6 ms·
If I program my Bendix-King autopilot to fly heading 270º at 4K feet and there's a 5K foot mountain directly west of me, the autopilot will do exactly what I to
by sokoloff 5y ago
If I program my Bendix-King autopilot to fly heading 270º at 4K feet and there's a 5K foot mountain directly west of me, the autopilot will do exactly what I told it to do and I will make a smudge on the side of the mountain.
- sudosysgen 5y agoDid you pay for the full-self-flying version of the Bendix-King? More seriously though, collision avoidance system are now common in airplane autopilot system, so by that logic it should be reasonable for the Tesla to issue at least an overspeed warning.
- xattt 5y agoThe time and degree of training that is needed to operate a plane is vastly different than the level of training needed to operate a car.
- dylan604 5y agoShould it be though? Obviously Joey Beercan and his soccermom wife with 4.5 kids are not ever going to do a pilot's level pre-flight walk around inspection of the s/aircraft/Chevy Tahoe/ to check that the tires are inflated and have proper tread. Nor would they ever spend the time to look at the indicator lights to ensure the equipment is operating correctly. No amount of tapping on the Check Engine light will ever make that indicator change value. However, we've made getting licensed to operate a vehicle way too easy. We should also make drivers get training on equipment type so switching from a mid-sized sedan to a gianormous SUV requires more than just being handed new keys.
- xattt 5y agoI don’t think vehicle licensing should be easy, and should fairly strict as I understand it to be in Germany. The extent of training increases the investment a person has around the regulated activity. The person is more likely to abide by the rules because (a) they have a deeper knowledge, and (b) they don’t want to lose the privilege of being able to carry it out. Increasing the strictness of license requirements could be a small nudge towards decarbonization to slow the growth of personal vehicles on the road.
- dylan604 5y ago>Increasing the strictness of license requirements... Sadly, I'd have to disagree. I think all this would do would be to increase the number of drivers operating illegally. Increase the friction, and people will just find a way to avoid it all together. The only real way to stop it would to have mandatory checkpoints. The push back from the masses for any kind of change like this would be enormous that you'd be asking Roe v Who? in comparison.
- ghaff 5y agoShould everyone just have to take a high-end defensive driving course? Sure. Why not? I can afford it. You can't? What a pity. But honestly I think demands to make a driver's license harder to get largely miss the point. From my own experience, time on the road makes far more difference than training or harder tests. As does, general maturity and attitude which isn't going to be taught by a class.
- dylan604 5y ago>Should everyone just have to take a high-end defensive driving course? Sure. Why not? I can afford it. You can't? What a pity. What does this have to do with anything? Advocating that people that can't afford to take training shouldn't be restricted from getting licensed? With that logic, let's all become pilots for free too! >time on the road The rest of this I can almost agree with, but you're glossing over that bad habits become entreanched. Distracted driving from today's smartphone use to the classic putting on makeup while driving, constant changing of the radio/spotify/etc, or just shoving fries/chips down your gullet while driving is never going away no matter how many years you've drive. In fact, the longer one goes with out having a wreck with these bad habits, the more one is emboldened that they are safe. It's not just teenagers with low hours behind the wheel that do any of the things listed above.
- ghaff 5y agoI'm not sure what training regime gets people to not do those things however. I assume US driver ed courses still include obligatory horrific videos of crashes resulting from people doing stupid things.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoYou know that's not how they sell autopilot. They sell it as something that is more intelligent than dumb cruise control, and they sell it as the safest driver on the road. They don't sell it as "equivalent to airplane autopilot." In Germany, a court ruled that they misled customers on the capabilities of autopilot and banned advertising it: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/tesla-autopilot-self-driving-false-advertising-germany.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/07/14/tesla-autopilot-self-driving...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oxplot 5y ago> they sell it as the safest driver on the road And it is "statistically" which is how all safety measures are evaluated.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoI believe there was a study that looked only at highway miles driven (where autopilot is mostly useful), and the advantage of Tesla's autopilot vanishes compared to a human. It turns out it's a lot easier to not crash on a highway than to do it on surface roads with many stops and starts.
- bmitc 5y agoWhen you bought that airplane or the autopilot system, was it advertised like this? https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot And note that this is the current marketing material. Edit: It's not mentioned in the article, as far as I see, but it's likely the driver was on the cell phone. It mentions the data shows the driver had their hands on the steering wheel, but that can be easily thwarted, to my understanding. The fact that they didn't brake at all implies they weren't actually holding the steering wheel, at least in a way where they were paying attention. In my opinion, both the driver and Tesla bear responsibility.
- sokoloff 5y agoI'll observe that that page contains the following text (inline and in the same font and size as the rest of the body text, not buried in a footnote somewhere): Current Autopilot features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous.
- cyphar 5y agoIf you look at the page from the time when the incident occurred[1], there is no such text anywhere on that page. It's almost as if they added the text in response to the threat of lawsuits. The only disclaimer is: > Please note that Self-Driving functionality is dependent upon extensive software validation and regulatory approval, which may vary widely by jurisdiction. And the rest is marketing copy explicitly written to make it sound more fully-featured than it actually is. [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20180211121851/https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://web.archive.org/web/20180211121851/https://www.tesla...
- shkkmo 5y agoBut that copy explicitly notes abouy the self driving features: > It is not possible to know exactly when each element of the functionality described above will be available, as this is highly dependent on local regulatory approval. So while you can argue that the marketing is deceptive, that can't really be read as saying that you could let the car drive itself at that time.
