3 ms·
Prints and NFTs are very different. You will very rarely be able to print it yourself because high quality copies will not be available to you. You also wouldn’
by Gigachad 5y ago
Prints and NFTs are very different. You will very rarely be able to print it yourself because high quality copies will not be available to you. You also wouldn’t expect a print to have resale value. You are buying it because it looks nice on your wall. Not as an investment.
NFTs are still a load of crap. Im glad some artists found a way to make money off them, but that doesn’t make them any less of a scam.
- aaronbrethorst 5y agoA print, especially a classic gelatin silver B&W or c-print, is something the artist has ostensibly personally labored over. It is as much a product of their craft as the original source material was, whether that was a negative, positive, digital image, or PSD file. NFTs...eh, not so much.
- web4 5y agomost artists will hire professional printmakers and printers. just because a photographer is good at shooting does not mean they are good in the dark room. when we talk about editioned prints, most of the effort is not in the print. a screen print takes a couple hours to make, an Epson print is a click of the button. but the work being printed might have been built from years of practice as an artist.
- web4 5y agoartist prints are routinely forged and resold. this is such a problem in high end artists work like Hirst that they must find complex ways to certify and authenticate their signed prints. sometimes this is with holographic stickers, or separate certificates of authenticity, or even non NFT blockchain certification. most signed prints are not bought because of what the content is, but because of the signature. you can buy unsigned prints of many notable artists work for 20 bucks while the same signed version sells at sothebys for thousands. users should not expect NFT to have any more or less resale value than a signed print. but because there is currently a market for it, it is easier to sell a token than a print. in future this may change if tokens are as commonly distributed and purchased as prints are.
- dmitriid 5y ago> artist prints are routinely forged and resold. this is such a problem in high end artists work like Hirst that they must find complex ways to certify and authenticate their signed prints. NFTs make this problem worse. E.g. OpenSea is awash with stolen art and removed the ability to contest the problem several months ago.
- web4 5y agothe blockchain allows anybody to publish nfts that point to any media, so naturally there is a lot of spam and copy-minting. anybody can publish to OpenSea a Picasso NFT but this does not mean it will be valued by the market as a Picasso. the same is true of an impersonator trying to mint a new Pak or Beeple or whoever you think is a popular nft artist. almost all of these "thefts" come in the form of social engineering and impersonation rather than forging the token itself. and if you look at the data, 99% of these copy-mints are not actually selling and are not making any impact in the market. a copy-mint of crypto punks is trivially easy to discern as a fake because its contract hash will be uniquely different than the crypto punks contract, which has a long and clear historical trail associated with it on chain. if a copyminter starts to post new work that resembles a popular artist like Beeple, it will be under a new public key hash or address, and also easy to discern. compare this crypto art copy-minting to paintings like Salvator Mundi which countless experts have been investigating for years and still are not able to discern the authenticity of the painting despite its $450 million price tag.
- dmitriid 5y ago> does not mean it will be valued by the market as a Picasso There are innumerable examples of digital art being sold on OpenSea without any knowledge of the original authors, but presented as if it was from the original authors. > almost all of these "thefts" come in the form of social engineering and impersonation rather than forging the token itself. It literally doesn't matter if the token is forged. The theft is there, and NFTs (and blockchains in general) have literally no mechanism to prevent it. > a copy-mint of crypto punks is trivially easy to discern as a fake because its contract hash You keep pretending that stealing art is the same as stealing/forging the token that points something > compare this crypto art copy-minting to paintings like Salvator Mundi which countless experts have been investigating Who. Cares. There's an irrefutable fact: NFTs provide literally zero protections against art theft. It's gotten so bad that sites like DeviantArt now have automated tools to find stolen art on sites like OpenSea and report it to original artists. - NFT art sales are booming. Just without some artists' permission: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/nft-art-sales-are-booming-just-artists-permission-rcna10798 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/nft-art-sales-are-boom... - Site Sells Famous Songs as NFTs Without Permission https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkpqyy/site-sells-famous-songs-as-nfts-without-permission-sparks-global-outrage https://www.vice.com/en/article/pkpqyy/site-sells-famous-son... - An artist died. Then thieves made NFTs of her work https://www.wired.co.uk/article/nft-fraud-qinni-art https://www.wired.co.uk/article/nft-fraud-qinni-art But sure. Keep trying to derail the discussion with Salvator Mundi