3 ms·
Look even waiting 3 months is already a failure of the speedy requirement. Saying well 1 year is too long but edge cases isn’t a minor issue… No anyone ever hi
by Retric 5y ago
Look even waiting 3 months is already a failure of the speedy requirement. Saying well 1 year is too long but edge cases isn’t a minor issue… No anyone ever hitting 1 year is clear evidence of total failure of the system to even pretend to care about this issue.
- mlyle 5y ago> Look even waiting 3 months is already a failure of the speedy requirement. 3-4 months to get a criminal case together, with discovery requirements, etc, seems reasonable. > No anyone ever hitting 1 year is clear evidence of total failure of the system to even pretend to care about this issue. I don't agree. Terrible stuff happens occasionally-- it is not evidence that every element of the system is broken everywhere. IMO the big issue is bail and pre-trial detention. Yes, criminal cases being in limbo is bad (and the constitutional right of speedy trial is important)-- but a lot of the reason why they take longer now than in the 18th century is because of additional protections for defendants.