3 ms·
The issue is free markets require more than just open competition, they need zero market coercions such as monopolies or misinformation, while also being free f
by Retric 5y ago
The issue is free markets require more than just open competition, they need zero market coercions such as monopolies or misinformation, while also being free from governmental interference.
That’s clearly a direct contradiction. So basically nobody is actually promoting free markets, they all have their own spin to get past these contradictions.
- WalterBright 5y agoFree markets do not require perfect information. Every transaction made has an element of risk in it - the risk is factored into the price. Buying a used car is a perfect example. They cost more at a dealer than from a private party - because people will pay more for lower risk. Another example is name brands costing more than generic items. Another is less risky investments come with lower returns. I don't know where the idea that free markets require perfect information comes from. As for monopolies, the historical ones are ones set up and enforced by the government.
- ncmncm 5y agoFree markets need management to continue existing at all. When one gets to a monopoly or oligopoly, it's not a market anymore, so isn't counted. Monopoly is the natural end state of an unregulated market.
- WalterBright 5y agoName a monopoly in the US not put in place by the government. Historical or contemporary.
- Retric 5y agoStandard Oil, plenty of others like Microsoft are more arguable but standard oil simply out competed and then bought up the competition.
- WalterBright 5y agoStandard Oil never was a monopoly, and never was convicted of being a monopoly. It was convicted of restraint of trade. SO never had a market share that exceeded 90%. Throughout the years-long anti-trust trial, SO's market share declined, as competitors had learned how to compete with SO. During the height of SO, the consumer price of kerosene dropped 70%. There is no evidence SO harmed consumers or charged monopoly prices. As for Microsoft, they never had more than 90% share, there were always alternatives consumers could buy (Linux and Apple), and their market share has slipped quite a bit since the Justice Dept took no action against them. There's no evidence Microsoft charged monopoly prices - they charged with giving away free copies of their browser! They still give it away for free. Nobody ever demonstrated any harm to consumers from Microsoft.
- Retric 5y agoMonopoly isn’t defined as having a market share over 90%, or any specific percentage. Standard oil was the massively dominant player which controlled enough of the oil supply to be able to set the market price because the competition had insufficient capacity to make up the difference and there was a lack of an equivalent substitute good(s). That’s the economic definition of a monopoly. As to being convinced, it isn’t illegal to become a monopoly.
- WalterBright 5y agoAgain, SO was never convicted of having a monopoly. SO's market share declined before the anti-trust trial got underway, and steadily declined throughout the trial. > set the market price Again, the "market price" declined by 70% under SO's alleged monopoly.
- Retric 5y agoIt’s not perfect information, it’s a lack of misinformation. Indistinguishable fake products remove the possibility of name brands. You run into situations where people can’t trust a gas station is actually selling gas when anyone can slap an Exxon sign up. Reputation networks fill some of these roles, but gatekeepers aren’t free markets.
- WalterBright 5y agoA free market comes with it government protections against use of fraud and force. Fraudulently misrepresenting your product is a crime and is actionable in a free market.
- Retric 5y agoThat’s exactly the kind of contradiction I am talking about. Some people view such government intervention as part of free markets, others feel free markets only exist without any government involvement.
- lern_too_spel 5y agoThere is a certain kind of religious nut that exists in the US, and no other place as far as I can tell, that believes that the invisible hand of the market is the benevolent hand of God, and that leaving it to its own devices is best. This is dogma, which needs no proof, and any market failures we mortals point out are simply failures to understand the Divine Plan.