7 ms·
This kind of thinking is something I internalised while doing 3D game engine development during the early era of hardware GPU cards. The growth curve was incred
by jiggawatts 5y ago
This kind of thinking is something I internalised while doing 3D game engine development during the early era of hardware GPU cards. The growth curve was incredible!
I learned quickly that the constants were the slopes of the best fit on a log graph. And that you could never intersect that curve with $today, you had to estimate your delivery date and use the intersection at that point for all planning. E.g.: vram budget for textures, polygon count limits, etc…
I’ve never seen this kind of thinking by management at any level, in any industry outside of computer game development.
I’ve tried explaining it to IT managers to no avail.
E.g.: don’t get a 10% discount now by buying 200 servers up front in a single sale! Buy 100 now at full price and 50 servers that are twice as powerful two years later.
Nope… got to get those sweet volume discounts…
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoProblem is, this applies "in reverse" to battery technology. Don't buy 1TW of storage today, buy 500MW and wait to see what's coming. Defensible, but possibly not what we actually need.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe jurisdictions buying storage today (California, Australia) are driving down the costs for those who will buy it tomorrow. As costs decline, the market expands, as storage paired with renewables (rapidly approaching $0.01/kWh at utility scale) is cheaper than existing thermal generation.
- MikeCapone 5y agoThe problem with battery supply is that it would be better to use that supply on EVs to displace oil rather than on massive stationary grid storage for intermittent sources. Instead, for the maximum cleaning up of energy, we should build nuclear for the grid and use batteries on transportation.
- ncmncm 5y agoDiverting money from renewables to nuclear brings climate disaster nearer. A dollar spent on renewables buys several times what a nuke could produce, and immediately, not ten years from now and buying fuel in the meantime. The money spent just on the fuel over that time would mostly pay for building the renewables.
- xbar 5y agoI see why you're saying that, but I'd love a reference that supports the per-dollar argument. Is it possible to just spend infinite dollars today and solve the climate crisis by tomorrow?
- ncmncm 4y agoWe are limited by the rate that manufacturing capacity can be scaled up, and then by the rate that product can be built out. I.e., it takes time to build factories. Spending more, you can get more factories, but they are not done sooner. A dollar can be spent on more factory, or on factory output. The factories you have so far can produce at some maximum rate. More factories than you expect to need later are hard to get financing for. Prices for big solar installations are in the public record. And for nukes. Recently North Carolina and Georgia spent, what, $15B for exactly 0 watts out. They were quoted another $10B to get the 2GW they had signed up for, which they had expected to pay, what, $8B for, total? They won't get any of it back. The corruption tax on nukes is withering. Nobody involved wants the money to ever stop flowing, as actually delivering would cause. The best I have seen for nukes is $2B/1GW, but nobody knows how to get that with any reliability; and that is discounted by a huge government disaster-insurance subsidy, and excludes ~$1B end-of-life decommissioning. I see $1B/1GW for recently finished solar projects, but prices are still falling fast.
- epistasis 4y agoFor the costs of nuclear, they are pretty abysmal, because it's a construction project and Western countries are terrible at construction logistics. One cost estimate: https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-of-energy-version-150-vf.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-o... Every year the cost of nuclear increases because we have fewer examples of successful construction and more examples of failed construction. The industry is in shambles, effectively dead. The US attempts at construction of AP1000s resulted in 2/4 failing, and the other two reactors being several multiples behind in schedule and pricing. The latest excuse for the failure is that they began construction before design was complete, so of course they failed. However this was the request of the nuclear industry, in an attempt to bring down prices, and the entire regulatory approval process was changed to accommodate this, which was supposed to bring down prices and prevent the failure of construction. Look at any attempt to build nuclear in a modern economy and you will find failure, not success. As for spending infinite dollars to solve climate change, no, that is not possible. There are real productive limits to capacity to build things. The solar, wind, and storage industries are growing at massive rates, but still its only barely enough to meet the speed needed for our energy transition. If we had infinite money to spend on nuclear, we still would not be able to build sufficient new restore by, say 2040. In the US alone we would need to build ~100 reactors simply to replace those reaching their end of life. We do not have the construction capacity for that, much less a design to build, or willing financial backers. For the foreseeable future, nuclear is a dying industry in the US, not because of regulation or public backlash, but because the industry can't build. The only hope for nuclear in the US or Europe is for small modular reactors, a design that in the past has been rejected for being too expensive. But since it's closer to manufacturing (like a plane) than like construction, there's hope, even if it's a long shot.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoYou are pricing battery storage in kWh but storage is measured in kW. $50-100 kW is "normal" for installed grid scale battery. There is no realistic way to GENERALLY determine the price of the kWh coming out of a grid scale battery due to the large number of variables, such as battery lifepan, wholesale production rates, land and permitting cost, etc.
