8 ms·
>The policy for the first time directs that good-faith security research should not be charged. Good faith security research means accessing a computer solely f
by duxup 5y ago
>The policy for the first time directs that good-faith security research should not be charged. Good faith security research means accessing a computer solely for purposes of good-faith testing, investigation, and/or correction of a security flaw or vulnerability, where such activity is carried out in a manner designed to avoid any harm to individuals or the public, and where the information derived from the activity is used primarily to promote the security or safety of the class of devices, machines, or online services to which the accessed computer belongs, or those who use such devices, machines, or online services.
Seems pretty reasonable. There will be arguments over what exactly qualifies but it provides a clear guideline / reasons where someone at the DOJ can not charge someone with good reason.
It hopefully side steps some of the "what even is hacking / a security breach / dude just opened browser dev tools ..." type questions where they can look and say "He notified them of the issue, I don't think this was in bad faith." Now you're all out of those other weeds.
If anything hopefully this provides a good example to trickle down to other law enforcement agencies.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoThere's so many cases of that. So many cases, it's the typicallest thing the first thing a clever kid who sees a glitch--supposing he's a good kid, I was--wants to do is tell the people who made it to make it better. It happened to me with Banco Estado, we were two OK remarkably smart guys but still, we were just shooting the shit on the subway none of this secret conversation on Signal business, and I said: hey Chilean banks have tiny tiny passwords, like pitiful. Might as well be one digit, like in the Little Rascals when the kid dressed up like an adult is asked for his bank number, he says "seven". Then tries "8". From the computer perspective, it is one digit. And we spent one minute joking how trivial it would be to rob the bank, but since then I just felt bad. It's the only account you can get for free in Chile, without a monthly fee and compound interest on that fee, and then collections out to fuck you. It means employers can look at their employees accounts during negotiations, brute force those four digits, and everything's unsafe, nah...it's basically due to the disgrace of Chilean education, just got plundered to pay for the expensive torture/rape apparatus, and to keep the poor and middle-class Chileans down. And secondly, to cut down on call center costs, that's why even Banco BICE, a really hot shit bank, has an embarrassingly low maximum limit on password length. I told an Indian about it, a IIT graduate, about this maximum he said "minimum. 8 character minimum." I corrected him, "no, maximum. I made it as long as I could."
- RonMarken 5y agoThis appears to be good however recent events showing the deconstruction of prior precedents and other policies not directly implemented by laws raise a tangible concern. It would not be surprising if some bored prosecutor with a grudge attempts to throw this out the window. In addition litigation by private-companies using the same laws could attempt to win by the virtue of having better funding and/or lawyers than the defendant. Too cynical? Maybe.
- anonymousiam 5y agoBut this is just a policy clarification and not a change to the text of the CFAA itself. Policy is not law and there can be arbitrary exceptions and even complete reversals of policy with a change in power.
- user3939382 5y agoIn the abstract, arbitrary enforcement of the law is a serious threat to democracy. I completely agree, the law needs to be amended. Unfortunately Congress doesn't seem to act unless it's in the interest of their megacorp donors.
- robonerd 5y agoOn the other hand, airtight enforcement of all laws is a serious threat to liberty. Laws are imperfect and prosecutorial discretion is an important safety mechanism to prevent people in odd edge cases (which it turns out, are common) from getting unjustly maimed by the legal apparatus. Adjusting laws is also part of the process, but that is a slow process (another safety mechanism.)
- mLuby 5y agoThere is already a safety mechanism for that: jury nullification. Airtight enforcement of all laws is only a threat to liberty when the laws themselves are a threat to liberty.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- inetknght 5y agoI wonder what it means for, eg, forcing users' printer drivers to update to a hacked firmware which notifies them that their firmware was hackable? [0]: https://cybernews.com/security/we-hacked-28000-unsecured-printers-to-raise-awareness-of-printer-security-issues/ https://cybernews.com/security/we-hacked-28000-unsecured-pri...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]