7 ms·
Problem is, this applies "in reverse" to battery technology. Don't buy 1TW of storage today, buy 500MW and wait to see what's coming. Defensible, but possibly n
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Problem is, this applies "in reverse" to battery technology. Don't buy 1TW of storage today, buy 500MW and wait to see what's coming. Defensible, but possibly not what we actually need.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe jurisdictions buying storage today (California, Australia) are driving down the costs for those who will buy it tomorrow. As costs decline, the market expands, as storage paired with renewables (rapidly approaching $0.01/kWh at utility scale) is cheaper than existing thermal generation.
- MikeCapone 5y agoThe problem with battery supply is that it would be better to use that supply on EVs to displace oil rather than on massive stationary grid storage for intermittent sources. Instead, for the maximum cleaning up of energy, we should build nuclear for the grid and use batteries on transportation.
- ncmncm 5y agoDiverting money from renewables to nuclear brings climate disaster nearer. A dollar spent on renewables buys several times what a nuke could produce, and immediately, not ten years from now and buying fuel in the meantime. The money spent just on the fuel over that time would mostly pay for building the renewables.
- xbar 5y agoI see why you're saying that, but I'd love a reference that supports the per-dollar argument. Is it possible to just spend infinite dollars today and solve the climate crisis by tomorrow?
- ncmncm 5y agoWe are limited by the rate that manufacturing capacity can be scaled up, and then by the rate that product can be built out. I.e., it takes time to build factories. Spending more, you can get more factories, but they are not done sooner. A dollar can be spent on more factory, or on factory output. The factories you have so far can produce at some maximum rate. More factories than you expect to need later are hard to get financing for. Prices for big solar installations are in the public record. And for nukes. Recently North Carolina and Georgia spent, what, $15B for exactly 0 watts out. They were quoted another $10B to get the 2GW they had signed up for, which they had expected to pay, what, $8B for, total? They won't get any of it back. The corruption tax on nukes is withering. Nobody involved wants the money to ever stop flowing, as actually delivering would cause. The best I have seen for nukes is $2B/1GW, but nobody knows how to get that with any reliability; and that is discounted by a huge government disaster-insurance subsidy, and excludes ~$1B end-of-life decommissioning. I see $1B/1GW for recently finished solar projects, but prices are still falling fast.
- epistasis 5y agoFor the costs of nuclear, they are pretty abysmal, because it's a construction project and Western countries are terrible at construction logistics. One cost estimate: https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-of-energy-version-150-vf.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-o... Every year the cost of nuclear increases because we have fewer examples of successful construction and more examples of failed construction. The industry is in shambles, effectively dead. The US attempts at construction of AP1000s resulted in 2/4 failing, and the other two reactors being several multiples behind in schedule and pricing. The latest excuse for the failure is that they began construction before design was complete, so of course they failed. However this was the request of the nuclear industry, in an attempt to bring down prices, and the entire regulatory approval process was changed to accommodate this, which was supposed to bring down prices and prevent the failure of construction. Look at any attempt to build nuclear in a modern economy and you will find failure, not success. As for spending infinite dollars to solve climate change, no, that is not possible. There are real productive limits to capacity to build things. The solar, wind, and storage industries are growing at massive rates, but still its only barely enough to meet the speed needed for our energy transition. If we had infinite money to spend on nuclear, we still would not be able to build sufficient new restore by, say 2040. In the US alone we would need to build ~100 reactors simply to replace those reaching their end of life. We do not have the construction capacity for that, much less a design to build, or willing financial backers. For the foreseeable future, nuclear is a dying industry in the US, not because of regulation or public backlash, but because the industry can't build. The only hope for nuclear in the US or Europe is for small modular reactors, a design that in the past has been rejected for being too expensive. But since it's closer to manufacturing (like a plane) than like construction, there's hope, even if it's a long shot.
- pstuart 5y agoI'm totally pro-renewables but think that there's enough money out there so that it doesn't have to be an either/or scenario. Modular thorium reactors would be a huge win if realized.