- ZetaZero 5y agoTesla is selling FSD, which claims it would steer around the mountain.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Karunamon 5y agoFSD is not autopilot. The latter is cruise control with lane keeping.
- LightG 5y agoYour average Joe or Jane absolutely doesn't know that ... all they know is that 'full' FSD isn't fully ready yet and they have the latest Autopilot Autopilot and FSD are two different things ... I'm sure the consumer is fully aware of that /s
- Karunamon 5y agoYour average Tesla owner definitely does know that because they had to go into the settings and enable one or both of those features (and pay a large sum of money for FSD), both of which are accompanied with a modal dialog on enabling indicating that they are in development and require your full attention. The car doesn't ship with autopilot or FSD turned on.
- LightG 5y agoPeople expect more from AP. And I promise you, I know people with Teslas, some are incredibly switched on, some absolutely are not.
- Karunamon 4y agoThat's their problem, then. Every reasonable step is taken to explain what each system does. If people can't understand something that simple, then they probably should not be driving anything, let alone a Tesla.
- sschueller 5y agoHow many of the public know how a plane works and don't assume that auto pilot means you do nothing? Popular culture has people seeing pilots having their legs on the console and drinking, parting with the crew while the plane is in autopilot. The general public is extremely stupid and believe everything they see in movies/TV. In fact a large part of the population believe that Fentanyl can kill you just by touching it which is the most ridiculous thing ever. Yet people are so paranoid about it that police officers have collapsed in hysteria after touching Fentanyl. [1] Candy wrappers say "Do no eat!" on them in the Unites States so you can not assume people know how an actual Autopilot works. Now you may say this is because companies are getting sued but that proves the point that you can actually sue someone for being this stupid and win. [1] https://healthandjusticejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40352-021-00163-5 https://healthandjusticejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/1...
- onion2k 5y agoIf I program my Bendix-King autopilot to fly heading 270º at 4K feet and there's a 5K foot mountain directly west of me Bendix/King autopilot has a feature called Enhanced Ground Proximity Warning System which would be hard to ignore. Some models have "terrain avoidance maneuvering" which would actually prevent it.
- nunez 5y agoTesla's autopilot also yells loudly if you do something that it thinks will result in a crash
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- subhro 5y agoAs a pilot, wanted to insert a little fun here: “Terrain, Terrain, PULL UP, PULL UP” Hopefully you were not sleeping. ;)
- bmitc 5y agoI tried searching for those features in that airplane, as I'm not a pilot but assumed they existed. On a related note, although they usually mean something's going wrong, which isn't cool, I've always been impressed by the way those warnings are delivered in airplanes. The tone and cadence of the warnings really communicate that this is something serious and you should respond to it and also communicates what exactly you should do. Here's a video of the exact scenario being discussed in a Boeing 747-400: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12jp5G1LWG0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=12jp5G1LWG0
- computerex 5y agoIt's not quite the same. If you are going to use aviation as an example, also consider that in Airbus planes the autopilot takes precedence and overrides pilot input to maintain a safe flight envelope. Fighters with FBW like the raptor can't be over G'd because FBW takes precedence over pilot input.
- simion314 5y agoCan you also defend the "Full Self Driving" naming is also super clear and it also implies that means something like "driving assist", not an english speaker so maybe "full" means incomplete in some american dialect , and "Self-driving" means "lane asist" in the same dialect.
- sokoloff 5y agoIt's a little weird to be defending Tesla's position here, because I think that Elon does overstate the capabilities of <whatever he's working on> and often to a needless and unhelpful degree. (It's like someone batting 0.409 and hitting 75 home runs per year claiming they're batting 0.600 and hitting 100 home runs. What he does is undeniably impressive and then he feels compelled to exaggerate it.) That said, the selling of FSD has, to my knowledge, always been positioned as the selling of hardware that is expected to be capable in the future of FSD. Sometimes you have to read all of the words in a paragraph to get that meaning, but that is the clear reading I get from that same autopilot page: Full Self-Driving All new Tesla cars have the hardware needed in the future for full self-driving in almost all circumstances. The system is designed to be able to conduct short and long distance trips with no action required by the person in the driver’s seat. The future use of these features without supervision is dependent on achieving reliability far in excess of human drivers as demonstrated by billions of miles of experience, as well as regulatory approval, which may take longer in some jurisdictions. As these self-driving capabilities are introduced, your car will be continuously upgraded through over-the-air software updates.
- simion314 5y agoAs others mention this disclaimers is not what is or was advertised, Elon fanboys always say "Ignore what Elon said, just read the latest Terms of Serive". By the same logic an Hello World Python script has the capability for general AI, i just need to wait enough years then add later add the missing part that accidental is the essential thing. Nobody disputes the terms of service language, but the advertising language, the intentional misleading names and stats greedy companies use. We are sure lawyers checked those terms of service very well and worked fine for US, seems German judges are not tricked by this trickery though, would be nice if more countries punish missleading advertising. I imagining new Elon product "Clean Drinking Water" and ads showing people drinking it, BUT with small text that mentions that the "safe for drinking will happen in 10 years after we fix our shit" and fanboys defending the naming because you should already know that Elon is always doing this and you should read ignore the advertising and go to the legal documents about the product to figureut all the real details.
- jjav 5y agoDoes the CEO of BendixKing regularly promote it on twitter as a full self-flying solution that will take care of intelligently avoiding obstacles like that mountain without your input? I don't fly but have an autopilot on a boat, same thing. It'll happily hold a heading onto the rocks if I set it. But everyone knows that's what it does, the company doesn't make any claims or insinuations otherwise.