- ncmncm 5y agoNot true. A battery stores kWh. kW is practically unlimited for utility-scale batteries. By contrast, many other storage methods have limits on kW, but may offer practically unlimited kWh. Some limit charging kW, but may be discharged at a higher rate. Short-term storage wants high charge and discharge rate, efficiency and durability. Longer-term storage mainly favors cheap capacity, and tolerates low charging rate and low efficiency.
- bagels 5y agokWh is a unit of energy measurement kW is a unit of power measurement Capacitors are capable of delivering high levels of power but have relatively small energy storage capacity compared to batteries. Grid scale batteries need to be sized in terms of both charge/discharge rates (kW/MW) and energy storage (kWh/MWh)
- nmeagent 5y agoStorage is measured in units of energy, i.e. something akin to Joules. Watts (and thus kW) are a measure of power, i.e. energy rate: 1 W is 1 Joule per second. kWh is a measure of energy (a kW for an hour) and is directly convertible to Joules. You could of course price based on energy discharge rate in kW, but not that alone...
- malchow 4y agoThat's right. Although (source: built Si battery company) the more powerful commercial trend is customers with arcane needs paving the way for architectures and chemistries that later can serve more general needs. Expensive NMC did make for cheaper NMC, but of course what actually happened is that Tesla and the automaker followed the lead of Enphase in switching over to LFP. In the more exotic architectures and chemistries, what's moving the needle is the exotic military or medical need, where the battery can be 10x more expensive on the OEM BOM and barely move the actual end unit price to the final user.
- gonzo41 5y agoWhat you really need is the government to be able to set a moving sliding window on battery performance, and then update tax regulation to allow companies to quickly depreciate an battery that gets outpaced fast and move onto the better tech. You'd ideally want to incentivise upgrades and updates for better tech in this space because of the positive externalities that come with it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ncmncm 5y agoGenerally, storage just gets cheaper, not better. Storage bought early is just as good as something cheaper bought later. Its resale value has fallen, but not its usefulness. You will always be best off buying storage as late as you can get away with.
- FabHK 5y agoBattery tech improves rapidly in terms of energy stored per $, but much more slowly in terms of energy stored per m^3 of volume ("energy density", relevant for cars) and energy stored per kg of mass ("specific energy", relevant for planes).
- ncmncm 5y agoUntil averaged renewable generating capacity entirely matches averaged demand, money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels. It will be radically cheaper, soon enough. That is why so little storage is being built, thus far. Costs for storage are falling even faster than wind or solar ever did, because there is nothing to be overcome except limits on scaling manufacturing. The physics of energy storage, chemical schemes excepted, are a matter of freshman physics, so the drive is only how to apply the same principles more cheaply. Simplicity is the greatest virtue: if you can make a storage system with just one moving part, you have the makings of a winner. Many involve anchoring something to the sea floor: an air bladder with a hose to an air pump and turbine onshore, charged by pumping in air; a float with a cable down to a pulley, thence to a winch and motor/generator onshore, charged by dragging the float down to the bottom; an air tank with an electric pump/turbine just wired to shore, charged by evacuating the tank. The overwhelming majority of storage will not be batteries, ever. But molten metal batteries have massive advantages over lithium, longevity and heat tolerance probably most important. Iron-air batteries are much cheaper. Hydrogen and ammonia synthesis will not be as cheap as the others, but have the massive advantage that, because tankage is cheap and transportable, storage capacity is unlimited; and when as much tankage as you care to keep is full, any extra generating capacity yields a high-demand product, thus extra revenue. Furthermore, if your local storage gets looking likely to run dry, you just buy more. Compatibility with existing natural gas generators is a plus; thus, compressed air, liquified nitrogen, hydrogen and ammonia. Burning something with compressed air increases efficiency. Energy Vault is bald grift, the Theranos of storage.