- ncmncm 5y agoMoney is fungible. Money spent on nukes is unavailable for renewables. You need to watch some thorium debunking videos. I live near Indian Point, recently shut down. They tried thorium, early on. It cost too much. Every single thing about nukes costs too much.
- pstuart 5y agoBut that supply of money is not a single pool. I think of it as hedging bets. I skimmed the Indian Point reactor -- it appears to be a non-LFTR reactor, and that seems to be where the excitement continues. But yeah, renewables are great and only getting better. If we had taken a trillion dollars out of the fiasco of the Gulf Wars (ostensibly for "energy security") we could have done significant things. For example, I'm enamored with the possibilities of geothermal around the Yellowstone caldera -- if we could figure out how to do that without destroying the local environment.
- ncmncm 5y agoThere is some likelihood that geothermal can be made compatible with any locale, using new drilling tech. But geothermal is likely to remain substantially more expensive than solar and wind, whatever happens: steam turbines are expensive to maintain. It might win at latitudes above 50-60 degrees, if it can compete with ammonia imported from the tropics. But shipping is absurdly cheap.
- pstuart 5y agoThere's something to be said about having the energy sourced domestically, and it would make a nice baseload service. I believe that dealing with the waste water can be challenging but again, having a spectrum of energy source would be really nice. Rebuilding The Grid with HVDC would help too, as well as an ammonia economy to utilize excess power from wind. It all seems very technically doable, it's the politics and petrol people that stand between us and a carbon free energy ecosystem (well, with reasonable exceptions for aerospace and other special cases)
- bhuber 5y agoThis makes sense for lithium based batteries, but those aren't the only ones around. Iron flow batteries, for example, consist mainly of iron, salt, and water. There's no shortage of ingredients. They're too big and heavy to be practical for most transportation applications, but they have a number of desirable properties for utility-scale energy storage. https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1046365/grid-storage-iron-batteries-technology/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/23/1046365/grid-sto... is a pretty good writeup.
- mbjorkegren 5y agoHere’s another interesting one, storing energy in heated metal, and later converting the emitted light back to electricity using specialized PV cells: https://youtu.be/Gn7pfYKB7DA https://youtu.be/Gn7pfYKB7DA
- ncmncm 5y agoMolten metal batteries have the advantage of not wearing out, and of welcoming heat produced when charging.
- scythe 5y agoFlow batteries are pretty questionable. Moving parts suck. Zinc-bromine in particular was around for a long time as a flow technology but only started to move towards mass production when a non-flow version was developed. But in particular, the iron-flow battery story going around recently stinks pretty badly. It's being heavily promoted almost entirely by one company, ESS, and their first real client is -- wait for it -- SoftBank [1]. The academic reports on iron-flow batteries [2] make the technology sound a lot less mature than the ESS website [3], which incorrectly refers to vanadium and lithium as "rare-earth metals". A 2018 publication [4] from Narayan's group at USC boasts that: >Thus, by operating at 60°C and a pH of 3 with ascorbic acid and ammonium chloride, we achieved a coulombic efficiency of 97.9%. While this value of coulombic efficiency is among the highest values reported for the iron electrode in the context of the all-iron flow battery, further improvement in efficiency is needed for supporting repeated cycling. However, further work by Narayan's group led them to replace iron chloride by iron sulfate in 2020 [5] which was celebrated by USC in a press release [6]. It was shortly after this that ESS burst onto the scene claiming iron chloride batteries with extremely long cycle life using "carbon composite" electrodes, "porous polyethylene separator" and a "polypropene spacer" [3], which are suspiciously similar to the graphite electrodes, mesoporous hydrocarbon-polymer-not-disclosed (Tokuyama A901 [7]) anion-exchange membrane, and polypropylene housing used in the Narayan group's 2016 paper [8] proposing all-iron-flow batteries for grid storage. It's worth noting that chemically unmodified polyethylene is probably not a suitable material for an ion-selective membrane, but it wouldn't even be the second-worst mistake on the page. Yet ESS, despite having supposedly solved major problems that are obviously of scientific interest to active researchers, does not appear to have any names on its website, and cites no publications. Frankly, it sounds like another EEStor. 