6 ms·
There’s a baseline issue here which is insurance companies and actuaries. If you can afford to be outside the insurance system in the US you can get excellent
by gumby 5y ago
There’s a baseline issue here which is insurance companies and actuaries.
If you can afford to be outside the insurance system in the US you can get excellent care. That can include having tests done that aren’t covered by insurance and avoiding tests that an insurance company would normally require just for CYA reasons, but aren’t worth the risk.
But the incentives of the insurance-driven care are not aligned with optimal patient outcome.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoin countries that have public paid medicare (such as France) it really shows that it leads to a strong lag in adopting modern medical practices and drugs. I'm not advocating against free medecine, however this limitation should be more highlighted than it currently is. Too many people think they're getting the best treatment..
- pfortuny 5y agoSame here in Spain “the best medical service in the world” (as all piliticians boast, from left to right and back again).
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoMake medecine great again /s
- gumby 5y agoThat kind of lag is not always a good thing. I'm OK with medicine not being an early adopter domain.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoThe patient should have a right to be an early adopter if he wants to. Besides, drugs will never leave alpha status if we never let them flow on the market. Although yes obviously a gradually titrated A/B testing scheme would be much more reasonable than the current illegal/legal shift. Moreover cf my other comments, anonymised statistics are needed.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoI hear this repeated a lot but it’s not necessarily true. I had an experience with a doctor who was supposedly so prestigious that she didn’t accept insurance. I ended up going to two appointments where she did nothing but push for redoing some tests in her expensive laboratory at a cost of $5000. She couldn’t explain why her lab was different and eventually admitted that they used the exact same equipment as my previous (insurance-covered) test. When I declined and tried to leave she offered me the “discount” of $1000 off for new patients. It was really just one big push to funnel people through her expensive lab combined with a fancy office and nice bedside manner. Don’t assume that just because someone is outside of the insurance system they’re going to provide superior care.
- hammock 5y agoYou got scammed. Sounds like you know that. I’ve seen functional medicine docs like this too, it’s a part of their business model to sell you overpriced supplements that they get kickbacks from. Just because they don’t take insurance doesn’t mean they don’t have their own ethical sketchiness. However, just because there are bad non-insurance docs out there doesnt mean there aren’t excellent, ethical ones of the type OP described.
- Spooky23 5y agoYup. Dermatologists are big into this too. My wife gets to visit them a lot due to a skin cancer episode, and her former practice was swallowed up by some private equity dermatology group. I learned about their operations via a case study published one of their vendors - a commission/incentive management software platform. Up to 70% of provider pay is about pushing magic goop for your face.
- gumby 5y ago> a doctor who was supposedly so prestigious that she didn’t accept insurance. It seems like there's a problem right up front: prestige. My main doctor doesn't accept insurance though she will give you a form with the diagnosis codes marked if you want to submit it yourself. She simply doesn't want to deal with the paperwork. There's none of the fancy "concierge" and "membership" bullshit, much less "prestige". She just has an ordinary doctor's office, and doesn't own a lab or anything. But in exchange for filing the insurance form if I remember to: the longest I've had to wait to see her when I was sick was a couple of hours, I can bring my dog with me to my visits, and she and I pass scientific papers back and forth when determining treatment. But the main advantages of "no insurance" are that we have lots of time for a visit (if needed) and nobody looking over her shoulder for prior auth or such. It's a much more collaborative model. Unfortunately I don't think this model scales, but my exposure to the more formula-driven mass medical system has been discouraging.