3 ms·
Aside from varying paces at which children learn, temperament makes a big difference too. I remember in elementary school, there was a subject I didn't like.
by aidenn0 4y ago
Aside from varying paces at which children learn, temperament makes a big difference too. I remember in elementary school, there was a subject I didn't like. Finally in 5th grade, I decided to try a different approach for one grading period. I did not participate in that subject. As in, when the teacher said to get out the materials, I instead got out a novel and read it. I turned in no work and did no homework.
When my report card came out, I was astonished to find I had a D (the lowest passing grade). My lesson for that quarter: it is impossible to fail at school (this lesson proved to generalize all the way through high school). At this point, I stopped putting any effort at school into something I didn't find personally gratifying. Most of my fellow cohort of "smart kids" were mystified by this; they would go through an existential crisis in the very rare event that they got a B+. Pretty much any of the straight-A students could have had almost-straight-As with 10% of the effort they put in to ensure they would never get a B+.
When I finally reached college, it became possible to fail, but still not particularly easy. I would skip evening exams to save myself the trouble of having to reschedule my weekly D&D session. I only studied when failing an exam would put me in danger of being kicked out of school (this happened maybe two or three times). I graduated with a C average.
I'm not sure what the moral of this story is other than to say that some kids will study no matter the difficulty of the material while other kids will not.
- stocknoob 4y agoYou did a n=1 study to show GPA is a proxy for conscientiousness. https://psychology.okstate.edu/faculty/jgrice/psyc4333/FiveFactor_GPA_JPSP.pdf https://psychology.okstate.edu/faculty/jgrice/psyc4333/FiveF...
- aidenn0 4y agoI'm not entirely convinced it's a very good proxy (at least for the hard sciences). Certainly in my physics classes, raw-intellect trumped conscientiousness; using tidiness as a proxy for conscientiousness and "holds an advanced degree from a distinguished university" as a proxy for GPA, a walk-through of the professors offices in that same department would also dispute that. I think GPA is closer to a proxy for (A + g) * (B + conscientiousness) with values A and B varying from school to school and department to department (as well as the threshold for "perfect" varying). I had 3 roommates with higher conscientiousness than me flunk out, so YMMV. [edit] While we are talking personality traits, I think a high GPA is probably also a proxy for neuroticism; certainly many of the straight-A students exhibited these traits (as does the child of mine who gets the best grades). FWIW I score low in both conscientiousness and neuroticism on a Big Five test. [edit] changed from "not convinced this is true" to "not convinced it's a very good proxy"
- stocknoob 4y agoYep, per the paper the mean correlation was about .26, which is still fairly strong. “Proxy” isn’t great phrasing, “correlates with” is better.
- aidenn0 4y agoWow, I completely missed the link in your earlier comment. Looks like my theory about neuroticism was not supported by that paper though.
- lazide 4y agoDid it help you or hurt you? One could argue it was a failing on your parents to set proper boundaries/discipline. I’m a lot of environments, you’d certainly not be helped by it. If you did well though, then who is to say?
- aidenn0 4y ago> Did it help you or hurt you? My gut feeling is that I was successful in spite of these things, not because of these things. With counterfactuals there's no way to be sure though. > One could argue it was a failing on your parents to set proper boundaries/discipline. I’m a lot of environments, you’d certainly not be helped by it. My parents did everything short of beating me to try and get me to do my homework. After school they sat me at the dining room table with nothing but my textbooks, pencil, and paper. I had to have my list of HW assignments signed off on by my teacher; if it wasn't signed I wasn't allowed to go out and play after school. All of that resulted in me sometimes doing my homework. By the time I was in high school they loosened up on the structure just because they believed that I only had 4 years left to figure out how to do this on my own, but I still was banned from attending various social events because of my lack of effort in school. By the end of 10th grade, I had grown distant from my main group of friends just because I essentially never hung out with them outside of school so there was a lot of missing shared-experiences. As a parent now, I have no idea what they could have done differently. My own personal nightmare is one of my kids acting like I did (despite my parents saying I was the "easy kid")...
- lazide 4y agoI was the same way, and share the nightmare with kids. Personally i’ve spent a lifetime learning how to say No to things I don’t want to do (very hard) and finding the things that work for me. It’s far from perfect, and it has sometimes come at the cost of heavy mistakes before I figured out why something wasn’t working. It does give me the ability to explain and help my kids try and find what works for them, and I have been materially successful enough to afford them options sometimes. Which is huge. I’ve been very lucky. I’ve also faced many hard truths that others have refused to, and worked my ass off too, to get there. I still do need to work my ass off every day. One consolation perhaps - I have several friends who were similar that I grew up with whose parents didn’t stop short at beatings. They succeeded very well in a specific environment afterwards (military), but at the cost of non-trivial mental health issues that are hard to properly describe. A inability to say No to an authority figure being one of them, perhaps, even when it leads to catastrophe. And a severe difficulty in trusting themselves to be independent thinkers. They’ve objectively done well for themselves by societies standards, as have I. But each of us has our own regrets. Such is life I guess?
- asiachick 4y agohow did you get into college with Cs?
- aidenn0 4y agoMainly that it was easier to get into college 25 years ago, but also I scored in the top 1% on the SATs. I also was a bit scared of not getting into college, so I managed to get my GPA up to a 2.9 by the end of junior year (which included a metaphorical rolling-over and showing my belly to my English teacher, who was giving me bad grades out of spite).
- t-3 4y agoMost colleges don't care, especially if your standardized test scores are high enough. The main problem is with obtaining scholarships, they will care about grades a lot. I left before completing even a single semester because I hated it, but my 2.0 GPA didn't stop me from getting admitted anywhere.
- barry-cotter 4y agoCompetitive colleges are a small minority in US. Less than 300 colleges reject more students than they accept. CUNY isn’t the only college with no entrance standards (open enrollment) and community colleges are also open enrollment and have transfer agreements for fours year colleges. Lots of countries have similar institutions.