9 ms·
The gist of the decision is that the SEC’s imposition of civil penalties and disgorgement violated defendants’ seventh amendment right to a jury trial. Under th
by rayiner 5y ago
The gist of the decision is that the SEC’s imposition of civil penalties and disgorgement violated defendants’ seventh amendment right to a jury trial. Under the seventh amendment, you have a right to a jury trial for any claim that would have been an action at law in the courts of England at the time of the founding, prior to the merger of law and equity.[1] There is an additional principle that so called “public rights,” like Social Security benefits or FCC licenses, need not be adjudicated by a real court (under Article III of the Constitution) but can be adjudicated by the executive branch. The theory is that public benefits are discretionary so the executive branch can decide how to dish them out. So you end up with administrative agencies having internal adjudicating bodies that look very much like courts, but which are not in fact courts.
Ordering a party to disgorge gains from fraud is of course not a “public right” but a quintessential legal proceeding that should be brought in a real court.
There’s a lot of things administrative agencies do that probably aren’t Constitutional and violate the separation of powers. Executive branch quasi-courts adjudicating claims like fraud is the tip of the iceberg. The Supreme Court upheld these statutes in the mid-20th century under the shadow of FDR’s threat of court packing. The Reagan-era Supreme Court was not inclined to roll those decisions back, but I think you will see the current Supreme Court being much more active on that front.
[1] Law courts are the courts we usually think of, with juries. They are the only courts that can award damages. Courts of equity are like the Delaware chancery court—they can award certain equitable relief such as recission of a contract. Today most states and the federal system invest legal and equitable powers in the same courts, but the right to a jury trial arose in England when those courts were distinct.
- guelo 5y ago
- jonahbenton 5y agoVery helpful. Seems like it could be a huge deal. Am curious what the impact from a caseload perspective would be? How many actions are handled on an administrative basis vs how much capacity the relevant court systems have? And impact on duration- administrative actions typically handled in x time, courts take y time. Would love pointers if anyone has them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xyzzyz 5y agoI think most of those cases that before were tried by administrative courts will still end up in a settlement instead of a trial. The difference is that now the process will not be blatantly favoring the executive agencies of federal government, which right now act as judges in the cases they themselves prosecute, and decide appeals from their own decisions.
- colechristensen 5y agoYou can find lists of agency actions, FCC, SEC, etc. etc. There aren’t often all that many, and they wouldn’t all fall under the category affected here.
- civilized 5y agoFinally, a reason for conservative FDR-hate that I can understand. Seriously, this is not a sarcastic or troll post. I have always been confused about this.
- HideousKojima 5y agoSee also: FDR banning private ownership of gold.
- chevill 5y agoI'm not sure why its confusing. Conservatives have historically proclaimed themselves to be (in their words even if the actions don't always match) in favor of small government, reduced government spending, and the minimal taxation required to keep a small government functioning. FDR implemented a bunch of large social programs which naturally grow the government, spend more money, and therefore require more tax dollars to fund. Social programs that redistribute money have long been considered a form of forced charity which many conservatives think is immoral. Disclaimer: Not taking a side here. In 2022 I don't think we have a "good" political party in the US let alone a perfect one.
- rayiner 5y ago“Conservatism” is a tent with a lot of different groups, most of whom dislike FDR for somewhat different reasons. There’s small government conservatives like you mention. There are legal conservatives who are animated more by being sticklers for the rules than opposition to government social programs per se. There’s also lots of folks, maybe the biggest group, who like the New Deal but resent FDR judicial appointees for their tendency to ignore clear Constitutional limits on the federal government one hand, while on the other hand reading in lots of restrictions on state moral and social regulation that aren’t so apparent in the Constitutional text or history.
- rkagerer 5y agoGreat summary, this is very fascinating. What are some of the likely impacts & effects this ruling will have over the long-term?