1: https://cleantechnica.com/2021/10/07/first-ess-iron-flow-battery-to-go-online-this-month/ https://cleantechnica.com/2021/10/07/first-ess-iron-flow-bat... 2: https://dornsife.usc.edu/labs/narayan/all-iron-redox-flow-battery/ https://dornsife.usc.edu/labs/narayan/all-iron-redox-flow-ba... 3: https://essinc.com/iron-flow-chemistry/ https://essinc.com/iron-flow-chemistry/ 4: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2451910319301577 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S245191031... 5: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/1945-7111/ab84f8/meta https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/1945-7111/ab84f8/... 6: https://news.usc.edu/166306/flow-battery-renewable-energy-electricity-storage-usc-study/ https://news.usc.edu/166306/flow-battery-renewable-energy-el... 7: https://watermark.silverchair.com/jeecs_18_2_024001.pdf https://watermark.silverchair.com/jeecs_18_2_024001.pdf 8: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/2.0161601jes/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1149/2.0161601jes/pdf
- epistasis 5y agoFor that matter, it would be good to prioritize EVs to those that drive the most, or have consistent long commutes. There has been some work on modding how well this could work for changing EV rebate incentives, but getting legislatures to adopt such complicated ideas is nearly impossible. Another approach would be to add a realistic, risk-adjusted carbon tax to gasoline (probably north of $200/ton co2, or $2/gallon gasoline) and let the market sort it out. Unfortunately when it comes to car purchasing, consumers are less economically rational than even legislators.
- nostrademons 5y agoIf you take a snapshot in time, maybe. Over the long term, any batteries sold are good batteries, because batteries exhibit large economies of scale. Profit on existing sales can fund new production facilities; incremental improvements in battery technology; R&D into capacity increases; improved distribution networks; R&D into new sources of lithium; and so on. The way you get dirt-cheap storage is to build lots of it.
- cycomanic 5y ago> The problem with battery supply is that it would be better to use that supply on EVs to displace oil rather than on massive stationary grid storage for intermittent sources. If your electricity generation is fossil moving to EVs is of questionable benefit. > Instead, for the maximum cleaning up of energy, we should build nuclear for the grid and use batteries on transportation. We are talking about solar power costs exponentially dropping and your suggestion is to build nuclear, the slowest to build and already much less economical than solar. By the time your nuclear power plants are build you could buy ~10 times the capacity in solar and likely would not need any battery storage.
- adrianN 5y agoEven if electricity generation is from coal, EVs produce less CO2 than ICEs, because big power plants are much more efficient than small engines. Plus all the other benefits they have, especially in cities.
- cycomanic 5y agoThis is quite disputed still, mainly because of the high weight of the batteries and the large energy cost of manufacturing these batteries. The studies I'm aware of, pretty much agree on that for 100% coal based electricity, ICEs are better, and for 100% renewables EVs are better. The dispute is at what percentage EVs become better.
- semi-extrinsic 5y agoOnce the energy storage demand follows the PV exponential curve a little longer, it will be obvious to everyone that batteries won't cut it, and you will see people starting to deploy stuff like hydrogen electrolysis and liquefaction for storage combined with hydrogen fired gas turbine powerplants. Several of the established players are close to achieving dry-low-NOx 100% hydrogen gas turbines. Then you are talking about >500 MW power per unit and a thermodynamic efficiency of >65%. If you are in the "extremely abundant but too variable renewable power" scenario, these things will be the major stabilisers. You can easily imagine smoothing out even seasonal fluctuations with them.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoYou are pricing battery storage in kWh but storage is measured in kW. $50-100 kW is "normal" for installed grid scale battery. There is no realistic way to GENERALLY determine the price of the kWh coming out of a grid scale battery due to the large number of variables, such as battery lifepan, wholesale production rates, land and permitting cost, etc.
