11 ms·
He Was a World Renowned Cancer Researcher. Now He’s Collecting Unemployment
- Comevius 4y agoThis is rather one sided. There was an independent investigation that uncovered a lot of sexist and predatory behavior in his lab. The guy is also not above data manipulation.
- pchristensen 4y agoI didn't read the report (just the article), but it sounded like the independent investigation did NOT uncover sexist or predatory behavior.
- Comevius 4y agoThe "article" is trash, it's basically a political bullshit about a poor cancer researcher being canceled. He was placed on leave after the investigation, and the report was damning. Many of his former colleagues and students called him out and continue to do so. And he is not collecting unemployment either, he is swimming in biotech money. Guys like this one are not easy to take down either, there are plenty like him out there.
- Inu 4y agoThis is how the article summarizes the report: >So what exactly had those 248 pages said? What had David Sabatini been found guilty of that merited this kind of punishment? Chiefly, failing to disclose his consensual relationship with Knouse. On top of that, the report found that Sabatini, in his day-to-day administration of the lab, violated the Whitehead’s Anti-Harassment Policy, since his “behavior created a sexualized undercurrent in the lab.” Sabatini’s relationship with Knouse exacerbated things, given his “indirect influence” over her, which violated the Anti-Harassment Policy and ran afoul of the “spirit” if not the letter of another of the institute's policies. True, he didn’t supervise Knouse. He didn’t work directly with her. He never threatened her or proposed a quid pro quo. And he certainly didn’t have the power to fire her. But, according to the report, he had “experience, stature, and age” over her. Knouse’s apparent desire to continue their relationship only served to confirm his influence: “That she felt the need to act ‘fun’ to impress Sabatini underscores how Sabatini’s words and actions profoundly impacted her,” the lawyers wrote. Nor did the lawyers care for the happy hours and whiskey tastings that Sabatini sometimes hosted in his office, which betrayed his “apparent ‘friendliness’ and general propensity to have ‘fun.’” (Knouse, in her counterclaim, says the events were “drunken,” and “conversations quite frequently veered to the sexual.”) “While we have not found any evidence that Sabatini discriminates against or fails to support females in his lab, we find that Sabatini’s propensity to praise or gravitate toward those in the lab that mirror his desired personality traits, scientific success, or view of ‘science above all else,’ creates additional obstacles for female lab members,” the report concluded. Not sure I understand what is damning about his behavior based on this summary.
- Comevius 4y agoThere is plenty wrong here, but the summary basically tries to pin it on Knouse when multiple women made complaints. One of the court filing had three accusers. I'm not a court to decide who is wrong here, but this does not look like a clear example of cancel culture. Going against this guy must have been a huge risk for these women.
- itchyouch 4y ago> Sabatini’s propensity to praise or gravitate toward those in the lab that mirror his desired personality traits, scientific success, or view of 'science above all else'... It sounds like the way to "succeed" in the lab was by an amalgamation of personality + merit, which sounds pretty reasonable. This is one of the very common modes in which people get ahead. If you are one of many researchers in the lab, equally capable, but you could gain an edge by flirting, sleeping with the head, etc, it behooves one to gain that advantage. And it can develop into a subtle, but insidious toxicity. It's the elephant in the room that no one points out, but also impossible to ignore, if you're considering how one's social dynamics play into career prospects. The problem is that many men are incredibly smart and nuanced in being capable of hitting just a bit too low, glancing just a moment too long, stepping just a half-step too close, insinuating with just a teency amount of overstepping boundaries, while maintaining the illusion that everything is above board and with plenty of plausible deniability. And to be subjected to that type of environment, as a woman, is this subtle non-verbal gaslighting that feels impossible to criticize or pinpoint without coming away as being perceived as delusional. However, women all around feel it, but this behavior hasn't necessarily been labeled yet. Even more challengingly, these slightly lower bids, are a built-in "feature" of human relationships and connection. It's a part of this dance we use to renegotiate relationships. But there's also unspoken and hidden contracts at play, where temporary advances, while not welcome with enthusiastic consent, won't be punished as long as they are temporary and ephemeral. Sabatini, likely never grossly crossed certain boundaries, but it seems that his behavior, choices and the air of his presence was just underhanded enough with enough women, with enough persistence, that finally multiple women would step forward. I'm willing to speculate that there was likely an unspoken contract between Sabatini and Knouse, where Knouse may have believed herself to be a much more serious connection to Sabatini, while Sabatini, over time, unveiled a growing disinterest in her. I'm also willing to bet that Sabatini had a seduction playbook of some sort that Knouse likely realized, either on her own, or in concert with other women, and finally retaliated to "protect" other women in the lab. Confounding this is that it's also very likely, that he had plenty of excellent and non-underhanded relationships with other female researchers who are quoted to vouch for him and his excellence. With the given story, it's impossible to pronounce judgement that he should have lost his career or that he was assaulting women per se, but when there is a pattern of women #meToo'ing to a person of power, there's a tremendous amount of signal pointing to something more underhanded going on.
