suaded. You asked a direct question, though, to what extent do social services exist. Social services exist to ensure that we all have a decent foundation on which to conduct our business of living. For some that will be as you say, providing basic food and housing. In fact in Sweden food is given to children for free in school; however in the UK it is only poor students that get it. In Sweden water is free, in the UK it’s charged but it’s a utility that cannot be turned off. Everyone draws the line somewhere else, but the basis is meant to be that we have a solid foundation. Unexpected medical expenses shouldn’t decimate a household economy for a decade, it doesn’t matter how unprepared the household is. But this is my personal feeling. In addition: tying health insurance to employment and having at-will working conditions strikes me as ensuring compliance/docility in the work place, which I don’t believe in.
- cjblomqvist 4y agoEven though quite cheap in most places, water is not necessarily free in Sweden - at least not according to the bill I receive every month... (I believe if you knock on someone's door and ask for water you can't say no to that person - if within reason - and there are usually lots of public/free places to get water to drink)
- civilized 4y ago> This is not an interesting conversation honestly. "Please don't post shallow dismissals" - HN Guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > Some Americans think that the US Healthcare way is “the right way but Slightly Off-Track(tm)” and will not be suaded. "Be kind. Don't be snarky... Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community." - HN Guidelines
- dijit 4y ago1) it's not a shallow dismissal if neither position is interested in having a conversation. 2) it's not unkind to point out the truth, it's not possible to persuade people that the American healthcare system has a fundamental architectural problem, they believe wholeheartedly that it would work if it wasn't for the <insert consequential factor here> it's not an intellectually honest conversation, it's shallow, everyone has dug in. it's boring.
- ricochet11 4y agothere is private healthcare available in the uk for those who want to pay. it isnt nhs or nothing.
- civilized 4y agoI'm not saying otherwise. I was replying to a specific comment that I did not interpret to be referring to a specific real health system.