- rayiner 5y agoSome effects will be relatively small. For example the SEC has authority to haul you into court, in a proceeding which reflects how the system is supposed to work, with the executive branch prosecuting the law and the judicial branch deciding it. But the principle invoked in this case, non-delegation doctrine, is far reaching. The non-delegation doctrine is a theory, some might say a legal fiction, that says that Congress can’t delegate its power to make the laws, but can make a broad law and allow agencies can fill in details so long as Congress gives the agencies “an intelligible principle” for doing so. This is not without basis—there is no obvious line to be drawn between Congress’s power to make laws, and the executive branch’s power to enforce them in a discretionary manner. There is nothing wrong with Congress making a broad law “fraud shall be illegal” and the SEC making rules for itself about how to enforce that. But clearly at some point executive regulation looks more like law making and less like an agency imposing guidelines for the exercise of its own discretion. Historically the Supreme Court has been unwilling to police that line, but that could change. One thing I think you might see is greater scrutiny of agencies applying existing authority to enter new areas of regulation. The theory might be, for example, that it’s fine for the EPA to cut sulfur particulate targets, which clearly falls under the scope of the Clean Air Act, but that the agency needs new Congressional authority to do something like impose limitations on CO2 emissions, which involves a different problem than the Clean Air Act was intended to solve. There is already precedent in this direction, under something called the Major Questions Doctrine: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12077 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12077
- twoodfin 5y agoIf you want to hear how this legal conflict directly plays out in a real case, the SCOTUS oral arguments for the recently heard West Virgina v. EPA are available via the Oyez podcast: https://overcast.fm/+FUsKSZuBc https://overcast.fm/+FUsKSZuBc
- snowwrestler 5y agoIt will be very interesting to see what happens if SCOTUS tries to roll back the administrative state, because this is how Congress wants things to work. They passed all those laws to create the agencies, after all. And the expanding administrative state is what has allowed members of Congress to do less and less actual work, and more and more performance art and fundraising. They barely even have to pass budgets any more; the agencies all find a way to keep “essential services” running anyway. Also, personally it drives me crazy when American legal discussions fall back to English legal traditions. Didn’t we fight a big revolution so we wouldn’t have to live with all that baggage? I’m not a lawyer so I know I’m out of my depth. But as a U.S. citizen living under a written Constitution, I have a hard time understanding why my country should make itself beholden to England’s legal history specifically.
- woodruffw 5y agoThe practical answer is that every country needs a body of law to "bootstrap" with, and English common and case law isn't the worst place to start.
- PeterisP 5y agoAnd the two major alternative starting points used in practice are Roman law or Sharia law, both of which are likely even less acceptable to someone who doesn't want the baggage of English common law. On the other hand, in the civil law systems when new countries are formed, as soon as you get the core laws passed (which takes some years of transition) you do generally make a clean start where only the new code of laws matter and everything else is discarded - you explicitly choose which parts of earlier code get included in the new laws, and that's it, old laws get pulled out only if there's a relevant dispute about some events which happened back when those old laws were in force.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoThe code of Hammurabi (eye for an eye) seemed to be popular back in the day. One must wonder if its host nation-state had survived for longer, what iteration would be out in the wild.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoAwesome write up thank you. What about executive orders? That seems like extreme overreach of the executive branch. It's it being used in an emergency either. The presidents are issuing hundreds of them during their terms.
- vmception 5y ago> The presidents are passing hundreds of them during their terms. There is a major lack of oversight on Executive Orders. BUT for the most part they are an accurate use from what I can tell. Usually they are merely aspirational goals for agencies to implement, much more similar to a CEO's quarterly goals for subdivisions. The President is a dual office role of being head of the executive branch, and being head of the military. I don't really see that much straight up unilateral ordering of specific actions, and those would be the only constitutionally questionable ones.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoAre they creating new laws with Executive actions? That would seem like it falls under the legislative branch.
- colejohnson66 5y agoExecutive Orders, technically, are only orders from the Executive (the President) to the rest of the branch. As in, they can only tell the rest of the Executive Branch what to do, not create laws. However, with how much Congress has delegated to Executive Agencies, there's a lot more overlap and gray area than there was 233 years ago. For example, the CDC has the authority to mandate certain things in the name of public health, because Congress created the HHS (who oversees the CDC) with the express purpose of doing so. So an Executive Order directed at the CDC can, in a sense, give the President that power.