- joeman1000 4y agoJust going by the article, it’s a really unfortunate situation. Their relationship seems… unsavoury, which may have led to the bitter feelings and vindictiveness of the lady. Part of me is sorry for her, and can see how the power dynamic influenced her to pursue the ‘relationship’. The other, more rationally inclined part of me sees this 29y/o, experienced and intelligent lady as completely knowing what she was doing, knowingly involved in a polygamous relationship, and herself having sex with multiple different people regularly, including other ‘powerful’ people. How can you expect to forge a lasting relationship with someone if you’re both f*cking your brains out with ten other people like bohemian bachelors? If anything this woman was unrealistic. Obviously we don’t know every detail, but this is as much as I can conclude from the article.
- inawarminister 4y agoHope he'd be happy and productive in either China or UAE. WOULD really recommend UAE, as long as oil and gas is still used they're stable enough. And his research directly impacts the magnates in charge.
- noduerme 4y agoI don't think this post should have remained flagged. I came here tonight to see if this story had been posted to HN, and to find out what users here would say about it. The story is relevant to recent cultural changes in a lot of tech workplaces; it's on-topic. The discussion here has been civil. Removing a well-sourced article that aims to exonerate someone who's been cancelled seems like a preemptive capitulation to fear that even by allowing discussion, HN could be tarred with the same brush. Upholding the flag demonstrates and amplifies the chilling effect on reasonable speech that's central to the article, by not-so-subtly telling users that it's verboten to even discuss it. HN shouldn't be afraid of allowing discussion around such an article. >> “It’s impossible to be honest about this and preserve your own skin,” says a scientist who recently worked under Sabatini. The fear exuded in this kind of statement is terrible for society, for academia and for science; whoever is right or wrong in this particular case. Whichever way the conversation evolves, the expectation must be maintained, even among people who want to silence others, that civil conversation will be allowed. That's why it's wrong to flag this and leave it flagged.
- Inu 4y agoI agree. I remember an article by Chris Avellone responding to allegations of misconduct also got flagged. Now he seems to be widely viewed as being a victim of false accusations. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27640701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27640701
- BLanen 4y agoLol, of course a Bari Weiss article. She's really going on the grift.
- jfengel 4y agoDoes Bari Weiss actually do anything tecy-related? I assume she must, to appear on HN so often. But every time I see her blog, it's because she's complaining about the persecution she suffers as a conservative. Does she actually do anything relevant to HN? Or is she just popular here because so many tech people enjoy the persecution complex?
- oneepic 4y agoIt's 2022, and we're throwing away researchers at the cutting edge just because of Internet articles, tweets and outrage over stories we were never a part of. (but, ironically, I haven't heard of this guy's story until today)
- SemanticStrengh 4y agoyour logical pressure is harassing me, if you keep arguing you will be cancelled /said someone in an incoming dystopian world
- akomtu 4y agoI suspect that using irrefutable logic to disagree with your opponents is covert toxic masculinity.
- withinboredom 4y agoIt’s important to realize anyone can say whatever they want. You don’t have to act on it. If I were “the boss” I would separate them and encourage the complainant to go to the police. If he/she were found guilty, then I’d do what I had to do. But I would never fire someone just because someone said some shit. This is probably why I’m not “the boss”…
- tsol 4y agoIf you don't, and suddenly you find huge crowds of angry protestors organized on Twitter around your facility, would you still not act? How about if they start contacting your funders and put pressure on them? Unfortunately it's not just about how you react to the situation, if everyone else believes the story you'll just be viewed as an 'enabler'.
- withinboredom 4y agoYeah. I stand by anyone can say whatever they want. Just because there’s a lynch mob, doesn’t mean it’s right.
