3 ms·
> The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever Pretty big categorical statement. The problem with the "one moving part" storage systems is
by pjc50 5y ago
> The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever
Pretty big categorical statement.
The problem with the "one moving part" storage systems is that their energy density is surprisingly bad. Gravitational potential energy in particular is terrible. Compressed air systems can be OK, especially the ones using underground reservoirs, but have an efficiency limited by the physics of gas expansion.
It's pretty hard to beat redox reactions for energy density. As you say, tankage is cheap, so can this be done with "flow batteries"?
But the real reason lithium is winning is the incredible power of path dependence and manufacturing efficiency. Is it the optimal chemists's whiteboard solution to churn out a billion 18650 cells? No. Is it the one that's easier to actually do in the world as it exists today? Possibly.
- ncmncm 5y agoWhat matters is not joules per unit mass or unit volume, but per dollar, and also watts charging or discharging per dollar. Gravity and compressed air systems excel on that axis (Energy Vault excepted, of course). Chemical synthesis systems suffer on cost per watt to charge, but hit it out of the park on joules stored per dollar. Further pluses are bulk-shippable storage media that may be bought and sold, and can be discharged using existing gas turbines, even in places where you have not installed any synthesis apparatus.