- vmception 5y agoEvery creature from the New Deal is probably unconstitutional. Additional context on that threat of court packing is that the Supreme Court was already invalidating and gutting the New Deal! Its such an important story to me because my grade school history books all upheld the New Deal as this monumental and amazing thing. From what I can tell, 75% of it (or 75% of the programs it created) was declared unconstitutional, and everything else just hasn't been challenged yet! And of the things that were challenged and declared constitutional, it was under the threat of court packing! Now, 3-5 generations later, the Supreme Court just can't imagine how society functions by ruling accurately to begin with! I'm pretty interested in any court unwinding this incongruency.
- munificent 5y agoI think implicit in your comment is that the New Deal must not actually be amazing because it turns out that it's likely unconstitutional but... how does that logically follow? It's not like the Constitution was handed down from the heavens as a flawless document. It may be that the New Deal does contain many unconstitutional provisions, but also that that same legislature was in fact a net benefit for Americans.
- bayareabadboy 5y agoProcesses were included to amend the constitution for this exact reason! Of course the framers knew that it was a flawed document.
- IG_Semmelweiss 5y agoExcellent explanation. I wonder what % of the entire judiciary budget could be paid via the budget SEC division of enforcement. From that standpoint, this assertion of jurisdiction could entail a better staffed judiciary.
- vkou 5y ago> The gist of the decision is that the SEC’s imposition of civil penalties and disgorgement violated defendants’ seventh amendment right to a jury trial If being tried by a jury is so necessary for justice, how is it that ~95% of people currently imprisoned in this country have never faced a jury trial? The answer is obvious - actually having jury trials for everyone would grind the country to a halt, so for the majority of us, this sort of right only exists in theory. But you'll never hear the 5th circuit saying a word on that subject. In a just world, this new development should mirror how jury trials work for the rest of us - anyone demanding a jury trial to avoid regulatory censure should be subjected to such horrific penalties if they lose, that nobody in their right mind would ever choose that option. Sadly, we do not live in a just world.
- xyzzyz 5y agoI don’t like it either that the right to jury trial is overwhelmingly bargained away, but having the right and bargaining it away is still preferable to not have any right in the first place.
- mellavora 5y agoYes, because this gives grounds for the argument that the system is broken (does not provide the right). If > 90% of people are pressured into waiving the right, does the system actually provide this right?
- xmcqdpt2 5y agoIsn't the issue that in the US you only have a binary choice between jury or plea deal? I'm Canadian and here most trials are bench trials, that is in front of a judge only https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/just/12.html https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/csj-sjc/just/12.html The reason why this is often advantageous is that the judge knows well the legal provisions and is more likely to rule in line with previous cases. The judge is also not a prosecutor (and in Canada, not elected by the public) so the judge doesn't have an incentive to be "tough on crime". AFAIK in general, you would only request a jury if you believe your case is in some way fundamentally different from similar cases and you don't want the "default" penalty if found guilty.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kurupt213 5y agoCan defendants in criminal or civil court request a verdict from a judge or panel of judges instead of a jury? I believe Mario Batali did that quite recently in his alleged creepy touching trial. Back to your explanation, this seems like a court functioning the way it was meant to. I think everyone will agree there was a massive Executive overreach in the 20th century, with congress abdicating much of its counterbalancing power (making difficult/unpopular policy decisions that are future-looking is not the recipe for re-election). Bowing to precedence regardless of the quality of the decision seems like bad law facilitating more bad law.
- rayiner 5y agoYes, both civil and criminal cases can try the case to a judge, called a bench trial. Both sides have to agree to that however, since technically both sides have a right to a jury trial.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Yes, both civil and criminal cases can try the case to a judge, called a bench trial. Both sides have to agree to that however, since technically both sides have a right to a jury trial. The government does not have a right to a jury trial, because the government doesn't have rights. (In the federal system, for example, government consent is required for a bench trial in the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, but because that is not a right, and the defendants right to a speedy and public trial, there is at least one case where a federal court, when jury trials were suspended because of the pandemic, conducted a bench trial under a defense jury trial waiver despite the government refusing consent and preferring jury trial.)