- Animats 4y ago
- inglor_cz 4y agoHmm. You are being downvoted, but your comment actually prodded me into thinking. Gay sexual harassment cases seem to be rather rare. But gay relationships probably do happen on the campus and between co-workers fairly frequently, much like straight relationships. Are estranged gay lovers/couples less likely to report their former relationships to authorities in order to exact vengeance?
- HKH2 4y agoIf you got groped, would you report it?
- inglor_cz 4y agoI was actually once groped in a gym, but I didn't. I just defended myself. This guy was notorious for being handsy. Yes, I suspect that males tend to trust authorities less and/or do not want to include them in their business, unless necessary. (Same probably goes with going to the doctor.)
- thriftwy 4y agoIt should be a good bait for China. Seriously though, in most countries, have his employer tried to enforce the "consentual nonsense whatever" act, they would be reinstating him while paying for all the missed opportunities and the legal fees also.
- temp8964 4y ago> He resigned from the Whitehead, and eventually MIT, at the advice of his lawyers who thought it would help him secure his next job. (“I one hundred percent regret that,” Sabatini told me). I feel this is the most critical mistake he made. There are stories that those who fought back actually got to keep their jobs (and reputation). The university investigation never gave him due process and was totally biased. He might had a chance.
- secondcoming 4y agoSometimes the process _is_ the punishment, and at the end you're ruined regardless. I'd like to know why he regretted that decision. Perhaps he felt it was an admission of guilt.
- DantesKite 4y agoWell he doesn’t have a job anymore so that’s probably why.
- temp8964 4y agoAfter he resigned, everyone cut tie with him and his grants were took away. If he had sued the university, the university can't do anything to him while the lawsuit is going on.
- ARandomerDude 4y agoTLDR: Smart guy has a sexual relationship with someone who is lower in the organizational hierarchy. She tells him she wants an open relationship and also sleeps with other men. After several months, he wants to break up. She gets mad and has him cancelled. Sadly, our hyper-outrage culture makes all this possible.
- jghn 4y agoTLDR: An incredibly one sided writeup failed to mention that an independent investigation came to the conclusion that there was indeed a pattern of bad behavior.
- chucksta 4y agoI don't know anything about this, do you have good info for the other side?
- kshacker 4y agoI read the article. My first thought was that there was a lot of defense so was it a paid article? But no, there is so much valid defense. If his colleagues have been banned from socializing, it may not be probable, but people should be able to confirm it. On balance, i am buying what this article is selling but keeping time to research more on this story.
- ARandomerDude 4y agoI don't think you read the article.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoA lot of those investigations start out assuming the man is at fault. It is just the way society leans. Women are as perfectly capable of violence and anger as men, but often get a pass because they can't (usually) physically get the upper hand on a male without a weapon. They are more than capable of making it up in psychological violence. Humans are good at that regardless of genders and non-genders.
- quantified 4y ago
- SemanticStrengh 4y ago> In over 55%-80% of intimate partner violence (IPV) cases, the victim is male. Nonetheless, the police arrest the male as the perpetrator in over 80% of IPV cases. Embarrassed at being regularly beaten by his female domestic partner, the male IPV victim commonly says nothing in his defense. He is likely to cover for his abuser, quietly taking the blame for the offenses she projects upon him. https://www.reddit.com/r/Male_Studies/comments/uokuto/what_might_encourage_the_male_intimate_partner/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Male_Studies/comments/uokuto/what_m... The truth is if you study empiric studies on gender inequalities and misandry, that men are becoming more and more abused and miserable. This is amplified by many things such as the women are wonderful effect, and the hypergamification of women via the use and abuse of artificial image enhancers (e.g. makeup) and their current gatekeeping from men, and the male condition cannot currently defend itself against those worsenings, given that masculinism nor the more relevant egalitarianism are represented online. In the modern feminimisandrist rethoric male suffering is because, you guess it, of the patriarchy, indeed a very logical (it's not) assertion. https://www.reddit.com/r/Male_Studies/comments/usi1ao/relationship_of_gender_differences_in_preferences/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Male_Studies/comments/usi1ao/relati... TL;DR women and most men care about women issues/suffering, almost no women (publicly) and few men care about men issues/suffering.
