5 ms·
Sets an interesting precedent for literally every other federal body that "acts as prosecutor and judge" while skipping the judicial system. Should everyone fig
by paxys 5y ago
Sets an interesting precedent for literally every other federal body that "acts as prosecutor and judge" while skipping the judicial system. Should everyone fighting an immigration or deportation case be able to request a jury trial? What about the military? Labor violations? EPA fines?
- djbusby 5y agoDoesn't US military have their own code of justice and court system?
- rootusrootus 5y agoSure, but this is about constraints by the Constitution, and military members do not give up their Constitutional protections when they enlist.
- rockemsockem 5y agoDon't they? I was very much under the impression that they did.
- torstenvl 5y agoNo. They absolutely do not. The closest thing that's true is this: Constitutional rights are always weighed against some government interest, and there's a lot of deference to the military with regard to government interest. So there may be things on the margins which are unconstitutional in every or nearly every civilian case, but are constitutional in the context of the government's interest in national defense. However, those rights still exist, and courts must still address those issues through the appropriate balancing test. EDIT: A cornerstone case to read, for those interested, is Parker v. Levy: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/417/733/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/417/733/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- YuriNiyazov 5y agoNo person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the militia, when in actual service in time of war or public danger;
- colinmhayes 5y ago> in the time of war So are military courts going to close down since we’ve now ended the Afghanistan war? Or is that comma before “militia” going to mean that the time of war phrase is on for people who in a militia?
- krapp 5y agoThe United States is always at war, if not elsewhere, then with itself and its own principles.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gpm 5y ago> or public danger; Whether or not we're in a time of public danger is definitely up for debate, but you can't just leave off the second condition in an or statement and pretend it doesn't exist when trying to claim the statement is false.
- colinmhayes 5y agoYea I’m on mobile so didn’t want to deal with full quote, it I assumed public danger meant like martial law. Do you know of any precedent on that part?
- gpm 5y agoNo clue, I assumed it was fairly general, but could be wrong. Googled it quickly just now and I didn't find an answer. Incidentally I did find an answer to your previous question (about who the clause applies to), pasted it above.
- nonameiguess 5y agoYes, they do. You absolutely give up freedom of speech and any rights of unreasonable search and seizure when you enlist. You don't give up every right, though. You still get the option of a jury trial whenever you want one. A commander's ability to levy administrative punishment relies on you opting in. You always have the option to seek court martial instead, the issue being they can levy much more severe punishments.
- rootusrootus 5y agoMilitary members still have freedom of speech rights. More tightly regulated in some instances than civilians, but the right isn't taken away. Even as a civilian there are restrictions on your freedom of speech. Similar for the fourth amendment. There are exceptions for civilians, and a different set of exceptions for military members, based on government need. The Constitution applies to all US citizens, military or not.
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe UCMJ forbids military members from "contemptuous speech" against the President and others in the chain of command. They may have some Constitutional protections, but they're hardly identical to those of civilians.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomcam 5y agoAnyone can request a jury trial in the USA. It's guaranteed by the Constitution.
- FYYFFF 5y agoUnless you signed an agreement that states otherwise... Most employee and contractor and user agreements fall into this category.
- colinmhayes 5y agoRight, but there are a lot of federal agencies that adjudicate and potentially give out harsh fines without actually being a court. If you are in that situation you do not have the right to a jury trial, at least until this case was decided.
- adrr 5y agoCan I for my speeding ticket or parking ticket?
- yeahwhatever10 5y agoYea it says how to on the ticket.
- adrr 5y agoNot in my state. https://www.courts.ca.gov/34711.htm?rdeLocaleAttr=en https://www.courts.ca.gov/34711.htm?rdeLocaleAttr=en
- colejohnson66 5y agoFrom that link: > Under Penal Code sections 17(d) and 19.8, if certain offenses are charged as an infraction instead of as a misdemeanor, you can ask that the infraction charge be tried with a jury as a misdemeanor.
- gadflyinyoureye 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoabout time! I think the common circuits are too far up their own ass to just take a fresh view at simply questions. 2nd circuit and 9th circuit just see too much action. Get a panel of judges from Texas and Louisiana for once (5th circuit) and they took a fresh view and came to an understanding that matches a plain reading of the constitution. there were a lot of barriers to this occurring though, which is a bigger issue.
- linkjuice4all 5y agoWhile I dislike poorly written laws (including those that work around some failing of our current "state" of government) and judges lacking accountability - this seems to be in the same league as the EPA Regulator Case[0] that's sitting at the Supreme Court right now. The end-goal doesn't appear to be justice for the aggrieved party but more so the elimination of agency-issued oversight. The jurisprudence seems to follow the idea that if the legislator didn't explicitly grant or disallow an agency to do something or regulate something then that agency has absolutely no power at all to do it. On a basic level this seems to make sense but the practical application of this would mean that legislators would need to explicitly pass legislation anytime a regulatory body needs to address a specific issue or regulate some behavior (that presumably they already had the authority to regulate by the very nature of the agency being created). This _may_ be a regular case that naturally found its way into the legal system - but the 5th circuit has the history that it does and the targets of these lawsuits (SEC, EPA, etc) typically have deep-pocketed foes. [0] https://www.npr.org/2022/02/28/1082934438/supreme-court-to-hear-a-case-that-could-limit-the-epas-power-to-fight-climate-ch https://www.npr.org/2022/02/28/1082934438/supreme-court-to-h...
- xyzzyz 5y ago> On a basic level this seems to make sense but the practical application of this would mean that legislators would need to explicitly pass legislation anytime a regulatory body needs to address a specific issue or regulate some behavior Yeah, can you imagine the horror of making the congressmen actually do their job and pass the laws, instead of delegating all their authority to unelected, nameless, and effectively unaccountable bureaucrats, so that they have more time to spend on fundraising and campaigning? This will literally grind US into halt, and bring it to similar stagnation and stasis it was under before FDR.
- vkou 5y ago> Yeah, can you imagine the horror of making the congressmen actually do their job and pass the laws, instead of delegating all their authority to unelected, nameless, and effectively unaccountable bureaucrats 1. Those bureaucrats are appointed by the President, whom you vote for, and by Congress, whom you vote for, and may be fired by the former. If you don't like what the executive branch of the government looks like, I have great news for you - you elect your chief executive! And people you elect appoint his immediate underlings! 2. In 2022, I wouldn't hold my breath for congress to pass any laws. Half of congress governs under the explicit mandate that the people paying for their campaign should be above any law, and the other half governs under an implicit mandate to the same effect.
- seanw444 5y agoGet outta here ATF.
- PeterisP 5y ago> Should everyone fighting an immigration or deportation case be able to request a jury trial? Not necessarily - this judgement is about assigning a punishment for a violation, which would generally require a trial; but immigration courts usually decide cases where whatever they judge is not a punishment but rather granting or denying a privilege, so their decision is legally fundamentally different even if it results in a deportation.