3 ms·
Some other brands have level 2 driver assistance technology as a standard feature. All of these can operate the steering wheel, brakes, and accelerator, and re
by kube-system 5y ago
Some other brands have level 2 driver assistance technology as a standard feature. All of these can operate the steering wheel, brakes, and accelerator, and require the driver to intervene if they make mistakes.
The major difference is that Tesla pushes their system to operate in a wider variety of conditions, while still putting the same responsibility on the driver, and advertising the system using language that suggests that it is higher than level 2 functionality.
It should be illegal to advertise a SAE level 2 driver assistance feature as “self driving” (regardless of how much fine print you have); by definition, it never drives itself.
- samatman 5y agoThere's a conflation of issues here. I agree that "FSD 'beta'" is pushing it as advertising goes, and probably on the wrong side of the line. I don't accept that advertising copy makes operating a car more or less dangerous. Tesla's system does more than the average level 2, so it's more useful. This may also mean operating it is more dangerous, but that isn't a given. Has it been demonstrated? If it has, I'd like to see that. It seems to be mostly taken for granted in this sort of conversation, and it seems like if it were demonstrably the case, there would be a pithy blog on that subject online. I can only say I haven't seen that, but it could easily exist, this isn't something I focus on.
- kube-system 5y agoTesla’s system does more driver assistance than other level 2 systems, but it is a level 2 system itself. FSD is an egregious misnomer. It doesn’t take over driving responsibilities under any circumstance. “Full automation” under SAE J3016 is level 5. The dangerous part is the false impressions of capability that they give to some of their drivers.
- lolinder 5y ago> I don't accept that advertising copy makes operating a car more or less dangerous. Advertising copy doesn't alter the car's safety, but it can make the driver of a car more or less dangerous. Tesla sells their cars as being capable of fully driving themselves, hands people a contract with a bunch of fine print saying "actually you still need to pay attention", and then acts shocked when drivers respond to the flashy marketing rather than to the fine print. It's absurd that people still defend Tesla after all that marketing and place full blame on the drivers. Yes the drivers were careless, but Tesla intentionally created an environment in which drivers could believe their cars would take care of themselves!