- the_third_wave 4y ago> In over 55%-80% of intimate partner violence (IPV) cases, the victim is male. ...and if you happen to live in Sweden those cases will be reported as men's violence against women [1] (mäns våld mot kvinnor) by the Swedish Jämställdhetsmyndigheten (gender equality authority, an organ which itself is criticised for only allowing women in the upper echelons and for studiously ignoring honour killings and related violence). When they were caught in falsifying the statistics in this way they tried to explain it by stating that "men's violence against women" is to be seen as an overarching term for all types of domestic violence [2] which includes those cases where women molest men. They have not changed their definition, when a women molests a man it still causes the statistic on "men's violence against women" to be raised which in turn is used by activists and politicians for their ideological purposes. Something is rotten in the state neighbouring Denmark. [1] https://kvartal.se/artiklar/jamstalldhetsmyndigheten-kvinnors-vald-mot-man-ar-en-del-av-mans-vald-mot-kvinnor/ https://kvartal.se/artiklar/jamstalldhetsmyndigheten-kvinnor... [2] https://kvartal.se/artiklar/svenska-myndigheter-producerar-alternativa-fakta/ https://kvartal.se/artiklar/svenska-myndigheter-producerar-a... (see 'Alternativ fakta: Made in Sweden')
- MathYouF 4y ago>This prompted the Whitehead (https://wi.mit.edu/ https://wi.mit.edu/) to hire the law firm Hinckley, Allen & Snyder to conduct an investigation >“While we have not found any evidence that Sabatini discriminates against or fails to support females in his lab, we find that Sabatini’s propensity to praise or gravitate toward those in the lab that mirror his desired personality traits, scientific success, or view of ‘science above all else,’ creates additional obstacles for female lab members,” the report concluded. Is this implying that the belief of the writers of the report is that "female lab members" struggle more than others to achieve scientific success or to view 'science above all else'? What other reason would they consider a scientific lab leader favoring those who are committed to science and scientific success to be a hindrance to "female lab members". Or is that entirely relying on the vague first term: "personality traits".
- slightwinder 4y ago> Is this implying that the belief of the writers of the report is that "female lab members" struggle more than others to achieve scientific success or to view 'science above all else'? It's a general believe now that woman struggle more because of permanent discrimination from society, and they deserve more support because of this. This is a complicated topic, but certain people simplify it, leading to these results.
- colechristensen 4y ago>At a meeting after Sabatini’s case was filed, on November 3, 2021 Lehmann, Kay Hodge, the Whitehead’s attorney, and the head of HR informed those left in the lab that NIH rules barred those who had worked under Sabatini from having any contact with him at all. When some of them objected—Sabatini, at that point, was just a guy living in Boston—a scientist who was there recalled Hodge warning them: “You wouldn’t want to jeopardize your future eligibility for NIH funding.” There was a chill in the room. “That’s a death sentence,” the scientist said. Jesus, government science organization explicitly violating freedom of association principles. It’s getting harder and harder to decide which branch of political Nazis are less appealing, and I’m not exaggerating when comparing both poles to fascists.
- hn_version_0023 4y agoThere’s a point coming where “burn it all to the ground” begins to make sense. We’re not quite there, but OTOH, we don’t seem terribly far off either. FWIW, I’m not involved in the sale of matches in any way.
- tomohawk 4y agoBut there's no such thing as cancel culture.
- jancsika 4y agoParagraph three: > “It’s like working for Steve Jobs. He can be brutal,” said one scientist. “But why would you want to work for anyone else?” And then the rest of the article argues how he was not brutal-- a consensual relationship, fun office parties, etc. Why didn't Weiss ask a simple follow-up to the one scientist to give a few examples of what 'brutal' means in this case? Compare: "Oh, I mean he demands excellence at every turn professionally, both of himself and his colleagues, to such a degree that it's difficult to keep up with him." "Oh, I mean he is a megalomaniac who speaks with complete confidence about things he is just plain wrong about." Edit: clarification
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI don't understand why he doesn't just go to another country that's isn't so crazy over political correctness.
- pchristensen 4y agoThe choices were Russia, China, and UAE. Very significant political considerations aside, that's a very, very big change from Boston, where his son and brother live (mentioned in the article).
- rmak 4y agoHe could actually start doing youtube teaching videos or paid ones in Udemy. In any case female teachers who rape underage boys don't get this kind of bad rap.