- ncmncm 5y agoNot true. A battery stores kWh. kW is practically unlimited for utility-scale batteries. By contrast, many other storage methods have limits on kW, but may offer practically unlimited kWh. Some limit charging kW, but may be discharged at a higher rate. Short-term storage wants high charge and discharge rate, efficiency and durability. Longer-term storage mainly favors cheap capacity, and tolerates low charging rate and low efficiency.
- bagels 5y agokWh is a unit of energy measurement kW is a unit of power measurement Capacitors are capable of delivering high levels of power but have relatively small energy storage capacity compared to batteries. Grid scale batteries need to be sized in terms of both charge/discharge rates (kW/MW) and energy storage (kWh/MWh)
- nmeagent 5y agoStorage is measured in units of energy, i.e. something akin to Joules. Watts (and thus kW) are a measure of power, i.e. energy rate: 1 W is 1 Joule per second. kWh is a measure of energy (a kW for an hour) and is directly convertible to Joules. You could of course price based on energy discharge rate in kW, but not that alone...
- malchow 5y agoThat's right. Although (source: built Si battery company) the more powerful commercial trend is customers with arcane needs paving the way for architectures and chemistries that later can serve more general needs. Expensive NMC did make for cheaper NMC, but of course what actually happened is that Tesla and the automaker followed the lead of Enphase in switching over to LFP. In the more exotic architectures and chemistries, what's moving the needle is the exotic military or medical need, where the battery can be 10x more expensive on the OEM BOM and barely move the actual end unit price to the final user.
- gonzo41 5y agoWhat you really need is the government to be able to set a moving sliding window on battery performance, and then update tax regulation to allow companies to quickly depreciate an battery that gets outpaced fast and move onto the better tech. You'd ideally want to incentivise upgrades and updates for better tech in this space because of the positive externalities that come with it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 5y agoGenerally, storage just gets cheaper, not better. Storage bought early is just as good as something cheaper bought later. Its resale value has fallen, but not its usefulness. You will always be best off buying storage as late as you can get away with.
- FabHK 5y agoBattery tech improves rapidly in terms of energy stored per $, but much more slowly in terms of energy stored per m^3 of volume ("energy density", relevant for cars) and energy stored per kg of mass ("specific energy", relevant for planes).
- ncmncm 5y agoUntil averaged renewable generating capacity entirely matches averaged demand, money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels. It will be radically cheaper, soon enough. That is why so little storage is being built, thus far. Costs for storage are falling even faster than wind or solar ever did, because there is nothing to be overcome except limits on scaling manufacturing. The physics of energy storage, chemical schemes excepted, are a matter of freshman physics, so the drive is only how to apply the same principles more cheaply. Simplicity is the greatest virtue: if you can make a storage system with just one moving part, you have the makings of a winner. Many involve anchoring something to the sea floor: an air bladder with a hose to an air pump and turbine onshore, charged by pumping in air; a float with a cable down to a pulley, thence to a winch and motor/generator onshore, charged by dragging the float down to the bottom; an air tank with an electric pump/turbine just wired to shore, charged by evacuating the tank. The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever. But molten metal batteries have massive advantages over lithium, longevity and heat tolerance probably most important. Iron-air batteries are much cheaper. Hydrogen and ammonia synthesis will not be as cheap as the others, but have the massive advantage that, because tankage is cheap and transportable, storage capacity is unlimited; and when as much tankage as you care to keep is full, any extra generating capacity yields a high-demand product, thus extra revenue. Furthermore, if your local storage gets looking likely to run dry, you just buy more. Compatibility with existing natural gas generators is a plus; thus, compressed air, liquified nitrogen, hydrogen and ammonia. Burning something with compressed air increases efficiency. Energy Vault is bald grift, the Theranos of storage.
- NortySpock 5y ago'money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels' Huh? Why would you not charge your utility battery bank with surplus solar or wind power? Bonus: at the point when solar or wind power would be curtailed (when it is generating more supply than the grid demands), is also when the wholesale price per MWh is zero or negative, making it free or profitable to charge your batteries.
- idontwantthis 5y ago