3 ms·
> It is fantastically frustrating, as it makes wealth-building through home ownership impossible I think this could bring up a debate: should we expect persona
by dangus 4y ago
> It is fantastically frustrating, as it makes wealth-building through home ownership impossible
I think this could bring up a debate: should we expect personal home ownership be a wealth-building tool? Is it the most ideal method of building personal wealth? The expectation that our home is an investment on top of being a place to live could perhaps be one of the factors in areas with a housing affordability crisis. It's in the best interest of the current homeowner to discourage development that would reduce costs for other buyers.
> houses in Japan are probably twice as expensive per unit area compared to the US
I don't see this as particularly alarming, as homes built in the US consume and waste a tremendous amount of space. I think about the typical single family suburban home's attached 2 or 3 car garage and how much of the home's sheltered space that feature takes up.
I also think about the American expectation for luxuries like walk-in closets, having more bathrooms than people, and rooms dedicated to "man caves" and other single-use pursuits. To me, the American suburban lifestyle represents a place to store excess goods consumption – the home is a place to store a bunch of stuff that ends up in the landfill.
Tokyo fits the entire population of California in an area the size of LA County, and I personally consider that to be more of a good thing than a bad thing. When we spread out we waste finite resources and emit carbon dioxide with personal vehicle travel and destroy more natural habitat.
> Did I also mention that a "big" housing lot is 1/20 of an acre? Usually no yard, just concrete.
Much of the overall plot of North American homes are consumed by driveways, yards, and dead space between homes that are usually completely unused for most of the day.
Yards and driveways are major contributors to car dependence and poor public transit in North America. Yards usually offer very little utility and sit unused most of the day, offering zero habitat for animals or people. They reduce walkability of neighborhoods by increasing walking distances between homes and in the street grid.
"But where will my kids play?" Probably at a communal playground, park, sports field, and really they're probably not going to be all that excited by an empty field in the front of your house.
https://twitter.com/officialmitchll/status/1382709940352135175 https://twitter.com/officialmitchll/status/13827099403521351...
Finally, I'll point out that to someone in a vertical housing unit like a residential tower, ground acreage is entirely irrelevant. I don't think the owner of the penthouse unit of 432 Park Avenue is upset that their home represents almost no acreage once the building's plot is divided by the quantity of residents.
I'll drop a couple of articles that discuss some of the negatives of misusing open space in urban planning:
https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/7/23/the-problem-of-forcing-developers-to-provide-open-space https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/7/23/the-problem-of...
https://www.washingtonpost.com/realestate/the-clamor-for-open-space-is-constant-but-sometimes-its-the-wrong-way-to-go/2016/01/14/68435328-b96f-11e5-99f3-184bc379b12d_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/realestate/the-clamor-for-ope...
"Designing green spaces nobody wants" in the article below:
https://www.theguardian.com/housing-network/2015/jul/28/urban-design-mistakes-unhealthy-inactive-communities https://www.theguardian.com/housing-network/2015/jul/28/urba...