3 ms·
"Any of you that have the N6005 model and tried to use 32GB+, I would be curious to know if your unit can successfully complete a full pass of memtest86+. I hav
by Animats 5y ago
"Any of you that have the N6005 model and tried to use 32GB+, I would be curious to know if your unit can successfully complete a full pass of memtest86+. I have the N6005 Topton model and it will recognize and boot with 2x16GB modules, but it will not complete a pass of memtest86+."
Uh oh.
Also, if you need that much memory in a firewall, its queues are too big and you're adding substantial latency.
- toast0 5y ago> Also, if you need that much memory in a firewall, its queues are too big and you're adding substantial latency. Maybe it's stateful and you've got a whole lot of connections? Or in this case, they're planning to run VMs and things on the box, so might need more ram for that.
- dijit 5y agoThese appliances can also be caching load balancers or caching reverse proxies. Which can make very good use of ram.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gigel82 5y agoI have the N6005 variant but haven't tried with 32Gb, because Intel specifically lists 16Gb as the maximum memory in the processor specifications: https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/212327/intel-pentium-silver-n6005-processor-4m-cache-up-to-3-30-ghz.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/212327/... FWIW, I'm not using it as bare OS firewall. Instead, it's running Debian with pfSense in a VM with 2 passthrough NICs (though I'm considering replacing Debian with Proxmox).
- zamadatix 5y agoVery often for the lower end consumer CPUs those spec sheet max RAM numbers are just what they've validated works reliably with most RAM modules not the actual limit. Oftentimes it works fine with the right modules, other times it says it works but if you test it it won't, and other times it's the actual hard cap of what it can support in which case you'll get something from works but doesn't recognize the second module to doesn't boot at all. It sounds like this one might fall into either the "doesn't work right" case or the "only works right with certain modules" case. It could also just be strain on the memory controller and need to be either slower RAM or ultra fast RAM that will cap out at a much lower than rated speed in the box instead of middle rung RAM which doesn't handle being run in strained scenarios at full speed well. I don't usually go out of my way to stick more in than is supported unless I can find reliable reports from others that get it working or just happen to have the sticks sitting next to me but I have been very successful going over the spec sheet limits and still passing a day of memtesting (and then years of use). Particularly for laptops and embedded class CPUs, not so much in desktop or server CPUs.
- tenebrisalietum 5y agoMaybe I want to run `ntopng` and also caching nginx on it.