- NortySpock 5y ago'money spent on storage is mostly wasted, because to charge it up you would need to burn fossil fuels' Huh? Why would you not charge your utility battery bank with surplus solar or wind power? Bonus: at the point when solar or wind power would be curtailed (when it is generating more supply than the grid demands), is also when the wholesale price per MWh is zero or negative, making it free or profitable to charge your batteries.
- idontwantthis 5y ago
- _jal 5y ago> I’ve tried explaining it to IT managers to no avail. I've had this experience myself. I usually find that I was overlooking important inputs to, constraints on or goals behind the decision. > Buy 100 now at full price and 50 servers that are twice as powerful two years later As someone who buys a lot of hardware for my employer, I can tell you that performance is only one of several interrelated considerations that goes in to purchasing decisions, and is far from the most important. For that matter, exactly the same thing can be said about the price.
- nuclearnice3 5y agoIf not performance and not price, what considerations are close to the most important for your employer?
- kaptain 5y agoReliability, compatibility, political considerations (eg we partner with this brand)
- jiggawatts 5y agoReliability hasn't changed significantly for server-grade kit for decades. All Intel-compatible servers have been essentially perfectly compatible with each other for decades. All major brands will keep selling server kit. It's not like you have to throw away your IBM brand Intel-based servers and replace them with ARM chips from some no-name vendor! My point is that in next year and the year after, and the year after that IBM will sell you faster and faster servers. Also... bigger and bigger. At roughly the same price point. With largely (if not entirely) compatible management systems, drivers, etc... Speaking of drivers: VMware and similar hypervisors have almost completely eliminated driver compatibility as a concern. Clusters can contain wildly different gear without issues. There's a lack of understanding in the industry by older managers that gained their experience in the "before times" when even the firmware had to be consistent for a cluster of servers. For example, the local budget airline Jetstar would buy used servers from Ebay. Why? Why not! Why would you need "support" if a server dies? It is stateless (diskless!) and just 1% of your capacity! Just throw it out. Why would you care about driver updates if all of your VMs are using emulated hypervisor drivers only? Why would you care if a server is "used" if chips don't "wear out"? Etc...
- nostrademons 5y ago"And that you could never intersect that curve with $today, you had to estimate your delivery date and use the intersection at that point for all planning." Otherwise known as "Skate to where the puck will be, not where it has been. -- Wayne Gretzky." This is fairly common in other software-related industries, eg. mobile. Uber was not physically possible when the company was founded in 2008 - most phones didn't have GPS, and when they did, it drained the battery too quickly for the phone to charge from a car. Same with Whatsapp's founding in 2009 - the push notifications that let it catch on weren't actually available until a year after the product first came out. I know a number of Silicon Valley drone transportation companies that know their product isn't feasible today, but are betting on improvements in battery technology. Oftentimes the market (and underlying technology) pivots into the startup, the startup doesn't pivot into the market. Many of the big pandemic successes like Zoom, Toast, Marco Polo, Peloton, etc. already existed before the pandemic, they just happened to luck out when everybody got shut up at home.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoThis is obviously very common for logic design and silicon manufacturing. They frequently design for technology that does not exist yet. I don't quite understand what you think is missing though, every industry and company I've had experience with has forecast things and planned based on some estimated intersection of many moving parts. The thermal coal industry has to forecast electricity demand, competition, coal demand, coal prices, building and mining prices, regulatory environment, etc. to build and operate mines and power plants., out to about 50 years. I don't know how much renewables have really caught the industry off guard, but rapid advancements in technology has caused many to come unstuck, especially those in the technology industry (Nvidia et al killed SGI, Intel killed DEC and Sun, and so on). It's not that it's just renewables catching the old dinosaurs off guard here, it's going both ways because energy is obviously very volatile and highly complex. The Moore's law era gains in transistor performance and density were obviously vastly larger changes but they were actually very consistent and easy to predict by comparison, some guy can't remember his name now even made up a trivial formula for it that held up extremely well for 50 years! With a few relatively minor tweaks. In contrast there have been proclamations for many years now that wind and solar have killed coal. That the price points have crossed over, that coal is dead and coal infrastructure is a worthless asset. Today, thermal coal prices are at historic record highs. Someone is buying it and someone is making a killing digging it up. And a lot of executives are kicking themselves for divesting at the bottom of the market thinking it was worthless except for the free kudos they thought it would get them boasting about something they were going to do for financial reasons anyway. It's hardly anything to boast about predicting silicon device improvements when others struggle to predict energy markets.