4 ms·
> What? If the harms of the biopsy outweigh the benefits, don’t do the damn biopsy! But you’ll get sued if the scan suggests something but you don’t follow up
by rayiner 5y ago
> What? If the harms of the biopsy outweigh the benefits, don’t do the damn biopsy!
But you’ll get sued if the scan suggests something but you don’t follow up and do the biopsy, and it turns out to be cancer. The author doesn’t seem to realize this is all happening against the background of potential litigation.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoAlso, if you know that you won't do a biopsy even if the test comes back positive, then the screening isn't helping anyway.
- ssivark 5y agoTo paraphrase the author's point -- the doctor could have a policy to intervene only if the screening produces _flagrantly_ worrying results, and continue to not intervene in cases where the results are merely mildly worrying. Technically, this might lead to strictly better outcomes at the ensemble level. But any patient likely 1. doesn't care about ensemble performance 2. will get stressed out at the mildest indication of concern 3. induce a concave payoff for a trigger-shy doctor (no credit for correctly not intervening, and massive discredit for incorrectly not intervening).