- tsol 4y ago>“They have the wrong guy,” a female scientist who knows Sabatini and Knouse told me. A female former trainee told me that the climate in Sabatini’s lab was “one of excellence.” She said that Sabatini could be demanding, but he was never demeaning or unfair. “I try to emulate him in my own lab,” another female former trainee said. A third female trainee said the lab could be informal, but it was hardly a locker room. “It just wasn’t in the air. >A few weeks later, Knouse filed a counterclaim that accused Sabatini, among other things, of sexual “grooming.” I find it interesting that we don't put as much weight when it's women countering abuse allegations. Yes I know that's no guarantee that he didn't do anything, but some of the claims in the article are questionable. Like is it really grooming for a 50 year old and a 29 year old to date? Doesn't this imply women of all ages are easily-influenceable and vulnerable? It's my opinion that when people allow things like this to continue unchallenged, it affects not only men but women. Eventually people start treating women differently. This is because while women may be equal to men, their ability to fraternize isn't treated that way-- it's implied in this judgement that their decisions might not be their own but the result of trauma or manipulation. It almost sounds like old fashioned misogyny. I should say I'm totally against office relationships in general, it's almost always a bad idea in my opinion. But I also understand that's how many men and women have met their spouses. This will certainly have a chilling effect on a society that already struggles to connect men and women together romantically. Edit: The entire post just got flagged. Sad that there can't be a discussion about these matters. Well there's not much I can do, eso si que es.
- slightwinder 4y ago> Like is it really grooming for a 50 year old and a 29 year old to date? Doesn't this imply women of all ages are easily-influenceable and vulnerable? This is less about age and more about the difference in power. He was the fancy successful guy at top, she the small nobody at bottom. The grooming is more about him abusing his position of power to prey on someone whose weakness does not come from their personality. > It almost sounds like old fashioned misogyny. This is actually not so far off from the younger generations toxic woke-culture. It's quite disturbing how some of them have twisted the fight against discrimination onto a foundation of sexism and racism, calling it justice and such. We will see how this will unfold, but I fear for the next 10-20 years it will only become worse.
- bubmiw 4y ago
- graycat 4y agoResearch Career Reality 101 Like research? Curing cancer? Understanding the Big Bang, gravitational waves, black holes, dark matter, dark energy? Etc.? Well, for a career doing such research, nearly always need money, financial support. Then, remember "He who pays the piper calls the tune." So, the source of the money has a lot of power over the research, the researcher, etc. So, the source of the money is interested in the research? Right? What they want is good research? They want to see good research? They will be thrilled by good research? 101 Lesson: Nope. In simple blunt terms, they don't care about the research. (1) They don't look into the research in detail -- likely wouldn't understand it even if they tried. (2) Similarly, they don't understand the value, especially the long term value, of the research. (3) Their view is that the research is all in the papers -- they want to see published papers. (4) But they don't read the papers, or even the abstracts of the papers, or even the press releases about the research or the papers. (5) For the papers, mostly they just count them, maybe with more weight for papers in highly respected journals. (6) They don't really like to count papers but prefer to look at prizes. Sure, the Nobel prize. An Abel prize. Etc. In simple terms, the people funding the research don't care about the research itself. So, what do they care about? How 'bout luster, status, prestige, good publicity. In simple terms, what they care about is close to just good politics. The researcher, then, has a career mostly in the service of politics. Then there is the role of the media: Good politics needs good media and can be killed off by bad media. The media, however, also isn't interested in research or the researcher. Instead the media wants ad revenue. For that they want eyeballs. For that they want shocking headlines. One of the best sources of shocking headlines is scandal. One of the best sources of scandal is anything about, I dare not say the word, it's a very dirty word, it's for adults only, S.E.X.!!! Don't say it out loud or in public!!!! So, for Sabatini, his career was ruined by the media that pushed a sex scandal. Then he had bad politics. Then the sources of the funding didn't get the good politics which was the real goal of their funding. So, no more funding. For the media, there is no effective due process. The people attacked by the media can't even get a Stalin Communist Party show trial. For a media attack, there's no effective appeal or ability to respond. Might be able to proceed with a long, expensive, high risk, low expected payoff legal effort. But even if win, and win big, there's no effective way to repair the damage done. In a basic sense, anyone in academics or research is a beggar. "Beggars can't be choosers" or beggars have very little power or financial security, etc. So, at least in the US, a career in academics or research is, in just two words, financially irresponsible. Or, don't do that.